Windows XP SP3. Much better than Vista SP1


Recommended Posts

Because Microsoft's own reccomended hardware specifications mention 1GB of RAM.

Obviously, when Microsoft were making Vista, their goal was to make it look good because they know that it works for Apple's OSX. Their priorities weren't set on performance. If they were, why the hell would Vista run best at 2GB ram? OSX runs perfectly fine on 1GB and the same goes to the new KDE4 with Plasma on Linux. dwm.exe has a working set of memory of 60-100MB just for Aero's effects, and here I thought the videocard would be used to draw the effects.

I'd say though, that a fair comparison would be XP with/without SP1 with Vista with/without SP1. At least compare the first service pack's impact on the OS. Right, from what I remember, SP1 was mainly fixes, just like Vista's SP1. Bad comparison.

Good point but Microsoft's Required ram for XP is 256mb, good luck running XP with 256mb of ram and have it be anywhere near as fast as Vista running with it's recommended 1gb of Ram. Sure it's more, sure 1GB or ram these days costs less then 256mb of ram did when XP came out, sure more is better...

Doesn't Matter, what matters is what you like what you use, what your preferance is...

Your OS is like your woman, you are the one that has to look at it everyday, which one makes you happy?

If it doesn't make you happy...get a new one...lol

Here's some interesting info about why XP apps run worse in Vista than XP.

It is because of GDI+. Vista no longer uses GDI+ for the GUI, it uses DirectX instead. That means the GUIs of XP-compatible apps must be remapped into DirectX in realtime. This causes all sorts of problems.

"Existing graphics interfaces, such as GDI, GDI+, and older versions of Direct3D, continue to work on Windows Vista, but are internally remapped where possible. This means that the majority of existing Windows applications will continue to work." - Microsoft

http://msdn2.microsoft.com/en-us/library/bb173477.aspx

There's more info about it here:

http://www.regdeveloper.co.uk/2007/12/04/vista_vs_xp_tests/

That's not quite correct. Yes, with the DWM running, the desktop is rendered using Direct3D. But applications that render using GDI / GDI+ for their client areas still render with those technologies. The difference with the DWM is that they now render to an off-screen buffer, which is then composited onto the screen.

The performance issue that I think you're getting at is entirely unrelated to those things. That issue is the fact that in Vista, with WDDM drivers, GDI is no longer hardware accelerated. For the most part, this isn't noticeable to anyone, since today's CPUs are perfectly capable of doing that work with as much effort as it takes you to blink your eyes. That said, there are cases where it can make a slightly noticeable impact... mainly around resizing applications that make heavy use of GDI/GDI+ drawing and have complicated layouts.

You forgot the awful implementation of the principle of least privilege (a.k.a UAC). Why on earth do I have to click through 3 dialogs just to rename a exe-file and its extension in the Program Files directory? The last dialog even has to redraw the entire screen in order to shade everything but the dialog darker and unclickable.

Only one of those dialogs is UAC, the others are shell dialogs, and their numbers are reduced in SP1.

The UAC dialog doesn't redraw the entire screen in order to shade everything and make it unclickable. For security purposes, those dialogs are displayed on an entirely different desktop. The other windows are unclickable (and dimmed) because they aren't really there. It's just a screenshot of your actual desktop, copied to the Secure Desktop - where the UAC dialog is displayed. This prevents other applications/windows from messing with the UAC dialog or manipulating its rendering.

This makes trustworthy consent prompts possible, something that doesn't exist on other operating systems (Mac and Linux, for example, require you to enter a password to elevate - which is more work and more disruptive to the user).

i hope i will never have to install vista on my PC machine

I can bet you said that for XP...... please, if don't have something good to say just shut up please

I have used Vista, liked what I saw, love all the new features and improvements. My configuration just fits the recommended requirements, problem is ... no proper hardware/driver support for the X-Fi from Creative :crazy:

My next PC will contain a Vista ready 8 channel sound card :D Sorry Creative, you guys are just (insert own thought) ! Maybe the Asus one can do better ;)

I have used Vista, liked what I saw, love all the new features and improvements. My configuration just fits the recommended requirements, problem is ... no proper hardware/driver support for the X-Fi from Creative :crazy:

My next PC will contain a Vista ready 8 channel sound card :D Sorry Creative, you guys are just (insert own thought) ! Maybe the Asus one can do better ;)

I have an X-Fi and have no problem with it.

