Lost Season 4

By Rappy
in The Media Room

 Share

Recommended Posts

Grand Master

Hurmoth

Posted
Posted
That also happened for Jacob's cabin.

Right, which to me is explained by visions at this point. What Hurley is seeing is in his mind, but that doesn't mean it wasn't put there by Jacob. Meaning the island is causing him to have these visions, he isn't necessarily crazy.

Grand Master

Mathachew Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted
Right, which to me is explained by visions at this point. What Hurley is seeing is in his mind, but that doesn't mean it wasn't put there by Jacob. Meaning the island is causing him to have these visions, he isn't necessarily crazy.

That could very well be the case, I was making the case that Charlie is in fact dead, that there's not two of him, but it's hard to say how this show can go since there's a plane and surely bodies were found in the plane, yet the plane and bodies are on the island as well. Oh what a mystery!!

Grand Master

episode

Posted
Posted (edited)
Is it possible Hurley is also imagining Lewis? That would explain how 'Lewis' could see 'Charlie' lol.

So then you have to assume he also imagined Jack.

And we saw Jack watch Hurley's car chase from Jack's POV. So that would mean Hurley didn't imagine that part.

Right, which to me is explained by visions at this point. What Hurley is seeing is in his mind, but that doesn't mean it wasn't put there by Jacob. Meaning the island is causing him to have these visions, he isn't necessarily crazy.

Which leads back to the same question. If the island is making Hurley see Charlie, how did Lewis see him?

Off the Island yes because of the time loop, to be it sounds logical but I am always for the far out ideas.

I think the time loop theory is different than what you believe it to be.

That theory is that events ON THE ISLAND repeat themselves. Meaning there are always a group of 'others' and 'survivors/stranded' and one group trying to find the island (DHARMA).

For example. If a group of new people came to the island right now after 4x01, say by shipwreck, they would view the 815ers as 'others'. Look at where the 815ers are going. To the barracks. Where the 'others' lived. Stands to reason that the 815ers are now the 'others'. The old others are now (again) the 'hostiles' from the DHARMA time.

Basically. The island always has three groups.

Edited by episode
Grand Master

Rappy Veteran

Posted
  • Author
  • Veteran
Posted
That could very well be the case, I was making the case that Charlie is in fact dead, that there's not two of him, but it's hard to say how this show can go since there's a plane and surely bodies were found in the plane, yet the plane and bodies are on the island as well. Oh what a mystery!!

Yeah thats what I am looking forward to them explaining who the peeps are in the plane under the sea because if the pilot is the one from the plane then one of the others must of put him down there...lol

Grand Master

episode

Posted
Posted (edited)
Which leads to the question is Lewis real?

We have no reason to think that he isn't. He is just as real as the other people in Santa Rosa the first time, which we know are in fact real due to Libby. There have been no clues toward Santa Rosa being in Hurley's mind this time around.

Is Matthew Abaddon also imaginary? As soon as he shows up to someone else, then we will know for a fact that it isn't all in Hurley's mind.

Edited by episode
Grand Master

Hurmoth

Posted
Posted
We have no reason to think that he isn't. He is just as real as the other people in Santa Rosa the first time, which we know are in fact real due to Libby. There have been no clues toward Santa Rosa being in Hurley's mind this time around.

Is Matthew Abaddon also imaginary? As soon as he shows up to someone else, then we will know for a fact that it isn't all in Hurley's mind.

But don't you remember Dave? Dave wasn't real, at least as far as we know he isn't. Lewis could be another Dave.

Grand Master

episode

Posted
Posted
But don't you remember Dave? Dave wasn't real, at least as far as we know he isn't. Lewis could be another Dave.

But Dave was shown to be imaginary right away (by showing him on the island). They have done no such thing with Lewis.

It has to be the island that made Charlie appear, not Hurley's mind. Remember Kate's horse? Sawyer could see it too. Kate and Sawyer, as far as we know, don't have imaginary people/things in their minds. So it had to be the island doing it.

