Do you perfer manual or automatic transmission?


Manual or automatic transmission?  

170 members have voted

  1. 1. What do you perfer to drive in a car using manual transmission or automatic transmission?



Recommended Posts

An automatic gearbox is for people who just want to get from A to B. A manual gearbox is for people who want to drive!

 

Seriously though I have no issues with changing gear, just comes so naturally that I don't even think about it. Driving an automatic I'm conscious about what my left foot is doing! 

/sigh, pretty idiotic thing to say. You can still be a car enthusiast and drive a car with an automatic transmission. Hell, most of the world still drives manuals anyways (most of Asia, South America, Africa, etc.), so your post is inaccurate. The fact is there are automatic transmissions out there that will shift way faster than a human being can with a manual transmission. Even Porsche with its newest GT3 is going PDK only. But, ultimately choice is a good thing, so I wish more manufacturers would offer both transmission options (at least in performance oriented cars).

/sigh, pretty idiotic thing to say. You can still be a car enthusiast and drive a car with an automatic transmission. Hell, most of the world still drives manuals anyways (most of Asia, South America, Africa, etc.), so your post is inaccurate. The fact is there are automatic transmissions out there that will shift way faster than a human being can with a manual transmission. Even Porsche with its newest GT3 is going PDK only. But, ultimately choice is a good thing, so I wish more manufacturers would offer both transmission options (at least in performance oriented cars).

 

My point was the driving manual is far more engaging and dare I say it exciting than driving an automatic. It also provides far better control in icy/snowy conditions but thats not to say modern automatics are competent enough to deal with these weather conditions, automatic gearboxes are great but most car enthusiasts prefer manual simply to have the control and feel engaged with the engine.

To chime in on the "drivers gearbox" it is actually 50/50 split. The gearboxes they use in the high-end cars is more accurately described as an "automatic manaul" gearbox. (wiki semi-automatic transmission) This is a traditional manual with a clutch (autos don't have a clutch) however for these SAT gearboxes the clutch is automatically actuated. These offer drastically quicker gear changes than either auto or manual - down to fractions of a second. In terms of performance, a "well trained" driver would have the slowest performance in an auto, followed by better in a manual, and then significantly improved times with a SAT gearbox.

 

Back on topic however. When I was driving every day to work, for 1h in stop-start traffic I was VERY happy to have an automatic. It was easier to drive, and less wear and tear on the car (very tempting to ride the clutch in stop start traffic!). Now that I'm taking the bus to work (new job!) I am looking at getting a manaual, seeing as I don't drive often, and when I do it is because I want to drive.

Hello,

Not really. Manual cars are driven by using your left foot for the clutch and the right for brake and acceleration. So in an automatic car I'd place my left foot on the brake by habit and that could be very dangerous. When my reflex strikes I'd automatically floor the brake pedal and the acceleration pedal which will turn my engine off. People have told me one way to deal with this is by sitting onto you left foot and thus ensuring I'll use only right.

I dont know....I dont see/feel it the same way but you are free to have your argument :)

 

 

An automatic gearbox is for people who just want to get from A to B. A manual gearbox is for people who want to drive!

Ive heard that statement so many times I find it so meaningless.

"Driving" is a lot more fun with automatic as you have one less element to worry about and more time to drive (and speed if thats your sort of thing). Manual is just such a time waste.

dont understand how its a time waste. Its not like cause its manual you spend half hour more driving than automatic. I have drove automatic once, and to be honest I was scared cause I was so used to manual, i thought that the car was going to stall if I stop. This made me concentrate on my left foot to tell it not to do anything.

It really depends on the type of driving, leisure drive through the country manual, traffic or snow automatic.

with an automatic I don't have to concentrate on anything other that steering and gas...with a manual there is gear selection based on environmental variables plus clutch grab. Sure I can drive a stick as good as or better than most autos, but it does require a thought process and I would have to get in a stick again in certain environments to figure that out again, besides every car is slightly different in center of gravity, power, and traction.

Manual = fun, fun and more fun and it doesn't have to be at 100km/h, its just always fun.

