Maxtor VS Seagate!


Recommended Posts

I had:

- 1 x Quantum Fireball is > 6 yr old and still running well ...

- Several Seagate running well in btw 4 yr old & 1yr old

- 2 x IBM (hitachi) Deskstar HDD are around 2 yrs

- 1 WD just about 4 months old...

(all count on date of purchase NOT date of manuf)

All of 'em going well.. no problem ... not even a bad sector ...

BUT, i also got:

1 x DEAD maxtor (about 3 yrs old) and just dead no reason :no:

That's the only HDD crash on me :) I decided never again going back to maxtor unless they manuf. a REAL cool thing.

I just bought a Seagate SATA last weekend and it's a beauty. This was my first SATA and I was surprised how quiet it was compared to my Western Digital ATA's. My best hard drive purchase yet. I could have gone with Western Digital but I was told that the WD's aren't true SATA, plus the Seagate was about $10 cheaper. I refused to buy Maxtor because I didn't want a drive that would just up and die on me. I'm a WD fanboy but I would suggest getting the Seagate.

Seagate, seek times are alot faster, so is everything else, plus there not known for dying.

585917604[/snapback]

Please know what you are talking about, before you hit the "add reply" button

From Seagate.com:

http://www.seagate.com/cda/products/discsa...dex/1,,,00.html

From Maxtor.com

http://www.pcclub.com/product_detail.cfm?itemno=A3450889

Now if you look at the Seagate chart, the 7200rpm drives ( which i'm know that the topic starter here is going for) Have the same seektimes as the Maxtor i posted.

And you can go ahead ad lookup other 7200rpm maxtor drives, and they will have the same seek times. with a few exceptions

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?...040#DetailSpecs

BE WARNED! SEAGATE IS A HORRIBLE COMPANY

I BOUGHT AN 80GB SEAGATE BARRACUDA AND THEN GUESS WHAT HAPPENED AFTER A YR THE UNIT WAS MAKING ALL SORTS OF WEIRD NOISES AND I CALLED THEM AND THEY TOLD ME THE WARRANTY EXPIRED IN APRIL 2003, AND I HAD BOUT IT IN MARH of 2003, THE WARRANTY STARTS WHEN THE UNIT IS MADE NOT WHEN IT IS PURCHASED! MAXTOR HAS A 5 YR WARRANTY

BE WARNED! SEAGATE IS A HORRIBLE COMPANY

I BOUGHT AN 80GB SEAGATE BARRACUDA AND THEN GUESS WHAT HAPPENED AFTER A YR THE UNIT WAS MAKING ALL SORTS OF WEIRD NOISES AND I CALLED THEM AND THEY TOLD ME THE WARRANTY EXPIRED IN APRIL 2003, AND I HAD BOUT IT IN MARH of 2003, THE WARRANTY STARTS WHEN THE UNIT IS MADE NOT WHEN IT IS PURCHASED! MAXTOR HAS A 5 YR WARRANTY

585919210[/snapback]

holy crap lets CAP IT ALL OUT SO EVERYONE CAN HEAR!

every hard drive watenty starts from the manufacure date. and most have a 1 year wantey. seagate is not a terible compnay, you jast had a single isolated bad experience with one of there hard drive. so pipe down.

they wouldn't be in business still if they were "horrible"

you want Proof?

Remember IBM's Deskstar drives? Uhm yeah where is IBM's Hard drive division now?

thank you  :sleep:

585919228[/snapback]

There is nothing wrong with deskstar drives these days. Its a shame that people still avoid them.

I guess its so hit and miss and luck of the draw..

Currently have Maxtor 80GB 7200RPM IDE (about 2 years old) and a Seagate 160GB 7200RPM SATA thats about a year old.. both rockin ok at the minute, but have had bad luck with Maxtor and IBM Deathstars so..

then you really shouldn't be using a pc if you think Maxtor sucks. but then again this is neowin and idiotic posts like this don't surprise me.

Most members here in the Hardware hangout know my stance when it comes to Seagate vs Maxtor vs Western Digital.

THERE ALL GOOD, DONT BLAME A  COMPANIES HDD"S BEING SUCKY BECAUSE YOU DIDNT TAKE THE PROPER PRECAUTIONS ON MAKING SURE THAT HDD LIVED A LONG TIME AND SERVED IT PURPOSE.

sometimes you do get a bad lemon, but a bad lemon don't spoil the basket.

585917020[/snapback]

Exactly. Someone gets a bad part, boom, they think the company sucks. It happens with all of them.