I just had to download the audio console launcher seperately to make it work...

I have an X-Fi and have no problem with it.

I just had to download the audio console launcher seperately to make it work...

I've tried just about everything, maybe I'm doing something wrong, I've tried different PCI slots, reloading with lesser peripherals, tried different versions of drivers, including the audio consle, etc. I have to reboot at least 3 times a day as the sound keeps disappearing. On XP, my record is 3 weeks and 2 days, before rebooting. Surely this has to do with driver support?

I love doing all things audio on my PC :devil:

You guys don't seem to understand. Macs use a Core 2 Duo just like a PC, they use the same memory, they use the same hard drives, they use the same chipsets (just a different layout on the motherboard) and they mostly use the same graphics processors (onboard or ATI).

No, you don't seem to understand. The point being made was clearly that ALL Macs run on the same hardware (Intel Core / Core 2) with the same Intel chipsets, etc. They don't have to support AMD chips. They don't have to support chipsets from Nvidia, Via, SiS, etc. They don't have to worry about other OEMs who may combine chipset A with processor B with sound card C with video card D. It certainly makes things much easier for them.

Compatibility rarely results in performance problems

Hahahahahaha. I'll pass that along to the Windows perf guys, they'll get a kick out of that one :p

It has now been about a year since Vista's release and SP1 is close, yet we are not seeing any performance improvements.

Are you kidding me? You obviously don't play games. Or copy files. Or have a computer on a corporate network.

I think it is safe to say by now that Vista's performance is not down to compatibility issues. If you take a look under the hood, it's performance issues are obvious. If you load a car down with a body that weights twice as much as another car with the same engine, the car that weights less is going to outperform it's competitor. Vista, while certainly having some improvements over XP, has alot more going on than XP. I honestly don't understand how people can dilute themselves into believing otherwise, there is nothing really to argue here. You can argue Vista's usefulness and features, since much of it comes down to personal taste and individual uses, but you cannot argue pure performance.

That's partially right. Yes, there is a performance penalty for new features and functionality. Heck, there are performance trade-offs for compatibility, security, and reliability as well. The new display driver model has a strong emphasis on quality and reliability (moving things out of the kernel, where they can crash and be restarted without bringing down the whole system), and that comes with a performance cost, albeit a small one in the grand scheme.

But there are countless compatibility problems that affect performance. That can lead to one system performing much slower than another with similar specs. Bad driver, bad add-in, misbehaving program, etc. Heck, there are some anti-virus programs (like outdated eTrust versions) that can bring a system to its knees, just because the USN change journal is enabled by default on Vista (and compounded by the indexer monitoring the journal). Their app would go nuts just randomly flipping attributes on every file in your system endlessly. On XP (without WDS and with the USN journal off) it's not terribly noticeable, even though it's still a terribly wrong and evil thing for the app to be doing. And that's just one of countless examples. Adobe Reader before the latest version included an IFilter that would return a success code when queried for functionality that it didn't actually support. Then it would crash when you tried to use it. Worse yet, I've seen some OEMs ship Vista machine with Reader 7.0 installed (though I can't imagine why they'd do that). We put a check in the indexer that prevents the busted version from ever being used, but unfortunately there are some situations (PDFs that come as e-mail attachments, mainly) where it still gets invoked and causes performance problems because every time it tries to index a PDF attachment, it crashes the protocol host and it needs to be restarted.

So yeah, compatibility issues can and do impact performance. And probably always will, in some way.

I've tried just about everything, maybe I'm doing something wrong, I've tried different PCI slots, reloading with lesser peripherals, tried different versions of drivers, including the audio consle, etc. I have to reboot at least 3 times a day as the sound keeps disappearing. On XP, my record is 3 weeks and 2 days, before rebooting. Surely this has to do with driver support?

