Microsoft patents Sudo

By Elliott
in Back Page News

 Share

Recommended Posts

Grand Master

Elliott

Posted
  • Author
Posted
As far as I know there is no way to configure sudo to present the user with a list of users with the appropriate rights. Sudo only lets you manually substitute from a pre-defined list of users.

No, they are patenting only their version that automatically looks up users with the appropriate rights. As far as I know Sudo cannot do this, nor can any frontends for it.

That'd be all well and good (insofar as a vague software patent like this can be), except that's not where it ends.

Although the invention has been described in language specific to structural features and/or methodological steps, it is to be understood that the invention defined in the appended claims is not necessarily limited to the specific features or steps described. Rather, the specific features and steps are disclosed as preferred forms of implementing the claimed invention.

That's from the end of the patent. With that statement, they've basically been given the patent to rights elevators of just about any form as long as it's some GUI.

Grand Master

Ricardo Gil

Posted
Posted
Software patents are evil anyway. This is just one more example of why they need to be abolished.

Abolishing software patents would be disastrous. What we need is a complete reboot of the patenting process, so that the usual abuse of it stops.

Grand Master

hdood

Posted
Posted
That's from the end of the patent. With that statement, they've basically been given the patent to rights elevators of just about any form as long as it's some GUI.

No, it is still limited to the specific invention, they can just change the design and implementation a bit instead of being tied to the exact one described in the application (which includes detailed screenshots and drawings, and point by point details of a specific implementation). It does not seem to give them the rights to elevation in general.

Grand Master

BajiRav

Posted
Posted
There's no significant difference between what Microsoft is trying to patent and the sudo authentication. We're not talking about the command that is used in UNIX here, nor the graphical interface for it, but the process and method that is used. Microsoft is trying to patent all of that and justifies it by including a graphical interface that lists a number of users.

How many times have we seen this? Copy something then develop and add new features. Finally patent it.

ICQ/AIM - MSN messenger

Netscape - Internet Explorer

(...)

So Netscape invented a browser? Thanks for just-because-it's-Microsoft-it-must-be-evil-comment of the day.

Grand Master

Lechio

Posted
Posted
So Netscape invented a browser? Thanks for just-because-it's-Microsoft-it-must-be-evil-comment of the day.

No I didn't say that, Netscape didn't invent the Web browser. Microsoft copied the way Netscape worked and bundled it with Windows OS, same as there MSN messenger, Windows Media Player...

Adopt > "improve" > patent > extinguish > lock-down.

Grand Master

Eric Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted
No I didn't say that, Netscape didn't invent the Web browser. Microsoft copied the way Netscape worked and bundled it with Windows OS, same as there MSN messenger, Windows Media Player...

Adopt > "improve" > patent > extinguish > lock-down.

Internet Explorer was purchased from Spyglass. It predates Netscape, which was also bought from another company: Mosaic. Microsoft actually tried to license Netscape but they apparently weren't interested. Oops. Firefox could've been the Windows default browser. :)

Grand Master

Rudy

Posted
Posted
Internet Explorer was purchased from Spyglass. It predates Netscape, which was also bought from another company: Mosaic. Microsoft actually tried to license Netscape but they apparently weren't interested. Oops. Firefox could've been the Windows default browser. :)

I bet at one point they regretted that move... lol

Community Regular

Eice

Posted
Posted
No I didn't say that, Netscape didn't invent the Web browser. Microsoft copied the way Netscape worked and bundled it with Windows OS, same as there MSN messenger, Windows Media Player...

Adopt > "improve" > patent > extinguish > lock-down.

For your own sake, I hope you aren't serious.

You're not really that ignorant... right?

Grand Master

Lechio

Posted
Posted
Internet Explorer was purchased from Spyglass. It predates Netscape, which was also bought from another company: Mosaic. Microsoft actually tried to license Netscape but they apparently weren't interested. Oops. Firefox could've been the Windows default browser. :)

Yeah. I think you forgot that at that time Netscape was far from resembling anything like Mosaic, with all the innovations that were made and then "adopted" by Microsoft. Eh, I think you even forget that tabbed browsing in IE is something that was copied only recently. :rofl:

Grand Master

Growled Member

Posted
  • Member
Posted
Abolishing software patents would be disastrous. What we need is a complete reboot of the patenting process, so that the usual abuse of it stops.

