Lost - Season 5

[SuperJediMedia]

I LOVE so much the scene Kate is leaving Aaron, So moving and the music is Great too! :)

[Mathachew Veteran]

Asking what if is natural, but there isn't any point in doing so with longevity in regards to Lost because whatever happened, happened. Because of this, the what ifs will never occur because they never happened. You could think of several dozen what ifs, but in the end it's just aimless pondering that won't clue you in to the mysteries that have been established. So, we get it, you wonder what if, but the fact of the matter is that what if isn't applicable with Lost. Just about any what if scenario could potentially screw up what Lost has established.

[ATGC]

Hoodie? How about: short, skinny, white female with wavy blond hair? Sounds like Claire, does it not? Why not a tall, fat black man if they didn't want us to think of Claire?

I can't believe I didn't see it. It's CLAIRE, look everyone its CLAIRE.

Sorry buddy, but that's a fail theory. Not sure why you are even bothering defending it?

[sundayx Veteran]

Looks more like Eloise Hawking.

[Mathachew Veteran]

I can't believe I didn't see it. It's CLAIRE, look everyone its CLAIRE.

Sorry buddy, but that's a fail theory. Not sure why you are even bothering defending it?

Maybe you missed the part where you see Aaron and the woman from behind. DUH, it's not Claire. Why is this so difficult?

[Rappy Veteran]

Looks like an extra...:p

[SuperJediMedia]

Kate told Jack "I like the old you"

Is she right?

Would the old Jack (Jack from season 1, who Kate liked more) saved Ben even if he knew Ben is evil?

Is the new Jack colder than the old Jack?

[sundayx Veteran]

I think the old Jack would save whoever regardless of their identity. The Jack we have now are more about consequences and trying (too hard) to make things right.

Please remind me though, was it Jack who cured Ben as he was shot from an arrow?

[Mathachew Veteran]

I think the old Jack would save whoever regardless of their identity. The Jack we have now are more about consequences and trying (too hard) to make things right.

Please remind me though, was it Jack who cured Ben as he was shot from an arrow?

Yep, Jack cleaned his wound while Sayid wanted to keep torturing him.

[Hurmoth]

Maybe you missed the part where you see Aaron and the woman from behind. DUH, it's not Claire. Why is this so difficult?

Exactly. It isn't difficult.

[Rappy Veteran]

I loved it when Hurley said about Sayid torturing Ben and how he didn't recognise him and Miles was "hmm" :laugh:

[ATGC]

Maybe you missed the part where you see Aaron and the woman from behind. DUH, it's not Claire. Why is this so difficult?

Yet, you two were asserting it to be Claire.

Hoodie? How about: short, skinny, white female with wavy blond hair? Sounds like Claire, does it not? Why not a tall, fat black man if they didn't want us to think of Claire?

I'm pretty sure that they wanted us to think it was Claire. I'm reading on a lot of other forums people thinking it was her too.

Why would you want to believe that? Claire has already said to keep Aaron off the Island and that is exactly what Kate did. To say the writers wanted to show it in someways to be Claire is idiotic.

Anyway,

next week's preview looks great. I'm thinking John, Ben, Sun and Lapdius will meet with the Others in the temple.

[SuperJediMedia]

Anyone think a HUGE part why Kate is so determined to save young Ben because of young Aaron?

'

[Mathachew Veteran]

No no no, we're saying the writers wanted us to think of Claire, we're not saying the woman was Claire. Crazier things have happened on this show, so this is far from idiotic and perfectly in line with said crazier things.

[sundayx Veteran]

It's been so long since we've seen Claire, and the moment shown her holding Aaron was so brief, I certainly wouldn't have associated the figure as Claire.

[ATGC]

No no no, we're saying the writers wanted us to think of Claire, we're not saying the woman was Claire. Crazier things have happened on this show, so this is far from idiotic and perfectly in line with said crazier things.

No, they didn't want us to think it was Claire. They put that scene in order for the next scene with Kate and Cassidy and eventually Kate and Carole Littleton.

[Mathachew Veteran]

No, they didn't want us to think it was Claire. They put that scene in order for the next scene with Kate and Cassidy and eventually Kate and Carole Littleton.

And you know for a fact that they didn't want us to think of Claire based on....?

If the woman didn't have features that matched Claire, I would agree, but that's not the case. The musical tones when Kate was looking at the woman (indicating the oddity or weirdness of the situation, typical of those situations in Lost), the other mentions of Claire throughout the episode, and Claire being the reason Kate went back, I think the argument is settled.

Just because you didn't think of it doesn't mean the writers weren't trying to make us think it. It makes perfect sense for it to be the case considering all of the above.

[SuperJediMedia]

Remind me of the conversation a couple years ago in an episode between Young Ben and Richard?

Was young Ben looking for Ghost Mom or something, if I remember correctly?

And the part that he forgets Everything, but still remember Annie is Odd, hmmm? Maybe he Only forgets about Sayid shoot him to Kate/Sawyer give him to Richard.?

[Rappy Veteran]

Maybe it makes him forget anything bad but keeps the good memories.

[Mathachew Veteran]

I'm thinking it makes him forget recent memories.

[ATGC]

And you know for a fact that they didn't want us to think of Claire based on....?

Based on...

1. Claire already came to Kate and told her not bring Aaron back to the Island.

2. They put that scene in for character development on why Kate finally managed to give back Aaron after 3 years.

If the woman didn't have features that matched Claire, I would agree, but that's not the case. The musical tones when Kate was looking at the woman (indicating the oddity or weirdness of the situation, typical of those situations in Lost), the other mentions of Claire throughout the episode, and Claire being the reason Kate went back, I think the argument is settled.

Kate was looking oddly at her because Kate knew it was a kidnapper... the blonde chick even passed the store manager.

[Hurmoth]

Based on...

1. Claire already came to Kate and told her not bring Aaron back to the Island.

2. They put that scene in for character development on why Kate finally managed to give back Aaron after 3 years.

Kate was looking oddly at her because Kate knew it was a kidnapper... the blonde chick even passed the store manager.

You are wrong. Deal with it.

Lostpedia states, "While at the store, she briefly loses Aaron and finds him walking with a woman, who from behind looks like Claire. Kate is reunited with Aaron at the store, and goes to visit Cassidy again."

Why can't you accept that the writers did this to make us think it was Claire for just a moment. That was the reason Kate had that look on her face. She realized he isn't her son and that it was time to start telling the truth. That scene is the pivotal moment that makes her realize she needed to go back to the island.

[Richard Hammond]

I dont think they put it in so the viewers would think it was claire, i think they did it so Kate would think it was Claire.

[Mathachew Veteran]

I dont think they put it in so the viewers would think it was claire, i think they did it so Kate would think it was Claire.

If for Kate, then why not for us too? Seems like they'd go hand in hand, wouldn't it?

[ThePitt]

Kate told Jack "I like the old you"

and Jack to Kate

<smirk>

"You dont like the old me, Kate"

<stares at her eyes and back to his sandwitch>

That was what make the whole episode to me.

I only hope that any mod dont get ****ed off at me but they were playing with 'teen' warm quadrangle of love for so long with people that is actually more than 40 years old, that... I dont know, the ppl actually like it.

They all looks really aged by now. Kate (and I know is natural) dont even looks like before. All that botox are actually destroying her face.

In the other hand, the other part I like was when Hugo was talking with the other guy about the timetravel. Probably there is a hope in there, but they ruin the thing when they use the so called resource "he wont be the same and he wont recall nothing of all of this", and the show back to its standards.

Lets keep watching and see what happend.

I miss claire and mr eko.