I love doing all things audio on my PC :devil:

Maybe you have a faulty card in your rig or maybe a Nforce chipset......

Your expectations are too damn high.. all of you

Sooner or later ALMOST ALL of us will have Vista installed in their PC....

Note: As with our Vista SP1 testing, we used the identical Dell XPS M1710 test bed with 2GHz Core 2 Duo CPU, 1GB of RAM and discrete nVidia GeForce Go 7900GS video.

With only 1 GB of memory, no wonder XP was that much faster... Maybe try using the correct "recommended" amount of memory in each test. If you are going to quadruple XP's minimum ram amout, then quadruple Vista's to 2gb and run it again.

Maybe you have a faulty card in your rig or maybe a Nforce chipset......

Hmmm. Ok, some research by me regarding Nforce shipsets won't hurt ;) As for a faulty card, I never considered that, being that it doesn't fault under XP :blush:

Maybe you have a faulty card in your rig or maybe a Nforce chipset......

Sooner or later ALMOST ALL of us will have Vista installed in their PC....

What makes you say that? Thats not true at all. Vista is ME reloaded whether you like it or not. It can easily be skipped until the next Windows release. Especially as Vista doesn't really offer anything over and above xp aside from a newer GUI and dx10 (which so far has been a joke).

Sooner or later ALMOST ALL of us will have Vista installed in their PC....

I doubt that... I doubt that even Vista can hit 60% usage before Windows 7 comes out. They said no more 5 year releases. It's likely to see Windows 7 in 2009 or 2010.

That's not quite correct. Yes, with the DWM running, the desktop is rendered using Direct3D. But applications that render using GDI / GDI+ for their client areas still render with those technologies. The difference with the DWM is that they now render to an off-screen buffer, which is then composited onto the screen.

The performance issue that I think you're getting at is entirely unrelated to those things. That issue is the fact that in Vista, with WDDM drivers, GDI is no longer hardware accelerated. For the most part, this isn't noticeable to anyone, since today's CPUs are perfectly capable of doing that work with as much effort as it takes you to blink your eyes.

Under a standard Vista install, you have GDI apps that are "remapped" to DirectX through software rendering instead of hardware acceleration and buffered off-screen using system memory instead of GPU memory. Are you saying GDI can be hardware accelerated in Vista if WDDM drivers aren't used? But then won't Vista revert back to DX9?

But, if as you say, the GDI to DirectX remapping doesn't cause a noticeable slowdown of XP apps and increased RAM usage in Vista, what is causing the slowdown in so many apps?

Under a standard Vista install, you have GDI apps that are "remapped" to DirectX through software rendering instead of hardware acceleration and buffered off-screen using system memory instead of GPU memory. Are you saying GDI can be hardware accelerated in Vista if WDDM drivers aren't used? But then won't Vista revert back to DX9?

GDI apps aren't "remapped" to DirectX. If they were, they would be hardware accelerated. The off-screen buffer for a window exists in both system memory and GPU memory.

My understanding is that if an XDDM driver (XP driver) is used, GDI will be accelerated. But the DWM won't run, and DirectX 10 won't work. Basically you'll be running XP as far as display and window management goes.

But, if as you say, the GDI to DirectX remapping doesn't cause a noticeable slowdown of XP apps and increased RAM usage in Vista, what is causing the slowdown in so many apps?

Still not sure what DirectX remapping you're talking about. Direct3D is responsible for getting things onto the screen, but not for drawing the client areas of GDI apps into their respective window buffers.

geez ! I'm sick of all those tests comparing Vista to XP and saying that XP is faster than Vista on the same rig . I say let's go back to DOS coz it's the fastest OS M$ ever brought to us !!!! And all those dudes saying that Vista=Win Me should shut their mouth !

I'm using Vista since Beta3 and I'm never going back to XP !