Grand Master

Hurmoth

Posted
Posted
But Dave was shown to be imaginary right away (by showing him on the island). They have done no such thing with Lewis.

It has to be the island that made Charlie appear, not Hurley's mind. Remember Kate's horse? Sawyer could see it too. Kate and Sawyer, as far as we know, don't have imaginary people/things in their minds. So it had to be the island doing it.

But the first time Kate saw the horse was off the island and we already know the island can see into you sole, mind, etc. because of Mr. Eko.

And in Hurley's flashback we saw that Hurley knew Dave was fake because of the photo where we had his arm around him. Once again the island looking into Hurley to place those tricks.

How can the island do that when the person isn't on the island? It doesn't make sense that it is the island IMO, I don't see how the island can control what someone is thinking off the island. And if Charlie is indeed dead, then how can Lewis see him? Unless Lewis is not real.

Grand Master

+Peewee210 Subscriber¹

Posted
  • Subscriber¹
Posted
One way to prove Lewis real is to look at when Abaddon comes in. Does the nurse give Lewis any meds?

If he is the guy who Hurley is playing connect 4 with then yes, she does give him meds.

Grand Master

Hurmoth

Posted
Posted
Yes he is. Then he is real.

Unless you are going to say that ALL of Santa Rosa is now imaginary.

Then how do you explain Lewis seeing Charlie? It doesn't fit with Lost. There's got to be a mistake somewhere. I'm wondering if that is suppose to be Lewis playing, I can't seem to find a screenshot of that scene with Lewis in it, I can just find arms.

The only thing Lostpedia has is the Charlie incident: http://www.lostpedia.com/wiki/Lewis. They don't mention him playing connect 4.

It simply can't be the island though, unless whatever is effecting Hurley also effects the people around him, which means that the cop should have walked in and seen Charlie and the water, etc.

How about this as a theory... they're not off the island. They're in the "box" or something like that and the island is fueling these images.

Grand Master

episode

Posted
Posted
Then how do you explain Lewis seeing Charlie? It doesn't fit with Lost. There's got to be a mistake somewhere. I'm wondering if that is suppose to be Lewis playing, I can't seem to find a screenshot of that scene with Lewis in it, I can just find arms.

The only thing Lostpedia has is the Charlie incident: http://www.lostpedia.com/wiki/Lewis. They don't mention him playing connect 4.

It simply can't be the island though, unless whatever is effecting Hurley also effects the people around him, which means that the cop should have walked in and seen Charlie and the water, etc.

We have already seen the island (or Jacob, I guess) influence events that occured off the island.

Remember the Charlotte Malkin autopsy tape?

Grand Master

Hurmoth

Posted
Posted
We have already seen the island (or Jacob, I guess) influence events that occured off the island.

Remember the Charlotte Malkin autopsy tape?

Where's the proof that Jacob did that?

We don't even know if she was really dead or if the Dr. was simply ignorant on that one. We've never gotten an explanation on that.

Grand Master

Hurmoth

Posted
Posted
Wheres the proof that Hurley is imagining Lewis?

Something sent a message through Charlotte to get to Eko about Locke.

It has to be the island or Jacob. Unless you are going to tell me that Lost is some big 'god is awesome' crap.

There's more proof that Lewis is fake (seeing Charlie for example) than the island (or Jacob) causing Charlotte to come back to life after being dead.

Carlton Cuse has stated that what happens ON the island has a global effect, but he hasn't said that the island directly causes things to happen off the island.

Grand Master

episode

Posted
Posted
There's more proof that Lewis is fake (seeing Charlie for example) than the island (or Jacob) causing Charlotte to come back to life after being dead.

Carlton Cuse has stated that what happens ON the island has a global effect, but he hasn't said that the island directly causes things to happen off the island.

No, not Charlotte coming back to life.

The first thing Charlotte says when she comes back is 'Let John Locke go'

It is a message directly to Eko, from the island or Jacob. The island brought her back to life to deliver that message so that Eko would follow Locke once he met him.

