WMA 9.2 Lossless or WAV?


Recommended Posts

The only issue I can think of, if I remember right, is WAV and its support of ID3 metadata and embedded album art but like I said, I can't remember.

 

Does not support metadata, or at least, not through Windows Explorer. Though Windows Explorer does not even support ID3v2.4 so that doesn't say much about it.

I have a couple believe it or not but I have no idea why I was thinking of just leaving the setting on for everything haha. Needless to say when I turned it down it made a BIG difference taking the folder size down to 520 MB. I'm surprised though that WAV isn't much bigger, I might go with that.

They were such great albums!!!

Just use WAV then, it's more compatible and you get the advantages of uncompressed audio (null seek times, data corruption resistance).

Does not support metadata, or at least, not through Windows Explorer. Though Windows Explorer does not even support ID3v2.4 so that doesn't say much about it.

I was worried about the metadata issue but I think it'll be okay.

I was worried about the metadata issue but I think it'll be okay.

 

Might want to try MP3tag, perhaps. It is great for tagging FLACs, MP3s, and WMAs, though I haven't tried it with WAVs so I am not sure if it can embed metadata (but then, whatever you're accessing the files with also needs to support the same format of metadata). Link: http://www.mp3tag.de/en/index.html

As storage space is so cheap and you want maximum compatibility I would say go with the nice and simple WAV format. It means you will need more space than if you were to use something like FLAC but it is probably the best solution for you.

 

I am not an audiophile but I do have decent-ish equipment so I like to have good quality music too. For on the go I just have everything in VBR MP3 as I am never going to be able to tell the difference when on a train or walking down the street but for my home audio system everything is in FLAC.

 

I would highly advise you to avoid things such as WMA. You never know when you might switch to a non-Windows platform and be ###### out of luck! Also I have been down the WMA route and got burned with incompatibilities using newer media players not supporting some of the old bits of WMA Pro encoded files. Was very painful so I switched to FLAC for my archiving as it is open source and spec and has amazing support everywhere.

Apple also released an opensource, lossless codec called ALAC 

Windows Phone actually used to support it natively. But for whatever reason, WP8 doesn't anymore.

 

Desktop Windows (including 8/RT) certainly supports the container format (with its metadata etc.) just fine, not sure why it doesn't yet natively support the codec itself, but Microsoft should get on it!

 

EDIT: Apparently Google Play supports ALAC, too

Might want to try MP3tag, perhaps. It is great for tagging FLACs, MP3s, and WMAs, though I haven't tried it with WAVs so I am not sure if it can embed metadata (but then, whatever you're accessing the files with also needs to support the same format of metadata). Link: http://www.mp3tag.de/en/index.html

I'm a big fan already :yes:

Why would you need to convert someone else's archive of music ?

 

 

Because although windows plays WMA fine, nothing else does. If I wanted to listen to WMA's I need to convert them to an open standard which is supported by my various media players, laptops, phones and car decks.

 

If OP never intends to share his archive of WMAs & plans to stick with windows for ever, it really don't matter what I think.

Because although windows plays WMA fine, nothing else does. If I wanted to listen to WMA's I need to convert them to an open standard which is supported by my various media players, laptops, phones and car decks.

 

If OP never intends to share his archive of WMAs & plans to stick with windows for ever, it really don't matter what I think.

 

Why would he share HIS library ? can't his friends buy their own music ? 

 

either way, read the OP's post, this is for him, not for sharing with his friends(wich is kind of illegal anyway), and he has devices that can read WAV and WMA and not FLAC, so suggesting FLAC is kind of useless. 

 

and the beauty of lossless, if you change devices you can easily convert the library without losing quality unlike lossy formats. 

the beauty of lossless, if you change devices you can easily convert the library without losing quality unlike lossy formats. 

 

This bears repeating.  At this point, I'd therefore be more concerned with proper metadata support, which instantly rules out WAV, in my opinion, because it is terrible in that regard.

 

So with only one other option left, use WMA Lossless, and then possibly think about converting it to a more broadly supported (and ideally open source, i.e. FLAC or ALAC) lossless format in the future.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Euro-Office must default to ODF to be considered "genuinely European", LibreOffice argues by David Uzondu Euro-Office is a web-based collaborative office suite that positions itself as a "European sovereign alternative" to American tech companies, backed by a coalition of developers including Nextcloud, IONOS, Abilian, BTactic, OpenProject, and, more recently, Tuta. The project officially went live a couple of days ago, but not before drawing heavy fire from LibreOffice developers, who called the marketing claim that Euro-Office represents the "first open-source office suite developed in Europe" a deceptive historical inaccuracy because projects like OpenOffice and LibreOffice existed decades earlier. Now that the project has launched, LibreOffice is back with another complaint, arguing that Euro-Office cannot consider itself "genuinely European" while it pushes proprietary Microsoft defaults on users. Euro-Office had promised to improve the OpenDocument Format (ODF) back in April, but the current release still plagues users with several technical failures. For instance, the suite lacks an admin setting to enforce ODF, and mobile editors completely block ODF saves, forcing files into Microsoft's OOXML formats. Some configurations force files into read-only mode, while editing frequently corrupts document formatting or erases data. LibreOffice thinks that merely supporting a format as an afterthought does not make you a sovereign alternative, as file formats are the battleground where" digital sovereignty is won or lost." The road to the first stable release of Euro-Office has been quite bumpy due to an aggressive public fallout with OnlyOffice, from which the coalition originally forked the project. OnlyOffice struck back by accusing the coalition of violating copyright terms under its AGPLv3 branding requirements by stripping the original branding anyway and forking the code. Getting Euro-Office up and running is a bit wonky (at least for non-technical users), as there is no direct installer to grab off the web. The easiest way we learnt is by using Docker. First, pull the official Euro-Office image from the GitHub Container Registry: docker pull ghcr.io/euro-office/documentserver:latest Then, run the container with active ports and a secure JWT token, enabling the test environment: docker run -i -t -d -p 8080:80 --restart=always -e EXAMPLE_ENABLED=true -e JWT_SECRET=my_secure_jwt_secret ghcr.io/euro-office/documentserver:latest And finally, open a web browser and go to the following address: http://localhost:8080 If you are running this on a remote server, replace localhost with your server's IP address. You will see the Euro-Office test page, where you can create new text documents, spreadsheets, or presentations directly in the browser. Image via Euro-Office Nextcloud promises that proper standalone desktop versions and mobile apps will arrive in a future release.
    • It’s any of their products not just windows.
    • Google Gemini has been failing for users across the United States, Europe, and Asia since early Wednesday morning, June 10, 2026, and more than six hours into the incident Google has yet to declare a fix............. https://www.techtimes.com/articles/318152/20260610/google-gemini-outage-tops-six-hours-errors-1076-1099-worldwideflash-lite-still-answers.htm
    • Fun fact: There are more Warhammer 40k games than there are stars in the universe.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      FBSPL earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Year In
      Jim Dugan earned a badge
      One Year In
    • One Month Later
      Tommi118 earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • One Month Later
      sjbousquet earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      sjbousquet earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      486
    2. 2
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      197
    3. 3
      +Edouard
      155
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      83
    5. 5
      ATLien_0
      69
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!