My 2 cents

P.S. : Brandon you rocks :D

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • OpenAI is rolling out a major upgrade to ChatGPT memory by Pradeep Viswanathan OpenAI is rolling out a major upgrade to ChatGPT's memory, making the system more capable, current, and scalable across long-term use. Memory allows ChatGPT to remember useful details about users, including their preferences, projects, and constraints. Instead of starting every conversation from scratch, ChatGPT can use this context to provide more relevant responses in future chats. OpenAI first launched saved memories in February 2024. That feature allowed users to explicitly ask ChatGPT to save information into its memory, such as travel plans or writing preferences. However, this system had limits because it depended heavily on users giving clear instructions to remember something. Additionally, saved memories could become stale over time. In April 2025, OpenAI expanded memory by allowing ChatGPT to reference past chat context outside the saved memories list. This was powered by a background process called “dreaming,” which automatically curates memories from chat history. This made ChatGPT better at learning from natural conversation without requiring users to manually save every detail. Today, OpenAI announced a more capable and compute-efficient memory architecture built on top of dreaming. This new system improves ChatGPT’s ability to carry forward useful context, follow user preferences, and remain accurate as time passes. According to OpenAI’s internal evaluations, the new system improves factual recall from 67.9% in 2025 to 82.8% in 2026. Preference adherence improves from 55.3% to 71.3%, while accuracy over time improves from 52.2% to 75.1%. The best part of this new system is a new memory summary page where users can review ChatGPT's memories. Users can even update details, correct information, or give instructions on what topics ChatGPT should bring up and when. This new, improved memory system is available to ChatGPT Plus and Pro users in the US starting today. It will roll out to more countries, as well as Free and Go users, in the coming weeks.
    • I work for a video production company in Australia. The camera operators shoot footage and then pass the SD card over to the editors. Much easier than handing over the entire camera. Plus, on a busy day you can hand off the SD card and then pop another in for the next shoot. Or, you might have used multiple SD cards because you need the extra space for a long shoot. I also use USB cables and wifi for transferring footage, but in many cases an SD card reader is the easiest method.
    • Microsoft Edge 149.0.4022.52 by Razvan Serea Microsoft Edge is a super fast and secure web browser from Microsoft. It works on almost any device, including PCs, iPhones and Androids. It keeps you safe online, protects your privacy, and lets you browse the web quickly. You can even use it on all your devices and keep your browsing history and favorites synced up. Built on the same technology as Chrome, Microsoft Edge has additional built-in features like Startup boost and Sleeping tabs, which boost your browsing experience with world class performance and speed that are optimized to work best with Windows. Microsoft Edge security and privacy features such as Microsoft Defender SmartScreen, Password Monitor, InPrivate search, and Kids Mode help keep you and your loved ones protected and secure online. Microsoft Edge has features to keep both you and your family protected. Enable content filters and access activity reports with your Microsoft Family Safety account and experience a kid-friendly web with Kids Mode. The new Microsoft Edge is now compatible with your favorite extensions, so it’s easy to personalize your browsing experience. Microsoft Edge 149.0.4022.52 changelog: Migration to improved V2 architecture for Workspaces. Workspaces, introduced in Edge in 2022, allows users to create durable sets of tabs that can be saved and shared with others. In order to improve reliability and performance of this feature, the following changes are being made: Migrating data for saved Workspaces from OneDrive/SharePoint to Edge Sync service Removing the collaboration/share functionality of this feature For organizations who have disabled Sync through policy, the existing v1 Workspace data will still be migrated to the new architecture. New v2 Workspaces created after migration won't sync across devices and will remain local to each device. This update occurs on a progressive rollout beginning in Edge Stable v145 and will continue rolling out in Edge v149. For more information, see Getting started with Microsoft Edge Workspaces. Feature