Man arrested for not tipping at NY restaurant


Recommended Posts

ya tips are pretty stupid. this one restaurant me and some friends went to had terrible service, and on the bill it actually says "$80 plus 10% tip" i mean com on! you dont ASK for a 10% tip, you get whatever the customer gives.

It is legal (at least in Idaho where I live) to pay an employee less than minimum wage if a substantial amount of their income comes from tips. When my sister started at Moxie Java, they started her at a little over $3 an hour (minimum wage was $5.25). She made a little over $6 on average.

I think if it's clearly stated that a tip is mandatory for large parties, and it is present on the bill, it should be paid. Failure to do so could constitute arrest. Although I agree tipping is WAY out of hand here in the states.

Tips are incentives for waiters to do a good job. I say pay them what they'd make with tips, don't require tips, and if a waiter is driving away customers with their crappy service, fire them. :p

in all fairness, unless the waiter is hurling abuse or actually ruining your night then i think its quite rude to not tip. the guy is going out of his way to carry a plate to your table and ensure your night goes well and if that isnt worth a measly 10% then shame on you.

I don't see how doing aq job that person willingly signed up to do is going out of his way. He's just doing what is expected of him. That'd be like rewarding a teacher for teaching your kid something instead of doing nothing.

OK, here's the scoop from a guy that actually works, at this moment, in a restaurant. No, I am not a server. No, I am not a manager. I'm a host who also does a lot of data entry and sees a lot of invoices in the office, which means I'm sort of somewhere in between.

The minimum wage of (I believe) around $5.30 an hour DOES NOT APPLY to servers/waitstaff. In Wisconsin, the minimum wage for a server or waitperson is $2.33 an hour. This is posted in the back of the house (that is, an area away from where customers can go), as it is in nearly all restaurants, to comply with federal law. Tips are an extremely important aspect of the server's income, because of this low wage. Generally, in the US, for good service (i.e. food is what you ordered, beverages refilled promptly, nothing spilled on you) the recommended and expected tip is 15% of your bill BEFORE TAX. IF you have outstanding service, feel free to leave more than 15%.

Our restaurant also has a policy, stated on the menu, that we will add an 18% gratuity to the bill of parties of 8 or more. If you really don't feel that your server merited that, hauling ass and trying to keep everything straight and perfect for your large party, you can speak to a manager and have that removed. In America, at least, it is very rarely, if ever, acceptable, much less polite, to not leave any tip at all.

As for prices of the menu, perhaps you don't realize how much the raw ingredients cost for most food. A restaurant will pay $4 for a 12 ounce steak, but once you factor in training, and wages for the person in the back who prepares the ingredients, cooks it, garnishes it, and plates it, $15 leaves very little profit left over. Do you know where most of the profits in your standard mid- to upscale restaurant come from? Booze. Beer, wine, cocktails, they are more or less what carries the restaurant in terms of profits. You can mark alcoholic beverages up 500% and people will happily pay it. But for all the labor involved in food preparation, quite frequently, you are paying an extremely good price for what you get.

And with that, I'm pushing the soapbox back behind the couch.

Yeah its your own fault for nuturing and abusing this notion of gratuity, In Australia tipping is a pretty rare event? why because we dont foster a culture of it, and our minimum wage is more than enough to live off to we dont have to subside them for their pay.

But again, it's because waiting staff people don't get paid enough to get by.

neither do teachers or nurses but the poor people that bring our food from the kitchen to our table should be taken care of so they can live a comfortable life doing a job that anyone with an elementary school education can do

in all fairness, unless the waiter is hurling abuse or actually ruining your night then i think its quite rude to not tip. the guy is going out of his way to carry a plate to your table and ensure your night goes well and if that isnt worth a measly 10% then shame on you.

Why it may be rude, it is not illegal.

The guy is not 'going out of his way' to get you some food. If anything, the cooks in the back are. Waiters do the least amount of work . Its their job to take the guy his food.

And further down [your next post I believe] you saying that people may live on their tips, maybe they should put a little bit more effort forward. Even if you do get stiffed once, the better tips you get from other people make up for it. The waiter probably sucked.