Either way, there needs to be a fundamental change in the way patents are extended. This is so stupid.

Grand Master

Subject Delta

Posted
Posted
Yeah. I think you forgot that at that time Netscape was far from resembling anything like Mosaic, with all the innovations that were made and then "adopted" by Microsoft. Eh, I think you even forget that tabbed browsing in IE is something that was copied only recently. :rofl:

People copy each other's ideas all the time, in every industry. It isn't new, and you are trolling for the sake of it because it is Microsoft. If you look through any Linux distribution, you will find ideas not original to Linux. Same for OSX, Windows, Solaris, ETC...

Grand Master

hdood

Posted
Posted
If Microsoft can patent thing that they never invented, why not?

Can you tell us where Microsoft's "invention" is already implemented? Don't say sudo, because sudo doesn't do what the patent describes (and the people who approved the patent and who studied sudo as part of the approval process don't seem to think so either.)

Grand Master

Lechio

Posted
Posted
People copy each other's ideas all the time, in every industry. It isn't new, and you are trolling for the sake of it because it is Microsoft. If you look through any Linux distribution, you will find ideas not original to Linux. Same for OSX, Windows, Solaris, ETC...

Yes, but answer this will you Frank: do you see the "FOSS guys" (as you call people who contribute to Free Software) behaving like Microsoft and even going to the point of selling patents to others to create problems?

The US "Software Patents" laws are absurd as they exist now. It does nothing but hold back development.

You don't live in the US should understand this, and be more informed of what your own country defends on this matter.

Grand Master

Eric Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted
Yeah. I think you forgot that at that time Netscape was far from resembling anything like Mosaic, with all the innovations that were made and then "adopted" by Microsoft. Eh, I think you even forget that tabbed browsing in IE is something that was copied only recently. :rofl:

Maybe you should read up on computer history and the browser wars? :) It's kinda irrelevant whether Netscape resembled Mosaic or not. Spyglass licensed Mosaic, Microsoft bought Spyglass, Netscape was started by the former Mosaic people. Both browsers came from the same source, so nobody ripped anyone off.

Several companies licensed Mosaic to create their own commercial browsers, such as Spry Mosaic and Spyglass Mosaic. One of the Mosaic developers, Marc Andreessen, founded Mosaic Communications Corporation and created a new web browser named Mosaic Netscape. To resolve legal issues with NCSA, the company was renamed Netscape Communications Corporation and the browser Netscape Navigator. The Netscape browser improved on Mosaic's usability and reliability and was able to display pages as they loaded. By 1995, helped by the fact that it was free for non-commercial use, the browser dominated the emerging World Wide Web.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Browser_wars

Also, many Linux distributions are compiled and distributed by corporations now. Kinda breaks the anti-corporate free mentality to me. I guarantee you that Canonical and Red Hat would sue each other over stealing each others' non-open additions.

EDIT: They do exactly that: http://www.linux.com/archive/feature/120117

Grand Master

Lechio

Posted
Posted

You forgot to continue the story:

And then came Microsoft with IE which copied all of the innovations made by Netscape and eventually bundled it with its Windows OS.

Later on came the EU with a big stick... And you know the rest of the story... :)

EDIT: They do exactly that: http://www.linux.com/archive/feature/120117

But you know why that happens, it's explained in that page.

Grand Master

Eric Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted
You forgot to continue the story:

And then came Microsoft with IE which copied all of the innovations made by Netscape and eventually bundled it with its Windows OS.

Later on came the EU with a big stick... And you know the rest of the story... :)

But you know why that happens, it's explained in that page.

The "story" is right there in my previous post and in the Wikipedia article. Microsoft did not "come with IE." They licensed the same exact browser engine that Netscape used. The story is no different than the WebKit one. WebKit came from Konquerer and is now used in multiple browsers.