Updates Passkey Sync for Enterprise Users. Microsoft Edge is introducing support for passkey synchronization for enterprise users, enabling secure, passwordless authentication across devices. Passkeys created in Edge can now be synced seamlessly, improving sign-in experience while maintaining strong security standards. Note: This is a controlled feature rollout. If you don't see this change, check back as we continue the rollout. Enterprise WebView2 runtime downgrade via DowngradeVersion policy. Administrators can temporarily roll back specific applications to a previous WebView2 Evergreen Runtime version (N-1 or N-2) using the new DowngradeVersion policy in msedgewebview2.admx. The Downgrade Version policy allows enterprises to mitigate critical regressions by specifying per-application exe-to-version mappings. The Edge Updater installs the target version side-by-side, and the WebView2 Loader redirects targeted apps accordingly. Downgrades auto-expire with each new WebView2 release: apps pinned to N-1 remain on the same version (now becoming N-2) and will auto-update in the next release, while apps pinned to N-2 will revert to the current Evergreen version. The policy applies only to enterprise-managed devices (domain-joined or MDM-enrolled). For more information, see Microsoft Edge WebView2 Policy Documentation | Microsoft Learn. Collections retirement. Collections has been removed in this update. Users can no longer access or use the feature. To keep saved content, users can export it, or move all pages to Favorites before updating to Microsoft Edge Stable 149. For more information, see Organize your ideas with Collections in Microsoft Edge - Microsoft Support. Modern, unified, and updated Look and Feel. Microsoft Edge has updated the Look and Feel to give customers a unified experience across all of Microsoft AI surfaces including Copilot and Bing. This changes multiple elements of the UX such as spacing, corners, fonts, default colors, etc. Clarify choices surrounding third-party cookie settings. Language under Settings > Privacy, search, and services > Cookies are clarified to better describe the choices users have in managing third-party cookies. Custom primary password retirement. Users are no longer able to create a new custom primary password in Edge Settings edge://settings/autofill/passwords/settings. Any users who are still using a custom primary password will be automatically migrated to device authentication. Additionally, the PrimaryPasswordSetting policy will no longer support the WithCustomPrimaryPassword option. For more information, see Keep your saved passwords private in Microsoft Edge | Microsoft Support. Unifying Copilot Chat policy controls. The Microsoft365CopilotChatIconEnabled policy is the standard for configuring Copilot Chat. Previously, this behavior was controlled by blocking the Copilot extension, either explicitly or by using the * wildcard via the ExtensionSettings or ExtensionInstallBlockList policies. Extension and sidebar policies no longer affect the appearance or functionality of Copilot Chat. Copilot address bar suggestions were also tied to extension policy settings. Starting in Microsoft Edge version 149, admins can use the CopilotAddressBarSuggestionsEnabled policy to manage this behavior. Intune MAM Protected Downloads. The protected downloads feature for Intune MAM is now available for BYOD (Bring Your Own Device) devices, which aren't managed by a tenant. Policy Updates / New policies CopilotAddressBarSuggestionsEnabled - Enable Copilot address bar suggestions CpuPerformanceTierOverride - Override for the CPU performance tier DataUrlInWebWorkerOpaqueOriginEnabled - Enable opaque origins for data URLs in Web Workers DefaultLocalFontsSetting - Default Local Fonts permission setting ForceForegroundPriorityForUrls - Force foreground priority for specific URLs LocalFontsAllowedForUrls - Allow Local Fonts permission on these sites LocalFontsBlockedForUrls - Block Local Fonts permission on these sites Deprecated policies WalletDonationEnabled - Wallet Donation Enabled (deprecated) EdgeWalletEtreeEnabled - Edge Wallet E-Tree Enabled (deprecated) Additional policy changes ForceForegroundPriorityForUrls - ForceForegroundPriorityForOrigins is renamed to ForceForegroundPriorityForUrls OnSecurityEventEnterpriseConnector - Add macOS platform support ProtectedContentIdentifiersAllowed - Remove macOS platform support Download: Microsoft Edge (64-bit) | 193.0 MB (Freeware) Download: Microsoft Edge (32-bit) | 170.0 MB Download: Microsoft Edge (ARM64) | 188.0 MB View: Microsoft Edge Website | Release History Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • User: "But is it good?" Microsoft: "Well, no. But it is less bad."
