Windows Phone Review from an Android Dev

By fusi0n
in Member Reviews

 Share

Recommended Posts

Grand Master

fusi0n

Posted
Posted

Windows Phone Review, from an Android Dev

 

Most of everyone on Neowin knows that I strongly dislike Microsoft?s new direction with Windows and Windows Phone. A while back I commented on the forums that Windows Mobile is horrible and that I had used it for half a day and sold it..  Then someone rightfully commented back, ?How do you really know if you like something after using it for two hours?. With the expectation of my of wife, they make a really good point J

 

I bought a Lumina 900 and went to the beach.. Leaving my Galaxy S4 at home, a phone that I know so well, I make custom roms for it.  This will be the ultimate test drive?

 

At first, I really hated that I left my S4 at home because I really did not like how the interface works at all.

 

Build Quality: Hulk/10

The build quality of the Lumina 900 is by far the best of any Smart Phone I have ever used. 

 

I took the phone in the pools with me, taking pictures of my nephew (3 Y.O), took it in the ocean. I felt safe enough with the phone to take it 5 or so feet deep. The phone kept getting splashed and never skipped a beat..

 

When not in the pool or ocean, I kept the phone out connected to my wireless Bluetooth speaker in the HOT sun.. My Nexus 4 wouldn?t survive 30 minutes before shutting off because of heat.  The phone was also connected to wifi the entire time, never missed a beat.

 

This phone was basically abused and survived without a scratch..

 

 

Windows Phone 7.8 7/10

It really took some time to get used to it.. Still not 100% and don?t think I will ever truly will.

 

Getting to settings like the Wifi is pain and I feel like it should be much easier..  I understand you just have to click and scroll and only takes a few seconds.. but on an Android device it is much more quick to access system settings.

 

The interface started to grow on a bit after messing around with it.. The tiles are a cool concept for a phone and when setup correctly it can save you some time.

 

The Marketplace was a lot better than I expected.. It isn?t quite up to speed like the stores on I OS or Android.. I am sure with time, it will be much improved..  I was able to Download Spotify, so that made me happy.. Other apps like Digitally Imported could not be found, but no biggie..  They say it is coming soon.. I am sure other apps will be ported over to WinMo as it gets bigger.

 

Screen: 8/10

I am conflicted with the screen.. While I feel like it could be MUCH more clearer.. the fact that you can read it in direct sun light is amazing.. The image quality just doesn?t do it for me.. S4 and iPhone 5 is much better? With that said, both of those phones are newer than the Lumina 900 and is to be expected..

 

Camera: 9/10

The camera is really awesome.. One of my favorite features and it isn?t due to the image quality of the pictures either.. I really like how there is a hardware dedicated button for the Camera.. It makes it much more convenient and you are more inclined to use it more. Huge fan of the Camera..

 

Speed:

Very snappy for a phone.. I can?t compare it to other WinMo 7.8 Phones, but I can tell you that it is on par with my S4 with how fast applications open..

 

 

Conclusion:

The phone took me for a surprise really.. It grew on me.. I won?t be using it has a main phone because of all the different apps I use and I enjoy making custom ROMs for the S4..  The new WinMo will be great after it matures a few years.. It took Android a few years to where it is today and I feel like that is the case for WinMo 7.8.. It will be very interesting to see how this platform grows.. I am attempted to get me a 920 now though: P

Grand Master

+Fahim S. MVC

Posted
  • MVC
Posted

At the risk of sounding picky Windows Mobile and Windows Phone are not the same thing. Version 7 and beyond is Windows Phone, Windows Mobile is before version 7.

Furthermore, the version and handset you are reviewing ate somewhat old and things have moved on.

  • jakem1, BajiRav and mjedi7
  • Like 3
Grand Master

fusi0n

Posted
  • Author
Posted

At the risk of sounding picky Windows Mobile and Windows Phone are not the same thing. Version 7 and beyond is Windows Phone, Windows Mobile is before version 7.