Grand Master

Lechio

Posted
Posted
The "story" is right there in my previous post and in the Wikipedia article. Microsoft did not "come with IE." They licensed the same exact browser engine that Netscape used. The story is no different than the WebKit one. WebKit came from Konquerer and is now used in multiple browsers.

It's quite different indeed, when you talk about what a Web browser was right after Mosaic and what it became after Netscape implemented all of their innovations, later copied by Microsoft. I'm not against copying features (quite the contrary), I'm against copying features, then "improve" them and make it proprietary based on a stupid, ambiguous, senseless US patent "law".

This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Posts

    • Display Driver Uninstaller (DDU) 18.1.5.5

      By Copernic · Posted

      Display Driver Uninstaller (DDU) 18.1.5.5 by Razvan Serea Display Driver Uninstaller (DDU) is a utility for completely removing AMD/NVIDIA/INTEL graphics drivers and related packages from your system, attempting to eliminate all leftovers (including registry entries, folders and files, driver store). Though AMD/NVIDIA/INTEL drivers can usually be removed via the Windows Control Panel, this uninstaller tool was created for situations where standard uninstall fails, or when you need to fully remove NVIDIA or ATI graphics card drivers. After using this driver cleaner, your system will behave as though it’s the first time you’re installing a new driver—similar to a fresh Windows installation. As with all such tools, we recommend creating a restore point beforehand, allowing you to undo changes if issues arise. If you're having trouble installing an older or newer driver, try it—there are reports that it resolves such problems. Recommended usage: The tool can be used in Normal mode but for absolute stability when using DDU, Safemode is always the best. Make a backup or a system restore (but it should normally be pretty safe). It is best to exclude the DDU folder completely from any security software to avoid issues. You do NOT need to uninstall the driver prior using DDU. Requirements: .NET Framework 4.8 Compatible with Windows 7, 8, 8.1, 10, and 11 (32-bit or 64-bit) Note: Using on Insider Preview builds is at your own risk. Display Driver Uninstaller (DDU) 18.1.5.5 changelog: Added 'Reset to recommended' button for the Options. General fixes and improvements. Download: Display Driver Uninstaller (DDU) 18.1.5.5 | 1.7 MB (Freeware) Download: DDU Portable | 1.2 MB Links: Display Driver Uninstaller Home Page | Screenshot Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • WACUP 1.99.51.24568 Preview