Auto/DSG/Steptronic/anything that doesn't have a 3rd pedal = dull = easier to text and drive while eating a hamburger *cough*

 

Not learning to drive a manual is really missing out on something special whether you are a 'car person' or not. Driving/commuting is a substantial part of our lives. Once you learn and still hate it, fine, but it's worth to find the answer rather than live in ignorance.

Manual = fun, fun and more fun and it doesn't have to be at 100km/h, its just always fun.

Auto/DSG/Steptronic/anything that doesn't have a 3rd pedal = dull = easier to text and drive while eating a hamburger *cough*

You need to drive cars that cost above 80k dollars. I.don't need to get into a gtr to know that is fun, sorry no third pedal.

Sorry, just being obnoxious and laughing at the thought of high MPGs. I think I've owned one car that got over 20 MPG regularly.

Most fuel efficient car I ever had was a 2009 Ford Focus.  It had a 5 speed manual transmission.  In town driving it averaged about 35 mpg, and on the interstate doing between 60 and 70 mph it would get between 50 and 60 mpg.  It wasn't a hybrid or anything either, just a regular gasoline engine.

Hello,

I dont know....I dont see/feel it the same way but you are free to have your argument :)

 

 

Ive heard that statement so many times I find it so meaningless.

"Driving" is a lot more fun with automatic as you have one less element to worry about and more time to drive (and speed if thats your sort of thing). Manual is just such a time waste.

To each their own.  I find the driving experience to be far less fun when just pressing a pedal.  I want better control of the gears.

You need to drive cars that cost above 80k dollars. I.don't need to get into a gtr to know that is fun, sorry no third pedal.

 

:) ... sure that is a different level of cars, and don't have first hand experience but on the road for everyday commuting I prefer simpler cars (Manual+RWD is all you really need), even my M3, was hard to really enjoy unless doing seriously illegal stuff.

  • 2 weeks later...

Hello,

Manual = fun, fun and more fun and it doesn't have to be at 100km/h, its just always fun.

Auto/DSG/Steptronic/anything that doesn't have a 3rd pedal = dull = easier to text and drive while eating a hamburger *cough*

 

Not learning to drive a manual is really missing out on something special whether you are a 'car person' or not. Driving/commuting is a substantial part of our lives. Once you learn and still hate it, fine, but it's worth to find the answer rather than live in ignorance.