This just goes hand in hand with the current America. You can have someone arrested or sued for something, even if it is for absurd reasons.

Edit - Him saying he's just doing it to defend his waitress? Yeah right bud, this is for publicity. Get real.

I do pizza delivery full time and build computers part time. when I get to a customers house under the time that was quoted to them, I expect a tip, even if its a dollar. I'm always nice, curteous, and respect their property. Tonight I got to a woman's house, in 25 minutes when she was quoted 45. I expected at LEAST a dollar, what'd she do? on the credit card slip I handed to her she wrote in the "Tip" section a big fat zero. I wanted to go back to her house later on that night and slash her tires. Mind you, the order was for $65 and I had to walk up her flights of stairs numerous times with bags of pizza to get it all up there.

in all fairness, unless the waiter is hurling abuse or actually ruining your night then i think its quite rude to not tip. the guy is going out of his way to carry a plate to your table and ensure your night goes well and if that isnt worth a measly 10% then shame on you.

Sorry mate. But isn't his job to "go out of his way to carry a plate to your table and ensure your night goes well"?

When I do myu taxi-ing I don't expect to get a tip like they seem to in the US.

yeah, hes being paid to run around after your lazy ass and the least you can do is tip him!

No mate. He is being paid to do a job. If someone goes to a restuarant, and is paying for the food, he is usually already paying at a premium for it, therefore the resurant owener should pay better wages.

It's got jack ****e to with anyones "lazy ass" :no:

They say right in the article that the 18% tip for parties of 6 or more is MANDATORY. I've seen this in Vancouver BC, and it is always right on the menu itself. Clear as day. It is included in the price of the meal and if you don't pay it, then you are considered to be shorting the check and that is against the law.

I went to america once, we went to a pizza place where the waitress took twice as long as stated to deliver our food and tbh she wasn't really that friendly, after our meal we went to the till to pay and were asked if we would like to tip, we said no because the waitress was crap, the excuse we were given was that the waitress had been crying earlier that day.

Whats wrong with that picture?

1. Being prompted to tip - I'll tip if the service is great and not otherwise, I don't need you to remind me to do it, if the service warranted a tip then I will remember to do so.

2. Having a section for a tip on the receipt - [see #1]

3. Telling me that the service was poor because the waitress had been crying - As if that makes everything alright? I really don't give a **** what kind of a day my waitress has had, if that makes her unable to do her job maybe she shouldn't be doing it, even worse was that she did a poor job and then the restaurant expected the customer to tip her.

In conclusion, America's tipping system is utter BS, whilst most places we went to did have great service, some don't and I don't want to shell out 15% on top of my bill to pay for their incompetence. In the UK we tip as and when we feel like it and I don't ever recall being asked to tip. Thus UK > US :p

The US gratuity system is being abused. In the UK, if there's a party of 8 or more, usually there will be a surcharge of 10% be added to it - the menus usually state that quite clearly - and it's a surcharge, hence it's part of your official bill, as opposed to gratuity (which by law remains optional).

Bottom line is, I'd rather pay more for food and have my waiters be paid a fair wage and then actually work for their tip. The current state of affairs means that tipping has become mandatory and that just defies the point of tipping!

Pay your waiting staff a fair wage - tipping is optional for service which is beyond professional.

in all fairness, unless the waiter is hurling abuse or actually ruining your night then i think its quite rude to not tip. the guy is going out of his way to carry a plate to your table and ensure your night goes well and if that isnt worth a measly 10% then shame on you.

He's not going out of his way... it's his job!

Here in Australia, we pay enough as it is for for a meal at a restaurant but restaurants and cafes do have a coin bowl at the counter, which i DO use when i get change back from paying the bill. (I keep the 1 and 2 doller coins tho :p)

Edited by nathanintu

I used to work as a waiter here in the UK, we never expected a tip, a tip was a bonus to us!

Much prefer our way of doing things than that of the U.S.

Maybe the employers over there should pay the staff more rather than having the blame labelled onto the customer! Jus my opinion! :huh:

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • All these CEOs got the biggest boners thinking about firing employees for AI. Turned out it was just a wet dream.
    • And the fact that the majority of people from Poland are white European Christians while the people you are complaining about in post after post are not is just a coincidence... Every sentence in your post I am replying to is racist nonsense. None of it is actually based on any facts whatsoever. All immigrants are seeking a better life too. It's literally the only reason they would risk everything and leave their homes, families, and homeland. They are working and contributing to the economy too, as you even admit. They get the same benefits your partner did AND that YOU are eligible for as well. That is one of the key things of the EU and a mark of a civilization. That is the definition of a society where everyone is given a chance, treated equally and fairly, and is judged by the content of their character, not their different skin color or which version of ignorant superstitious nonsense their parents lied about as children. Racists around the world said the same things about the Irish and Jews and Poles (like your partner) and...every other immigrant movement over the centuries. What's your family's heritage, by the way? Were your ancestors lied about with racist fearmongering crapola by self-entitled locals the same way as you are now? If someone like that said the same things about all people from Poland, like your partner, would they be right? Or would you want them to judge your partner based on who they actually were, not where they just happened to come from?
    • Again, this is an irrelevant attempt to attack the messenger. The truth does not require any justification.
    • Removed the blue and underline as you did not post a link. This would also  be considered spamming.
    • Why it's almost impossible to produce a smartphone in the United States by Hamid Ganji If you look at the back of some Apple products, you can see the famous phrase “Designed by Apple in California, Assembled in China.” This phrase appears on products from one of the largest smartphone brands in the United States. These products are designed in the U.S., but their manufacturing takes place in China, India, Vietnam, or even Brazil. But why can’t Apple, as one of the largest American tech companies, produce its iPhones on U.S. soil? The idea for this topic came to me after the Trump Foundation launched a smartphone called the T1 and claimed that it was designed and built with American values in mind. However, this claim did not last long, as it was revealed that Trump’s phone was actually a rebranded HTC U24 Pro, with only a gold case and minor internal component changes. You see? Even a phone that is supposed to represent American values is manufactured in China. With a gross domestic product (GDP) exceeding $32 trillion, the United States is currently the world’s largest economy, while China ranks second with around $20 trillion. On the other hand, the United States is by a wide margin the global leader in various technological fields, and American companies spend hundreds of billions of dollars annually on research and development. From Apple and Google to Microsoft, Lockheed Martin, Boeing, and others, American tech and industrial giants lead their foreign competitors in many sectors. The United States also has no shortage of smartphone brands. Apple, Google, and Motorola are among the major brands in the smartphone market, collectively holding a significant share. However, the vast majority of their products are manufactured outside the United States. So why is it that the world’s largest economy, home to the most advanced technology companies and industrial powers, cannot produce a smartphone on its own soil? Let’s explore this question together. Even threats to impose tariffs won’t work After Trump entered the White House as the 47th President of the United States, his administration adopted strict tariff policies. One of these policies was the imposition of a 25% tariff on smartphones manufactured outside the United States. Trump said he “had a little problem” with Apple CEO Tim Cook over producing smartphones outside the U.S. So he thought that threatening a 25% tax on imported phones might force Apple to bring manufacturing back to the United States. “I have long ago informed Tim Cook of Apple that I expect their iPhones that will be sold in the United States of America will be manufactured and built in the United States, not India, or anyplace else,” Trump wrote on Truth Social. Image via The White House Although Apple currently manufactures some of the iPhone’s chips in the United States with TSMC's help, it still shows no willingness to shift full iPhone production to the country. At the time, renowned Apple supply chain analyst Ming-Chi Kuo wrote on X, “In terms of profitability, it’s way better for Apple to take the hit of a 25% tariff on iPhones sold in the US market than to move iPhone assembly lines back to the US.” However, manufacturing a smartphone in the United States is not as easy as it might seem, and many technical and economic barriers are involved. The lack of necessary manufacturing hubs There is a clear reason why many companies prefer to manufacture their products in China. China has established itself as the main global manufacturing hub for international companies, and over the past few decades, large contract manufacturers have emerged there, allowing companies like Apple to outsource production. One such example is Foxconn, which also manufactures some Apple products in India. Building the infrastructure required to produce smartphones in the United States would require tens of billions of dollars in new investment. Factories would need to be built, essential manufacturing equipment would have to be installed, and, most importantly, a skilled workforce capable of operating these systems would need to be recruited and trained. The United States currently lacks the core infrastructure needed to manufacture smartphones, and for this reason, many companies prefer to outsource production to Chinese contractors rather than spend tens of billions of dollars to build that infrastructure, which is significantly more economically efficient. Additionally, building such infrastructure in the United States could take up to a decade, ultimately leading to a significant increase in the product's final price for consumers. Shortage of trained labor in the U.S. compared to China Decades of serving as a global manufacturing hub have allowed China to build a massive talent pool in the production sector that is almost unmatched worldwide. Today, if a company chooses to manufacture its products in China, it can be confident that the workers involved in production have years of experience in their respective roles and are capable of producing high-quality goods with minimal errors. Even if we assume that tens of billions of dollars were invested in building smartphone manufacturing infrastructure in the United States, finding skilled workers would remain highly challenging. Apple CEO Tim Cook visiting the iPhone 6 assembly line in China in 2014. Image: Tim Cook on X In a 2015 interview on CBS’s 60 Minutes, Tim Cook said the main reason Apple isn’t producing in the US is a lack of skills. "China put an enormous focus on manufacturing, in what you and I would call vocational kind of skills. The US over time began to stop having as many vocational kinds of skills. I mean you could take every tool and die maker in the United States and probably put them in the room that we're currently sitting in. In China you would have to have multiple football fields,” Cook said. Also, in 2017, at the Fortune Global Forum in Guangzhou, Cook once again emphasized the importance of highly skilled Chinese workers. “China has moved into very advanced manufacturing, so you find in China the intersection of craftsman kind of skill, and sophisticated robotics and the computer science world. That intersection, which is very rare to find anywhere, that kind of skill, is very important to our business because of the precision and quality level that we like. The thing that most people focus on if they’re a foreigner coming to China is the size of the market, and obviously, it’s the biggest market in the world in so many areas. But for us, the number one attraction is the quality of the people,” Apple CEO said. Higher labor costs in the United States Producing almost any product in the United States is more expensive than in many other countries, and one of the main reasons is the higher cost of labor in the U.S. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, median weekly earnings of full-time workers in the United States were $1,235 in the first quarter of 2026. Meanwhile, the average annual salary in China's private sector in 2025 was RMB 71,590 (US$9,961). In many parts of the world, the weekly wage of an American worker is equivalent to several months of income. Another important factor to consider is that in the United States, the workforce capable of working on a smartphone assembly line is highly specialized and therefore commands higher-than-average wages. According to an estimate by Bank of America, producing an iPhone in the U.S. is technically possible, but “iPhone cost can increase 25% purely on higher labor cost in the U.S.” However, this 25% increase applies only if final assembly is performed in the United States while components are still sourced from China or elsewhere. In this case, the price of a base iPhone would rise from $799 to around $1,000. But in another scenario, if Apple were to produce the required components for the iPhone within the United States, production costs could increase by more than 90%. Trump’s dream for a “Made in the USA” iPhone might never come true In a free-market capitalist economy, one of the primary responsibilities of any CEO is to maximize profit. Using Apple as an example, Tim Cook’s role is to maximize the company’s profits so that it can fund research and development for new products and invest in areas such as artificial intelligence, while also keeping shareholders satisfied. Therefore, it is entirely understandable that Apple would choose not to bring its manufacturing back to the United States and instead keep production in countries where labor is cheaper, and products can be manufactured at a lower cost, thereby maximizing its profit margins. What is your opinion about manufacturing smartphones in the United States? If you are an American citizen, would you be willing to pay hundreds of dollars more for a smartphone made domestically in the USA? Let us know in the comments.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Conversation Starter
      jessse3334 earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
    • Reacting Well
      JuvenileDelinquent earned a badge
      Reacting Well
    • One Month Later
      Excellence2025 earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      Excellence2025 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Week One Done
      flexorcist earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      506
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      196
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      153
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      72
    5. 5
      FloatingFatMan
      65
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!