      By Copernic · Posted

      WACUP 1.99.51.24568 Preview by Razvan Serea WACUP (WinAmp Community Update Project) is a modern, enhanced version of the classic Winamp music player, designed for better stability, performance, and compatibility. Built for Windows, WACUP retains the familiar Winamp interface while adding 64-bit support, bug fixes, and new features like improved audio format support, customizable skins, and optimized playlist management. Unlike bloated alternatives, WACUP focuses on lightweight performance and regular updates, making it the best choice for fans of the classic Winamp experience. Basically, if you miss the good old days of Winamp and want a modern upgrade that doesn’t mess things up, WACUP is for you! WACUP key features: Classic Winamp Feel – Keeps the familiar interface and functionality. Bug Fixes & Stability – Fixes old Winamp issues and improves performance. 64-Bit Support – Works better on modern systems. More Formats & Plugins – Supports additional audio formats and third-party plugins. Customizable UI – Skins and tweaks for a personalized look. Better Library Management – Improved playlists, media organization, and search. No Bloat – Focuses on performance without unnecessary extras. Regular Updates – Community-driven development with new features and fixes. WACUP 1.99.51.24568 Preview changelog: Fixed a deadlock seen from the recent crash reports when doing some of the drag + drop actions within the media library window Fixed a loading crash seen related to a problem with some of the artwork cache image files being restored which should now be better handled allowing for the bad image to be removed without it failing Fixed a deadlock seen from the recent crash reports when the internal metadata cache clearing is triggered which could block the main ui thread for too long with this now being moved to a background thread Fixed some performance issues with some of the methods related to determining artwork support which mainly affected the local library import / refresh (this is still slower for some compared to other players because there's more data & artwork aspects being checked for which means doing more processing on a single file despite the best of attempts to reduce duplicate / heavy processing where possible) Fixed a crash with the JTFE based missing files hotkey which no one seems to have used for an age for this to appear (maybe it's time to seriously consider stripping out features that aren't being used) Fixed how some of the file types which use extra information to reference their sub-songs is handled which was preventing some from being correctly resolved back to their base file (noticed fixing above) Fixed an issue with the handling of files with underscores in their filepath which wasn't being correctly handled causing some of the filename to be lost when shown as the title if title reading is delayed Fixed a few things that might be behind NotSoDirect not being stable for some setups though am still not certain that the changes done for this are going to fully resolve the problem from the crash reports Fixed the OS toast handling when there's no prior shortcut in the OS start menu to now create the shortcut (needed to allow the yes/no buttons for the new build / post-release toast) to be done as a hidden one so it's less likely to cause annoyance for those not wanting to see it whilst still allowing this less than ideal OS api implementation requirement to be met to avoid toasts without the needed buttons Fixed a regression when moving from taglib1 to taglib2 which broke some of the handling in place to allow for external programs to still access files when wacup has a held open cached instance of the file Everything else Updated cppwinrt (gen_win10shell.dll) to 3.0.260520.1 (26 May 2026) Updated libcurl (libcurl.dll) to 8.2.1 (24 Jun 2026) Updated Monkey's Audio (in_ape.dll) to 13.15 (28 Jun 2026) Updated mpg123 (mpg123.dll) to 1.33.6 (6 Jun 2026) Updated OpenSSL (libcurl.dll) to 3.5.7 (9 Jun 2026) Updated pugixml to 1.16 (16 Jun 2026) Updated taglib (tag2.dll) to 2.3.0 (11 May 2026) Updated vgmstream (in_vgmstream.dll) to the latest Git commit from 28 Jun 2026 Download: WACUP 64-bit | 9.6 MB (Freeware) Download: WACUP 32-bit View: WACUP Website | Screenshots Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • Dbrand thought they could get away with this Steam Machine case, Valve disagreed

      By Doli · Posted

      "over a thousand engineering hours" and started selling it but could not take a couple of minuets to send an AI email to ask permission. What an expensive lesson.
    • Can't access the forum on mobile

      By WITHOUT-ME · Posted

      just tested it yesterday, a simple page with autoloading ADS takes 60mb....just 1 page for 60 megabytes.   poor people with a limited internet never will visit neolose
    • Tor Browser 15.0.17

      By Copernic · Posted

      Tor Browser 15.0.17 by Razvan Serea Protect your privacy. Defend yourself against network surveillance and traffic analysis. Tor is a network of virtual tunnels that allows people and groups to improve their privacy and security on the Internet. The Tor software protects you by bouncing your communications around a distributed network of relays run by volunteers all around the world: it prevents somebody from watching your Internet connection and learning what sites you visit, it prevents the sites you visit from learning your physical location, and it lets you access sites which are blocked. The Tor Browser Bundle lets you use Tor on Windows, Mac OS X, or Linux without needing to install any software. It can run off a USB flash drive, comes with a pre-configured web browser to protect your anonymity, and is self-contained. Tor Browser 15.0.17 changelog: All Platforms Updated Tor to 0.4.9.11 Updated NoScript to 13.6.25.1984 Build System / All Platforms Bug tor-browser-build#41821: Update gpg subkeys for boklm Bug tor-browser-build#41827: Update morgan's keychain with renewed key Download: Tor Browser (64-bit) | Tor Browser (32-bit) | 109.0 MB (Open Source) View: Tor Browser Website | Other Operating Systems Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware

  • Recent Achievements

    • Reacting Well
      Wakeen1966 earned a badge
      Reacting Well
    • Rookie
      Almohandis went up a rank
      Rookie
    • Apprentice
      jahara21 went up a rank
      Apprentice
    • Reacting Well
      NovaEdgeX earned a badge
      Reacting Well
    • Week One Done
      NovaEdgeX earned a badge
      Week One Done

  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      530
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      266
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      148
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      99
    5. 5
      macoman
      55
    Show More

  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!