I have had IBM (now Hitachi), WD, Maxtor, and other drives. I just got ( a few months back ) a Maxtor 300GB 16MB buffer for only $145 and it's great. So on that I'll recommend the Maxtor.

Personally I'd go with Samsung because they are making the quiestest hard drives right now, unless you can get your hands on the older single plater Barracudas.

Between Maxter and Seagates, I'd go with the Seagate. Sure maybe they both perform along the same level, so get the one with the longest warrenty so that if one does go bad... you can get it replaced.

wow... maxtor seem to have massive problems..

almost 1/2 the ppl that came in here have had problems with maxtor drives..

but is the DIAMOND 10 drives better now??

585919990[/snapback]

Well when people have problems, the majority will come to vent and post about it. When things work fine they are less compelled to post about it, no complaints!

That is why you will always hear more negative stuff about a company than positive. If they were really that bad, why would major companies still use them, and they would not remain one of the largest HDD providers in the world.

Just like how someone can do 10 things right but mess up 1 thing and people will tend to pick on that 1 negative thing and fail to see the history of positive things.

Anywhoo, like Help said the maxtor has 16MB Cache and NCQ and has been proven to be quite a good performer.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • The Trump administration doesn't want you to use OpenAI's GPT-5.6 without its approval by David Uzondu Image via @realDonalTrump (X) As OpenAI prepares the release of its next model, GPT 5.6, the White House has instructed the company to limit the distribution of the software to a small group of government-approved partners instead of the general public, as it has done with previous releases. According to The Information, OpenAI Chief Executive Officer Sam Altman sent an internal memo to staff on Thursday explaining that the federal government will approve access "customer by customer" during an initial preview phase. Altman noted in the communication that this restrictive rollout is "not [their] long-term model" for software deployment, and the company plans to work toward a "more sustainable" distribution method later. CNN said that both OpenAI and the Trump administration view the capabilities of GPT 5.6 on the same level as Anthropic's Mythos and that government officials intend to "collaborate with frontier AI labs to develop shared approaches for addressing the challenges of scaling this technology." The latest restriction comes just weeks after the US Commerce Department decided to restrict Fable, a version of Mythos with extra safety "guardrails" to prevent users from exploiting software vulnerabilities. Not long after the release, though, researchers at Amazon found a way to bypass these restrictions, prompting an aggressive response from federal authorities. The government ordered Anthropic to cut off access for non-US citizens located outside the US, non-US citizens living inside the US, and incredibly, even Anthropic's own foreign-born employees. Anthropic now appears to be building a workaround to resolve this compliance block with an update to its Privacy Policy that introduces a category called "Verification Data" to handle KYC and Digital IDs. This setup could mandate digital identity checks to filter users by nationality, requiring a government-issued ID and facial biometric data. Who knows? Maybe in the future, you would have to scan your US Passport or State ID to prove your citizenship before you are allowed to chat with Fable 5 (or any other model).
    • When Windows 7 was released I created an AutoHotkey script that uses Alt+` as a keyboard shortcut to move a window across monitors. I have been using that script for over 15 years and this is the first time I have come across another app that uses the same shortcut!
    • I called it last year that they wouldn't end support when they said there would. There are too many people still on Windows 10 waiting for something better to upgrade to and 11 ain't it! The recent promises of fixing Windows 11's many problems is nice, but unless they deliver on those promises in a big way then I expect customers will still want to stick with 10.
    • Full ACK. I went too far adressing your post specifically. And as you said, it up to us customers as participant of the market dynamic as it happens to decide whether we spend our money on a product or not. The responsibility is to the company. In case of this price hike one could assume that MS is expecting or even starting to see a new interest in XBox hardware so they want to avoid losses per unit sold. I find it fair enough that they granted a period in which everyone interested could grab a unit for the current price (Amazon.de has a reliable stock of XBox Series X digital, which I bought last December after having sold my day one Series X a year ago). It is not that they cash up their customers starting on Monday. Cheers and let's cling to our perfectly fine hardware as long as we deem it worthy in relation to purchasing something new!
  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      xvvxcvv earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Month Later
      xvvxcvv earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Enthusiast
      Xonos went up a rank
      Enthusiast
    • Conversation Starter
      Admir earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
    • First Post
      The_Focal_Point earned a badge
      First Post
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      414
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      170
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      129
    4. 4
      neufuse
      69
    5. 5
      Xenon
      68
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!