    • Media Player Classic - Home Cinema 2.7.2 by Razvan Serea Media Player Classic - Home Cinema (MPC-HC) is a free and open-source video and audio player for Windows. MPC-HC is based on the original Guliverkli project (which is no longer maintained) and contains many additional features and bug fixes. As the continuation of the original Media Player Classic, MPC-HC isn’t flashy but it works with nearly any media format. MPC-HC uses DXVA technology to pass decoding operations to your modern video card, enhancing your viewing experience. And MPC-HC supports both physical and software DVDs with menus, chapter navigation, and subtitles. Overview of features A lot of people seem to be unaware of some of the awesome features that have been added to MPC-HC in the past years. Here is a list of useful options and features that everyone should know about: Dark interface Menu > View > Dark Theme When using dark theme it is also possible to change the height of the seekbar and size of the toolbar buttons. Options > Advanced Video preview on the seekbar Options > Tweaks > Show preview on seek bar Adjust playback speed Menu > Play > Playback rate The buttons in the player that control playback rate take a 2x step by default. This can be customized to smaller values (like 10%): Options > Playback > Speed step Adjusting playback speed works best with the internal audio renderer. This also has automatic pitch correction. Options > Playback > Output > Audio Renderer MPC-HC can remember playback position, so you can resume from that point later Options > Player > History You can quickly seek through a video with Ctrl + Mouse Scrollwheel. You can jump to next/previous file in a folder by pressing PageUp/PageDown. You can perform automatic actions at end of file. For example to go to next file or close player. Options > Playback > After Playback (permanent setting) Menu > Play > After Playback (for current file only) A-B repeat - You can loop a segment of a video. Press [ and ] to set start and stop markers. You can rotate/flip/mirror/stretch/zoom the video Menu > View > Pan&Scan This is also easily done with hotkeys (see below). There are lots of keyboard hotkeys and mouse actions to control the player. They can be customized as well. Options > Player > Keys Tip: there is a search box above the table. You can stream videos directly from Youtube and many other video websites You can stream videos directly from Youtube and many other video websites Put yt-dlp.exe or youtube-dl.exe in the MPC-HC installation folder. Then you can open website URLs in the player: Menu > File > Open File/URL You can even download those videos: Menu > File > Save a copy Tip: to be able to download in best quality with yt-dlp/youtube-dl, it is recommended to also put ffmpeg.exe in the MPC-HC folder. Several YDL configuration options are found here: Options > Advanced This includes an option to specify the location of the .exe in case you don't want to put it in MPC-HC folder. Play HDR video This requires using madVR or MPC Video Renderer. After installation these renderers can be selected here: Options > Playback > Output Ability to search for and download subtitles, either automatically or manually (press D): Options > Subtitles > Misc Besides all these (new) features, there have also been many bugfixes and internal improvements in the player in the past years that give better performance and stability. It also has updated internal codecs. Support was added for CUE sheets, WebVTT subtitles, etc. Media Player Classic - Home Cinema 2.7.2 changelog: Updated LAV Filters to version 0.81-23-g6fadb Updated MPC Video Renderer to version 0.10.2.2540 Updated MediaInfo DLL to version 26.05 Updated MPC Audio Renderer Several crash fixes, bug fixes and small improvements. Download: MPC-HC 2.7.2 (x64) | Standalone | ~20.0 MB (Open Source) Download: MPC-HC 2.7.2 (x86) | Standalone Links: MPC-HC Home Page | Screenshot Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
  • Recent Achievements

    • Very Popular
      The Norwegian Drone Pilot earned a badge
      Very Popular
    • Very Popular
      s0nic69 earned a badge
      Very Popular
    • Collaborator
      Asgardi earned a badge
      Collaborator
    • Conversation Starter
      mobandz earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
    • Apprentice
      fernan99 went up a rank
      Apprentice
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      471
    2. 2
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      247
    3. 3
      Skyfrog
      80
    4. 4
      FloatingFatMan
      67
    5. 5
      Michael Scrip
      60
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!