Samsung Wins U.K. Apple Ruling Over


Recommended Posts

Samsung Wins U.K. Apple Ruling Over ?Not as Cool? Galaxy Tab

Samsung Electronics Co. (005930) won a legal ruling after a U.K. judge said its Galaxy tablets aren?t ?cool? enough to be confused with Apple Inc. (AAPL)?s iPad.

The design for three Galaxy tablets doesn?t infringe Apple?s registered design, Judge Colin Birss said today in London in a court fight between the world?s two biggest makers of smartphones. Consumers aren?t likely to get the tablet computers mixed up, he said.

The Galaxy tablets ?do not have the same understated and extreme simplicity which is possessed by the Apple design,? Birss said. ?They are not as cool.?

Apple is fighting patent lawsuits around the globe against rivals including HTC Corp. (2498) and Samsung as it competes for dominance of the smartphone and tablet computer markets. The firms have accused each other of copying designs and technology in mobile devices. Together, Samsung and Apple make more than half of the smartphones sold worldwide, according to IDC, a Framingham, Massachusetts-based market researcher.

Samsung said the judgment affirms its position that the Galaxy doesn?t infringe Apple?s design rights.

?Should Apple continue to make excessive legal claims in other countries based on such generic designs, innovation in the industry could be harmed and consumer choice unduly limited,? Suwon, South Korea-based Samsung said in an e-mailed statement.

Unusual Details

?It?s no coincidence that Samsung?s latest products look a lot like the iPhone and iPad,? Apple spokesman Alan Hely said in an e-mailed statement that didn?t specifically address the ruling. ?This kind of blatant copying is wrong and, as we?ve said many times before, we need to protect Apple?s intellectual property.?

Samsung asked the U.K. court to rule that its Galaxy tablets weren?t too similar to products created by the late Apple co-founder Steve Jobs and design chief Jonathan Ive, according to today?s judgment. Apple filed a counter-claim.

The judge found that Samsung?s products were distinctive because they were thinner and had ?unusual details? on the back. He gave Apple 21 days to appeal.

Apple, based in Cupertino, California, has sought court orders in the U.S., Germany, the Netherlands and elsewhere seeking to block Samsung from selling its tablets.

Samsung has been ordered to stop selling its Galaxy Tab 10.1 in the U.S. until a patent-infringement trial can be held. An order that it also stop selling its newest Galaxy Nexus smartphone was temporarily put on hold last week while an appeals court considers Samsung?s petition to have the ban lifted.

The case is Samsung Electronics (UK) Limited & Anr v. Apple Inc., High Court of Justice, Chancery Division, HC11C03050.

Source: Bloomberg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That sounds like an odd tagline on which to win an argument :laugh:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

LOL, I'm pretty sure "coolness" is a matter of opinion. Just glad this judge's opinion was enough to sway this lawsuit in the right direction, even if Samsung is left going "wtf?"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This topic is now closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Similar Content

    • By zikalify
      Apple taps Prince William to close season 2 of Time to Walk
      by Paul Hill

      Apple has announced that Prince William will be the guest on the next episode of Time to Walk. The 38-minute episode will close the second season of the series on December 6 and it’ll focus on keeping mentally fit, an issue Prince William has discussed at length publicly.

      According to Apple, he will discuss a time when he was taken out of his comfort zone, the importance of listening as a way to empower others, and an experience he had that caused him to prioritise mental health. Prince William has chosen three mental health charities to which Apple has said it will be making donations; they include Crisis Text Line in the U.S., Shout 85258 in the UK, and Lifeline in Australia.

      The Time to Walk episodes are available in the Workout app on Apple Watch with a Fitness+ subscription, however, there will be three special audio airings of Prince William’s Time to Walk episode featuring just the stories and music. These specials will stream for free on the Apple Music 1 radio station on Apple Music.

      Giving the times you’ll need to tune in, Apple said:

      Fitness+ is available in Australia, Austria, Brazil, Canada, Colombia, France, Germany, Indonesia, Ireland, Italy, Malaysia, Mexico, New Zealand, Portugal, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Spain, Switzerland, the UAE, the UK, and the U.S. Meanwhile, Apple Music 1 can be listened to in 165 countries and regions, and streams to iPhone, iPad, Apple TV, Mac, Apple Watch, iPod touch, CarPlay, popular smart TVs, smart speakers, and Android and Windows devices, or online at

    • By zikalify
      Gartner expects fewer people will opt-out of personalised mobile app ads by 2023
      by Paul Hill

      The analyst firm, Gartner, has released an interesting prediction which we could see in 2023. It said that the opt-out rate for mobile app tracking will decline from 85% to 60% as consumers experience more untargeted ads.

      With Apple rolling out more ways to opt-out of ad tracking in mobile apps, fewer people are being shown relevant ads. Gartner believes, however, that consumers can be persuaded to opt-in to tracking especially if they trust the brand or publisher requesting tracking. Explaining this a bit more, Andrew Frank, vice president and analyst in the Gartner Marketing practice, said:

      Gartner has outlined several methods that marketers could and will likely try to boost opt-in rates when it comes to mobile ad tracking. First, it said that customers need a compelling reason to opt-in and it should be made clear to them what tangible value opting in provides them with. Secondly, it should be easy for customers to change their privacy settings so they can opt-out at any time. Finally, Gartner said that marketers should work with publishers to optimise contextual targeting and measurement in the absence of tracking data.

