HBO's Game of Thrones

By Rappy
in The Media Room

 Share

Recommended Posts

Grand Master

spacer

Posted
Posted

Not really. The books are more gruesome with a few exceptions like the pregnant stabbing or Oberyn's death, but I suppose some readers might lack imagination.

It's a joke, and you mentioned two examples of how said joke is relevant. /boggle

Veteran

Luc2k

Posted
Posted

It's a joke, and you mentioned two examples of how said joke is relevant. /boggle

Of course it's a joke, just not a very good one when there's only two examples in 4 seasons. Actually the Red Wedding is the only example since Oberyn's death is as gruesome, just different. And speaking of the Red Wedding there's a part of gruesome missing, Catelyn going insane and scratching her own face off before her throat is slit.

Grand Master

sharpy2k4

Posted
Posted

Damn it, they killed

Pyp and Grenn. In the books they're both alive and Donal Noye (the one armed blacksmith of Castle Black) is the one that kills and dies with Mag the Mighty (the giant in the tunnel).

Good focused episode overall with no talks of beetles.

 

One thing they ######ed up in a major way (book and possibly E10 spoilers):

Where the ###### was Stannis. He's supposed to be the one that crushes the wildlings on the north side of the wall.

 

pretty sure in the books they hold out over night like in the show, then Snow talks to them and while that happens Stannis comes in a few days and wipes them all out, im 99% sure it didn't happen on the first day/night.

 

Also, that episode took a big number 2 over the battle of helmsdeep in LOTR. 

Veteran

Luc2k

Posted
Posted

pretty sure in the books they hold out over night like in the show, then Snow talks to them and while that happens Stannis comes in a few days and wipes them all out, im 99% sure it didn't happen on the first day/night.

 

Also, that episode took a big number 2 over the battle of helmsdeep in LOTR. 

You're right, this happens when Jon meets with Mance so I guess it's going to take place at the start of the next episode. The circumstances of Jon going to assassinate Mance is completely different on the other hand and you have to admit, the attack on the north was pretty anaemic (or am I misremembering stuff again).

 

I liked the sword fighting a lot, none of that fast cuts bullcrap.

Grand Master

simplezz

Posted
Posted
One thing they ######ed up in a major way (book and possibly E10 spoilers):

Where the ###### was Stannis. He's supposed to be the one that crushes the wildlings on the north side of the wall.

I thought

Stannis came after Jon had gone to parley with Mance

. Assuming that's what's going to happen next episode.

 

What I'm really looking forward to is

Tyrion getting his revenge on Shay and Tywin

. As well as reading Feast for Crows later this month :D

Veteran

Luc2k

Posted
Posted

I thought

Stannis came after Jon had gone to parley with Mance

. Assuming that's what's going to happen next episode.

 

What I'm really looking forward to is

Tyrion getting his revenge on Shay and Tywin

. As well as reading Feast for Crows later this month :D

Yeah, I got the order of events mixed up.

The look on Tywin's face should make that extremely satisfying, but want I'm most looking forward to is Jaimie telling Tyrion the truth about his first wife.

Grand Master

MorganX

Posted
Posted

pretty sure in the books they hold out over night like in the show, then Snow talks to them and while that happens Stannis comes in a few days and wipes them all out, im 99% sure it didn't happen on the first day/night.

 

Also, that episode took a big number 2 over the battle of helmsdeep in LOTR.

But nothing beats the Giants in GoT. Pretty Awesome for a TV show.

Grand Master

simplezz

Posted
Posted

Yeah, I got the order of events mixed up.

The look on Tywin's face should make that extremely satisfying, but want I'm most looking forward to is Jaimie telling Tyrion the truth about his first wife.

Yeah that should be an interesting interaction.

Initially when I read it and what follows in the book, I thought Jamie was lying in order to provoke Tyrion into killing Tywin.

I guess I won't find out until I read Feast for crows.

Grand Master

Draconian Guppy

Posted
Posted

Freak'n amazing episode. Loved the whole thing...... That ending though. Now Jon will need to gather the 7 dragon balls... oh wait, I'm mixing shows up again.

:laugh:

Yeah

 

Didn't expect Jons wildling gf to get killed, but I guess EVERYONE dies in a song of fire and ice eh?

 

Grand Master

Rappy Veteran

Posted
  • Author
  • Veteran
Posted

Not that I don't enjoy this but aren't you behind now?  Episode 8 was 2 weeks ago and episode 9 was a couple of days ago.

Yeah but the pictures got released yesterday in Hi-Res might be someone that might be interested in them :)

the rest of 9

dR4FDYFc.jpg 4rjHnapz.jpg 2GwX3qtl.jpg sMukmOQc.jpg vSQ1sjbZ.jpg ZIorWyh6.jpg EQZc5WL7.jpg

Grand Master

MorganX

Posted
Posted

Yeah but the pictures got released yesterday in Hi-Res might be someone that might be interested in them :)

the rest of 9

dR4FDYFc.jpg 4rjHnapz.jpg 2GwX3qtl.jpg sMukmOQc.jpg vSQ1sjbZ.jpg ZIorWyh6.jpg EQZc5WL7.jpg

The Giants, Awesome.

What ever happened to the 2 hr. Season Finale?

Grand Master

MorganX

Posted
Posted

What are you talking about?

This show needs a 2hr finale. Finale's used to go 2 hrs.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing