Alabama Judge at it again

[Dashel]

MONTGOMERY, Ala. - A judge refused to delay a trial Tuesday when an attorney objected to his wearing a judicial robe with the Ten Commandments embroidered on the front in gold. 

Circuit Judge Ashley McKathan showed up Monday at his Covington County courtroom in southern Alabama wearing the robe. Attorneys who try cases at the courthouse said they had not seen him wearing it before. The commandments were described as being big enough to read by anyone near the judge.

McKathan told The Associated Press that he believes the Ten Commandments represent the truth "and you can't divorce the law from the truth. ... The Ten Commandments can help a judge know the difference between right and wrong."

Alabama Judge's New Clothes

Besides undermining the core values of this nation (Freedom of religion and separation) these judges are starting to think of themselves as avatars of god. Let me get this straight, you need gold embrodery to know the difference between right and wrong? They should be defrocked at least, imprisoned/executed ideally.

[ksalter]

Alabama Judge's New Clothes

Besides undermining the core values of this nation (Freedom of religion and separation) these judges are starting to think of themselves as avatars of god.  Let me get this straight, you need gold embrodery to know the difference between right and wrong?  They should be defrocked at least, imprisoned/executed ideally.

585105383[/snapback]

I weep for the future.

I think these "judges" are traitors to the US Constitution and should be dealt with as traitors.

And I am from Alabama the Beautiful...

[Fred Derf Veteran]

Alabama Judge's New Clothes

Besides undermining the core values of this nation (Freedom of religion and separation) these judges are starting to think of themselves as avatars of god.  Let me get this straight, you need gold embrodery to know the difference between right and wrong?

585105383[/snapback]

There's one reason why we don't elect judges.

[threetonesun]

That's odd more than anything. It's not like I have a shirt embroidered with cliff notes for my job.

[Fred Derf Veteran]

That's odd more than anything. It's not like I have a shirt embroidered with cliff notes for my job.

585105497[/snapback]

That might be handy for an english exam though...

"To be or...", um, just a sec, I need to lift my lapel...

[ksalter]

There's one reason why we don't elect judges.

585105491[/snapback]

No, but the officials that appoint these judges are elected. Can't wait for the next Supreme Court justice that is appointed by Jehovahbush.

[aem4162]

That might be handy for an english exam though...

"To be or...", um, just a sec, I need to lift my lapel...

585105517[/snapback]

it worked for me on the "parts of the engine" and "how the car engine works" tests in driver's ed :yes:

[Fred Derf Veteran]

No, but the officials that appoint these judges are elected.  Can't wait for the next Supreme Court justice that is appointed by Jehovahbush.

585105527[/snapback]

I thought Cirtuit Court judges were elected in the USA and that Supreme Court judges were appointed?

Ours are hired and fired except for the Supreme Court of Canada that are appointed based on geographical localtion (3 for Quebec, 3 from Ontario, 2 from the east and one from the atlantic provinces).

[threetonesun]

No, but the officials that appoint these judges are elected.  Can't wait for the next Supreme Court justice that is appointed by Jehovahbush.

585105527[/snapback]

Especially if you can tell the teacher you can take the test anyway, because you're wearing the "truth".

[ksalter]

I thought Cirtuit Court judges were elected in the USA and that Supreme Court judges were appointed?

Ours are hired and fired except for the Supreme Court of Canada that are appointed based on geographical localtion (3 for Quebec, 3 from Ontario, 2 from the east and one from the atlantic provinces).

585105551[/snapback]

I think you are correct...but it wouldn't matter in this case since the majority population approves of ten commandment judges.

[Fred Derf Veteran]

I think you are correct...but it wouldn't matter in this case since the majority population approves of ten commandment judges.

585105854[/snapback]

That's what prompted my original reply that I'm glad that Canadian judges are not elected.

[ksalter]

That's what prompted my original reply that I'm glad that Canadian judges are not elected.

585105856[/snapback]

But what would happen if the elected officials in Canada were more conservative (as voted by a changing electorate) ... you may end up with those kind of judges anyway.

[dreamz Veteran]

how did that guy become a judge? :no:

[Fred Derf Veteran]

But what would happen if the elected officials in Canada were more conservative (as voted by a changing electorate) ... you may end up with those kind of judges anyway.

585105877[/snapback]

Um, I don't think we're communicating properly here.

Judges in Canada are hired by the office of the Ministry of Justice. They are not elected.

Judges in the USA are elected (as far as I know but it might vary by state).

Supreme Court Judges in both countries are appointed by the President/Prime Minister and approved by the Senate/Cabinet.

[Dave Veteran]

MONTGOMERY, Ala. - A judge refused to delay a trial Tuesday when an attorney objected to his wearing a judicial robe with the Ten Commandments embroidered on the front in gold.

Oh wonderful, so lets say the defendant is guilty, now the guy gets a pass because this "activist judge" is doing something he knows full well to be a contradiction of seperation of church and state.

Can you say mis-trial? How about civil rights violation?

[threetonesun]

Judges in the USA are elected (as far as I know but it might vary by state).

585105955[/snapback]

They are? :huh: :unsure:

If they are, it's not by the average person.

[ksalter]

Um, I don't think we're communicating properly here.

Judges in Canada are hired by the office of the Ministry of Justice.  They are not elected.

Judges in the USA are elected (as far as I know but it might vary by state).

Supreme Court Judges in both countries are appointed by the President/Prime Minister and approved by the Senate/Cabinet.

585105955[/snapback]

Okay, so how does the Minitstry of Justice get populated? Are they elected or appointed by the government.

So if the ruling governement changes (becomes conservative) and puts different people in the Ministry of Justice, they may hire judges with a conservate slant...

That was what I was trying to say.

[Fred Derf Veteran]

They are?  :huh:  :unsure:

If they are, it's not by the average person.

585106052[/snapback]

I guess it varies by state then.

Okay, so how does the Minitstry of Justice get populated?  Are they elected or appointed  by the government.

So if the ruling governement changes (becomes conservative) and puts different people in the Ministry of Justice, they may hire judges with a conservate slant...

That was what I was trying to say.

585106055[/snapback]

Except for the actual Minister of Justice, the Ministry of Justice is staffed by non-partisan public officials and there usually is not much turnover from government to government. Sometimes changes in governments bring in new deputy-ministers (the top non-elected position) but not always.

[Aaron Veteran]

They are?  :huh:  :unsure:

If they are, it's not by the average person.

585106052[/snapback]

We vote on Judges here in GA.

[Mike Douglas]

Anyone else think this would have made a great TheOnion article two years ago?

[Fred Derf Veteran]

Anyone else think this would have made a great TheOnion article two years ago?

585106531[/snapback]

Yesterdays fantasy, today's reality. And they say that the slippery slope is a fallacy...

[nowimnothing]

Anyone else think this would have made a great TheOnion article two years ago?

585106531[/snapback]

i kinda wish it were an article from TheOnion. Would make me feel a little better about my fellow countrymen.

[threetonesun]

We vote on Judges here in GA.

585106462[/snapback]

During town elections, or some other time?

I could be completely oblivious, since I've missed a few local elections. I always figured if you have a long black robe and were willing to wear it in public, they took you.

[Dave Veteran]

During town elections, or some other time?

I could be completely oblivious, since I've missed a few local elections. I always figured if you have a long black robe and were willing to wear it in public, they took you.

585106706[/snapback]

Let me be the first to tell you, they don't let you in for just having the robe.

If I'm not mistaken I have infact voted for judges.

[nowimnothing]

maybe this'll answer some questions.

scroll down about 3/4 of the way to "Methods of Judicial Selection"

http://www.lwvmi.org/lwvjudsl.htm

(i didn't read the whole thing, but it looked informative and explained why i have never voted on a judge (i live in Virginia))