Furthermore, the version and handset you are reviewing ate somewhat old and things have moved on.

Thanks for the feedback..

Grand Master

Max Norris

Posted
Posted

Pretty much agree with this review.. really boils down to what you're doing with it.  As a phone in general, I'm very pleased with my 900.  Fast, stable, and does the job nicely.  The ecosystem isn't as big as Androids yet obviously, as the market share slowly grows (which it's mostly doing) it'll get better, if you're wanting everything right now you're probably better off going the Android route. I have two phones, one for work, one is my personal phone.  (When I'm off the job, I'm off, no calls, no texts, nada.) To me anyway, Windows Phone "feels" more like a fast, streamlined phone, where my HTC One feels more like a small tablet that just so happens to also make phone calls, if that makes sense.  Upgrading to a WP8 phone is on my to-do, I'm sold on the platform.  Very easy to develop for too, same language, IDE, etc as my other projects.

  • SierraSonic
  • Like 1
Grand Master

BajiRav

Posted
Posted

Getting to settings like the Wifi is pain and I feel like it should be much easier.. I understand you just have to click and scroll and only takes a few seconds.. but on an Android device it is much more quick to access system settings.

With all due respect, you find this a problem because you are used to toggling these things on Android. You can set your wifi once and not care about it until you are at a place where you want to connect. The phone will prompt you in that case.
Grand Master

Noir Angel

Posted
Posted

So will an Android phone if you're near an open network. If the network you're using isn't open you will have to go into the settings menu once to connect to it, then it will automatically connect when you're next in range.

 

I'm pretty sure the OP's post was in reference to the annoyance of getting into the menu not the actual functionality of the wifi

  • 6 months later...
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Posts

    • Microsoft OneDrive is getting a simple yet much needed feature

      By hellowalkman · Posted

      Microsoft OneDrive is getting a simple yet much needed feature by Sayan Sen Microsoft has been steadily expanding OneDrive’s file management capabilities over the years, including for shared content and shortcuts, although it has had its flaws, too. The cloud storage platform introduced support for folder shortcuts several years ago, allowing users to pin frequently accessed shared folders from OneDrive, SharePoint, and Teams. Now, Microsoft is refining that experience further with a new way to organize those shortcuts as revealed in a recent Microsoft 365 roadmap addition. Previously, shortcuts added through the “Add shortcut to My files” option would appear alongside all other files and folders in the root of a user's OneDrive. And although it's meant to be useful, this approach could also create clutter along the way, especially for heavy users who may have to work with large numbers of shared folders across multiple projects and teams on their systems. This is where Microsoft’s latest feature comes in, as it is looking to address this inconvenience by giving users the option to place new shortcuts inside a dedicated “Shortcuts” folder instead. The feature is designed to keep shortcut links organized into a single location instead of scattering throughout the main OneDrive directory. Hence, the idea is to make navigation and usability easier and simpler. The first time a user chooses this option, OneDrive will automatically create the folder, and to help make it stand out from the other folders, the Shortcuts folder will have a distinct visual identity featuring a unique color and a building-style icon. That being said, the new Shortcuts will behave just like any other folder in OneDrive, and as such, users will be able to move it to a different location, rename it, share it with others, or remove it entirely if they prefer a different structure. You can view the entry on the Microsoft 365 roadmap website here. Currently, the feature is in the "in development" phase, but the tech giant expects the rollout to start next month (July 2026). Do keep in mind, though, that new feature rollouts often get delayed.
    • VS Code 1.123 introduces massive upgrades for persistent AI developer workflows