      Google, one of the largest advertisers online, has already begun using some of these tips. For a while now, it has made a point of communicating to customers that at no point is their data sold on to third-parties. This sort of messaging can help build trust which should lead to more people opting in to tracking.

      It’s certainly a hot topic anyway and Gartner's prediction is a little surprising. It’ll be interesting to see whether it comes to fruition.

    • By zikalify
      Apple reveals its customers have raised $270 million since 2006 to fight AIDS
      by Paul Hill

      Marking World AIDS Day today, Apple has revealed that since 2006, its customers have helped raise $270 million to fund prevention, testing, and counselling services for people affected by HIV/AIDS. Now, the company has announced several other actions its taking to raise more money and help raise awareness of the issue.

      To help raise more money for (RED), Apple said that it has been offering a range of devices where a portion of the proceeds are donated to tackle AIDS. These devices include iPhone 13 (PRODUCT)RED, iPhone 13 mini (PRODUCT)RED, and Apple Watch Series 7 (PRODUCT)RED. Until the end of next year, half of the eligible proceeds will be directed to Global Fund’s COVID-19 Response to help fight that disease.

      In addition to selling (PRODUCT)RED devices, Apple will donate $1 to the Global Fund between now and December 6 for every purchase made with Apple Pay on, in the Apple Store app, or at an Apple Store. The firm is also introducing six new Apple Watch faces that can be downloaded here. While they can be used on any Apple Watch, Apple designed them with the Apple Watch Series 7 (PRODUCT)RED in mind.

      On the software side of things, the Apple App Store will highlight Positive Singles, a dating app that aims to connect singles living with HIV/AIDS and other STIs. Apple Books will feature collections of books and audiobooks that address the fight against HIV/AIDS, Apple Podcasts will feature shows addressing the issue, and Apple Music will carry a feature in recognition of World AIDS Day. Apple TV app users can also head to the Watch Now tabs to see shows and movies about ‘the human cost of the HIV/AIDS epidemic.’

    • By zikalify
      Samsung unveils the Galaxy A13 5G, due to launch in the U.S. on December 3 for $250
      by Paul Hill

      Samsung has announced that it’s planning to launch the Galaxy A13 5G in the United States on December 3 with an affordable price tag of $249.99. Like other mid-rangers, the Galaxy A13 5G packs a huge 5,000 mAh battery so you’ll get a full day’s use, but this phone is also nice because it allows you to get on board with 5G at a reasonable price point.

      With such a big battery, it would normally take a while to charge up with a standard charging connection but luckily this device supports 15W fast charging meaning you can get the battery full in minutes, rather than hours. In addition, it packs a triple-lens camera, an edge-to-edge display, and Samsung’s ‘defense-grade’ Knox Security.

      The full specifications for the new phone are as follows:


      6.5" HD+ LCD
      720 x 1600
      90Hz (Adaptive) Dimensions


      164.5 x 76.5 x 8.8mm
      95g Camera (Front Camera)
      5MP, F2.0

      (Rear Camera)
      Main: 50MP, F1.8
      Macro Camera: 2MP, F2.4
      Depth Camera: 2MP, F2.4 AP MTK Dimensity 700
      Octa-core (2 x 2.2Ghz + 6 x 2.0Ghz) Storage 64GB (4 GB RAM)
      External Memory up to 1TB Battery 5,000 (mAh, Typical)

      Charging 15W (Fast Charge)

      OS Android 11

      Network & Connectivity

      Wi-Fi 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac
      Dual Bands

      5G Sub 6 Payment

      Samsung Pay (NFC) Sensors Side Fingerprinting Sensor

      Audio Single Speaker, 3.5mm

      If you’ve been looking to upgrade to a 5G device but don’t have much money to buy a flagship, the Galaxy A13 5G could be the ideal device for you at just $249.99. The phone will go on sale online from December 3 at AT&T and while T-Mobile will have the device available from January 2022.

    • By zikalify
      Samsung launches persistent AR with Dreamground at two locations in the U.S.
      by Paul Hill

      Attempting to unlock possibilities with augmented reality, Samsung has announced the launch of a new app called Dreamground for Android and iOS which can be used at Hollywood Park in Los Angeles or Samsung’s experiential store, Samsung 837, in New York City.

      Through the app, users can see a new layer on top of the physical world where they can see creations other people have made, they can also create things for others to see too. The elements in the Dreamground can be viewed by other users for up to 24 hours before disappearing and clearing room for other people to come along and get creating.

      As an exclusive for Galaxy 5G device owners on Verizon, there will be Galaxy 5G Portals that stream 4K, 360 video and ultra-high fidelity AR. This exclusive, Samsung says, is to show off the high bandwidth and low latency of 5G. Aside from these portals and other people’s creations, Samsung urges users to look out for Bubbloonland, Fluttering Forest, and Crystal Galaxy.

      The launch of Dreamground is quite limited at the moment as it’s just available in two locations but as time passes it’s easy to see how Samsung could expand this AR layer to other venues around the world, especially at concerts and sporting events such as the FIFA World Cup or the Olympics. Time will tell whether the Korean firm decides to expand the use of Dreamground or whether it’ll receive a quiet retirement.