I still don't see why manual is fun. What kind of roads do you drive in? Maybe thats why.
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • AI is the beginning, wait until real robots replace more jobs, specifically jobs that require physical work.
    • AI is indeed eliminating jobs, and Oracle just proved it by Hamid Ganji There’s no question that AI has become the hottest trend in workplaces, and every company is trying to adopt AI-driven solutions across its operations. While some industry leaders repeatedly say AI won’t lead to massive layoffs, recent data suggest that AI is actually one of the main reasons some companies are reducing their workforce. According to Oracle’s annual regulatory filing, the company has laid off about 21,000 employees, or 13% of its workforce, amid increasing AI adoption. “The adoption and deployment of AI technologies across our operations have resulted, and may continue to result, in reductions to our workforce,” Oracle said in the filing. The software giant now has approximately 141,000 full-time employees, a notable decrease from 162,000 during the same period last year. Restructuring expenses, including severance payments, cost Oracle $1.84 billion in fiscal 2026. Additionally, around 49,000 Oracle employees were based in the U.S., while approximately 92,000 were employed internationally. Like many other companies, Oracle has fully embraced AI and concentrated much of its efforts on the technology. The company is also a key participant in the United States’ $500 billion Stargate Project, which aims to build multiple AI data centers across the country. When it comes to AI adoption and its impact on the workforce, opinions remain divided. NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang, whose company has been one of the biggest beneficiaries of the AI boom, recently said in an interview that attributing job cuts to AI is a “lazy” narrative. “The narrative that connects AI to job loss, for many of the CEOs that are doing it – it is just too lazy. AI has just arrived, how is it possible they're already losing jobs?” Huang said. However, statistics and recent reports tell a different story. According to Layoffs.fyi, 196 tech companies have laid off about 119,800 employees so far this year. Reducing staff and replacing roles with AI agents could become one of the most significant trends in the job market in the years ahead.
    • Zoom Workplace 7.1.0.41345 by Razvan Serea Zoom Workplace for Windows is a reliable video conferencing tool that makes it easy to connect and collaborate. With features like messaging, file sharing, and app integrations, it’s designed to streamline teamwork. You’ll get high-quality audio and video, strong security with end-to-end encryption, and an intuitive interface—all of which help remote teams and businesses stay productive and connected. Zoom Workplace key features: High-Definition Video & Audio: Provides clear, reliable communication for virtual meetings. End-to-End Encryption: Ensures secure communication with strong data protection. Multi-Factor Authentication: Adds an extra layer of security for user accounts. Integration with Productivity Apps: Supports seamless integration with Microsoft Office, Google Workspace, and more. File Sharing: Easily share files during meetings for efficient collaboration. Real-Time Messaging: Enables team chat for ongoing communication. Collaborative Whiteboarding: Allows teams to brainstorm and collaborate visually. Webinar Support: Host large webinars with interactive features. Administrative Controls: Manage user permissions, meeting settings, and security features. Cloud Storage: Automatically stores meetings and files in the cloud for easy access. Cross-Platform Support: Available on Windows, macOS, and mobile devices. Meeting features: Virtual Backgrounds: Customize your background for meetings to maintain privacy or enhance professionalism. Touch Up My Appearance: Automatically smoothens skin tone for a more polished video appearance. Breakout Rooms: Divide meetings into smaller sessions for group discussions or workshops. Live Transcription: Automatically generate real-time captions during meetings for accessibility. Zoom Apps: Integrate third-party applications directly into Zoom for enhanced functionality. Meeting Reactions: Participants can use emojis for quick, non-verbal feedback during meetings. Polling: Conduct live polls during meetings to gather instant feedback from participants. Attention Tracking: Monitors participant attention during meetings to ensure engagement. Closed Captioning: Enable manual or automatic captions for a more inclusive experience. Webinar Replay: Record and share webinars with analytics for audience engagement. Download: Zoom 64-bit | 145.0 MB (Free, paid upgrade available) Links: Zoom Website | Zoom ARM64 | Zoom Installers | Release Notes Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • UK funds £60M AI labs to challenge US tech dominance with open-source models by Paul Hill The UK government has awarded £60 million to Oxford University and University College London to help keep the country in the AI race by focusing on open-source, low-hardware alternatives. This is in stark contrast to the expensive, closed-source, and high-hardware-requirement models being created in the United States and elsewhere. The money will be shared among two new academic research labs over six years to help them redesign the fundamental mathematics and architectures of AI to help the UK reduce its reliance on a handful of US tech firms. Commenting on the development, AI Minister Kanishka Narayan said: Initially, the government planned to fund just one lab with a £40 million investment, but with this update, two labs will now get access to a larger pool of funds. The labs are expected to invest in the top AI researchers at every career stage, with £2 million per lab being set aside for hiring at least ten doctoral students. The government hopes that this will grow the UK’s talent in the field of AI. The labs are also expected to work closely with the leaders in British AI research, such as the Alan Turing Institute and UKRI’s AI research hubs. This will allow the various teams to collaborate and create new solutions faster than they could alone. This development is pretty interesting for a number of reasons, chiefly that it could create a long-term challenge for US tech firms if these labs successfully scale these open-source architectures that bypass the proprietary ecosystems. It could also give British businesses and public sector organizations access to AI features without paying high licensing fees to foreign providers or needing to invest in specialized server infrastructure.
  • Recent Achievements

    • One Month Later
      nates earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      Almohandis earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Rookie
      dorf went up a rank
      Rookie
    • First Post
      mike_rumble earned a badge
      First Post
    • Dedicated
      tuben earned a badge
      Dedicated
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      464
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      182
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      97
    4. 4
      Michael Scrip
      89
    5. 5
      neufuse
      70
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!