      By zikalify · Posted

      VS Code 1.123 introduces massive upgrades for persistent AI developer workflows by Paul Hill Microsoft has just released Visual Studio Code 1.123 alongside its annual developer conference, Build 2026. This release, as always, has a heavy focus on advanced AI agent integration and making the built-in browser more robust. Notably, this update brings big sync changes that keep your AI agents persistent across sessions. With this update, VS Code now supports cross-machine syncing for chat histories, touched files, repository contexts, and related PRs via GitHub accounts, tying users even more into Microsoft’s developer ecosystem. This update also introduces the new /chronicle command that allows you to query past sessions using natural language, generate instant standup reports, and get personal productivity insights. Microsoft has also made some improvements to network-dependent operations, it explains: “When a terminal command that is run by a local agent requires access to domains that are not configured as allowed domains, the command is automatically retried inside the sandbox with unrestricted network access. After that, if it still fails, it falls back to unsandboxed execution. This allows network-dependent operations such as git fetch to finish, while keeping filesystem protections in place.” Microsoft has not stopped there; in this update, it also allows developers to drag, drop, and pin multiple agent sessions side-by-side for easy code comparisons in real-time. It also introduces the Research Agent, accessible via /research. This is a read-only, depth-optimized tool that gets data from the web, local codebase, and GitHub to give you a Markdown report on complex APIs or unfamiliar code. Now, let’s talk about the integrated browser and some security enhancements. VS Code 1.123 features enhanced screenshot capture tools that allow for targeted Area Screenshots and Full Page Screenshots to send layout context instantly to AI chat. The address bar has also been revamped, supporting favorite pages and tab management. Finally, on the security front, this update introduces a safety-first two-hour delay on third-party extension auto-updates to safeguard against compromised or buggy releases. This release is now available for Windows, Mac, and Linux. If you have VS Code, keep an eye out for the update availability notification. If you still don’t have VS Code, you can get it here.
    • New Surface Pro with Qualcomm Snapdragon X2 leaks ahead of announcement

      By dirtyvu · Posted

      I'm hoping with the Surface Pro 12, I can use either USB-C for my Xreal One Pro glasses. With my Surface Pro 11 OLED X Elite, I have to plug them into the top port. The bottom port will power it, but nothing shows on the screen. Maybe it's my setting. When I plug in the glasses, I have it output only to the glasses. So maybe I need to turn on both displays with it in the top port, then switch the glasses to the bottom port and set it to output only to the glasses. And then hopefully Windows remembers the settings for either the top port and bottom port (one of the awesome features of Windows where it remembers the exact configuration when plugging in external monitors.
    • New Surface Pro with Qualcomm Snapdragon X2 leaks ahead of announcement

      By +samw61 · Posted

      Forgive my ignorance, but the only difference I see here is that a USB-A is now a USB-C, so there are two of them. For the modern age (and I'd argue since 2020), most products would now come with USB-C as an option, if not the default. Display, charging, devices, etc on TWO connectors, sometimes all combined! So having 2 of those powerful ports is great for something this size! Meanwhile my Surface Pro (5) has a single USB-A port which I cannot even get display out to, instead relying on some Surface Connect dock which I don't have. That is a poor experience, not to mention expensive and not compatible with other devices. Thank God USB-C is mainstream!
    • New Surface Pro with Qualcomm Snapdragon X2 leaks ahead of announcement

      By dirtyvu · Posted

      wow. that color finally comes to Surface Pro. was always a little jelly when a friend had the sandstone Surface Laptop. I wonder how different this dune is from the sandstone. I'll be getting the dune version. always thought black and platinum were a little boring. I'll still have access to my blue Surface Pro 11 as it'll be a hand-me-down.

  • Recent Achievements

    • One Month Later
      B2Proxy earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • One Year In
      MadMung0 earned a badge
      One Year In
    • Week One Done
      jefred earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Apprentice
      JoeyNeo went up a rank
      Apprentice
    • Week One Done
      oliviaexpo earned a badge
      Week One Done

  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      482
    2. 2
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      227
    3. 3
      Skyfrog
      70
    4. 4
      FloatingFatMan
      60
    5. 5
      Nick H.
      54
    Show More

  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!