Grand Master

Hurmoth

Posted
Posted
No, not Charlotte coming back to life.

The first thing Charlotte says when she comes back is 'Let John Locke go'

It is a message directly to Eko, from the island or Jacob. The island brought her back to life to deliver that message so that Eko would follow Locke once he met him.

I don't remember that at all. And there's no mention of that on Lostpedia, you'd think that would be very important. I'm going to watch that episode again tonight because I completely missed that.

The only thing listed on Lostpedia is, "She stops Eko at the airport to deliver a message to him from Yemi - she claims to have seen Yemi whilst she was "between places", after the drowning incident." But they don't mention what the message was.

Grand Master

episode

Posted
Posted (edited)
I don't remember that at all. And there's no mention of that on Lostpedia, you'd think that would be very important. I'm going to watch that episode again tonight because I completely missed that.

The only thing listed on Lostpedia is, "She stops Eko at the airport to deliver a message to him from Yemi - she claims to have seen Yemi whilst she was "between places", after the drowning incident." But they don't mention what the message was.

Its on Lostpedia, I'll find it. Its where I find out about it.

http://www.lostpedia.com/wiki/Whisper_transcripts

Scroll down to the entry about 'The 23rd Psalm'.

Edited by episode
Grand Master

Hurmoth

Posted
Posted

Here's the guy who played Lewis: http://www.lostpedia.com/wiki/Image:Steven_Neumeier.jpg which doesn't look anything like that guy playing Connect 4. At least to me he doesn't, maybe I'm wrong.

So the theory that Lewis is not real is back in play. It is the only thing that makes sense.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Posts

    • Microsoft releases major feature updates for stock Windows 11 apps

      By PurSpyk · Posted

      Anyway to download these versions without being on the Experimental builds?
    • Microsoft about to radically change how often your Edge browser updates

      By testman · Posted

      Nothing is stopping you from continuing with your testing cadence. If updates are released every 2 weeks instead of 4, and you test once every 4 weeks, the exact same amount of patches will still be available for you in those 4 weeks. For example: Before 4th week - patch 1, 2, 3, 4 After 2nd week - patch 1 and 2 4th week - patch 3 and 4 Still the same amount after 4.
    • Microsoft about to radically change how often your Edge browser updates

      By testman · Posted

      Everyone else has said it. I'm gonna say it - you don't know what you're talking about. I do. I have two laptops. One work, one personal. I have access to two more laptops - both personal. At home I manually update my personal laptop when I see on Neowin that there is an update - I carry on and only apply the updates when I am ready. My work one only updates when my workplace decides to send it - I carry on and only apply the updates (when they actually arrive, which is usually days after the release) when I switch off the laptop at the end of the day as usual. The two other personal laptops only get updated when I get to it which is rarely - the people who own them carry on using them until I get to it and update them. All of the browsers on all laptops are configured to restore the tabs when launched. Google and Microsoft have changed from 6 weeks to 4, and it looks like it's going to move to 2. None of these changes affect how any of these browsers on the laptops are used. Not one jot. My advice to you is stop panicking whenever you see an update. Just carry on with what you're doing. This even benefits you in a way - from your comment you sound like you don't like the changes or the frivolous new features - great - then carry on as before!
    • Lethal fake phone chargers are still being sold on Amazon and eBay, UK watchdog warns

      By Brian Miller · Posted

      AMAZON needs to take total accountability for this.
    • Windows Server gets DNS over HTTPS (DoH) support

      By binaryzero · Posted

      Server Summit had a heap of announcements, ADCS changes are baller.

  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      Jeroen Wilms earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Week One Done
      rolfus earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Month Later
      Leroy Jethro Gibbs earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Conversation Starter
      flexorcist earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
    • One Month Later
      AndreaB earned a badge
      One Month Later

  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      508
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      197
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      138
    4. 4
      ATLien_0
      90
    5. 5
      Steven P.
      80
    Show More

  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!