Windows Technical Preview  

1031 members have voted

  1. 1. On a scale of 1-5, 1 being worst, 5 being best. What do you think of Windows 10 from the leaks so far?

    • 5.Great, best OS ever
      156
    • 4. Pretty Good, needs a lot of minor tweaks
      409
    • 3. OK, Needs a few major improvements, some minor ones
      168
    • 2. Fine, Needs a lot of major improvements
      79
    • 1.Poor, Needs too many improvements, all hope is lost, never going to use it
      41
  2. 2. Based on the recent leaks by Neowin and Winfuture.de, my next OS upgrade will be?

    • Windows 10
      720
    • Windows 8
      20
    • Windows 7
      48
    • Sticking with XP
      3
    • OSX Yosemite
      35
    • Linux
      24
    • Sticking with OSX Mavericks
      3
  3. 3. Should Microsoft give away Windows 10 for free?

    • Yes for Windows 8.1 Users
      305
    • Yes for Windows 7 and above users
      227
    • Yes for Vista and above users
      31
    • Yes for XP and above users
      27
    • Yes for all Windows users
      192
    • No
      71


Recommended Posts

Which is fine... for phones and small tablets. Not for the SP3 or touch screen laptops.

 

How is moving your hand to the center of the screen for task view easier than swiping in from the left edge to cycle through apps? Not better.

 

Taskbar? Now apps are going to use that back button more and more :( you will have to keep the bar open, app controls now clutter the UI with a hamburger menu.

 

Right action center >> this is better, but the time and date are not shown and what about battery and the volume and brightness and wifi from Charms? Much easier. Search from the right side? Easier with charms. There was a start button in charms, now it requires the taskbar :(

Move the task bar to the right or left side problem solved! LMAO

Move the task bar to the right or left side problem solved! LMAO

How does that solve anything? Explain. My SP3 does not need an old fashioned taskbar with a ton of wasted space anywhere on the screen where touch will be not ideal. Useless transparency effect? Auto-hiding the taskbar doesn't work anymore because it interferes with app controls and always appears on when Start is open. 

The charms bar frequently would slide in when trying to close a window with a mouse. Good riddance. You can get most of its functionality by using winkeys - which I'm sure there are finger touching patterns/gestures to replicate those if you don't want to get a cheap bluetooth keyboard and use that. Or use the on screen keyboard's winkey. 

 

The charms bar was a usability nightmare. 

 

http://www.cnet.com/how-to/how-to-use-windows-10-without-the-charms-bar/

do you realise that there was an option to disable charms bar corner triggers? just because someone is ignorant about it, it's no reason to remove the whole feature. If Windows 8.1 had start menu like in early 10 builds and automatic settings switch upon installation based on the type of the system (no touchscreen - startmenu/ touchscreen present - startscreen, and so on), most of the problems with it would be gone.

The charms bar frequently would slide in when trying to close a window with a mouse. Good riddance. You can get most of its functionality by using winkeys - which I'm sure there are finger touching patterns/gestures to replicate those if you don't want to get a cheap bluetooth keyboard and use that. Or use the on screen keyboard's winkey. 

 

The charms bar was a usability nightmare. 

 

http://www.cnet.com/how-to/how-to-use-windows-10-without-the-charms-bar/

It should not be there for mice, but for tablet mode yes. Opening the new notification center should be an option either by using the charms bar or without the charms and just sliding them in.

Which is fine... for phones and small tablets. Not for the SP3 or touch screen laptops.

 

How is moving your hand to the center of the screen for task view easier than swiping in from the left edge to cycle through apps? Not better.

 

Taskbar? Now apps are going to use that back button more and more :( you will have to keep the bar open, app controls now clutter the UI with a hamburger menu.

 

Right action center >> this is better, but the time and date are not shown and what about battery and the volume and brightness and wifi from Charms? Much easier. Search from the right side? Easier with charms. There was a start button in charms, now it requires the taskbar :(

 

Hold on, you don't need to hit the task view button, the swipe from the left gesture still works, the button is there for mouse users really, and it's not even in the center, it should be offset to the left of the screen.

 

The back button isn't needed really, not on the tablet as much as the phone, but it's there to help you.  What current apps need it exactly? None that I know of, but future ported apps that hit the store might.  So they either put the back arrow in the app, or make it a universal button on the bar, either way you'll need to have one somewhere.

 

As far as the taskbar goes, I don't see this as any different from having to use, say, the app bar in 8.x, specially when you set it to be hidden and swipe up to show it/use it.  It's all about the default and where you want it.    The start button in charms was/is pretty redundant, most if not all windows devices have a hardware start button, look at the SP3 and the issues that caused, it's really not needed anymore.   Now you can just swipe up and hit the start button on the left, again, it's up to you what the taskbar does regardless of the default.

Hold on, you don't need to hit the task view button, the swipe from the left gesture still works, the button is there for mouse users really, and it's not even in the center, it should be offset to the left of the screen.

 

The back button isn't needed really, not on the tablet as much as the phone, but it's there to help you.  What current apps need it exactly? None that I know of, but future ported apps that hit the store might.  So they either put the back arrow in the app, or make it a universal button on the bar, either way you'll need to have one somewhere.

 

As far as the taskbar goes, I don't see this as any different from having to use, say, the app bar in 8.x, specially when you set it to be hidden and swipe up to show it/use it.  It's all about the default and where you want it.    The start button in charms was/is pretty redundant, most if not all windows devices have a hardware start button, look at the SP3 and the issues that caused, it's really not needed anymore.   Now you can just swipe up and hit the start button on the left, again, it's up to you what the taskbar does regardless of the default.

No for task view I was talking about how swiping in from the left shrinks all the windows into the center of the screen. Which, when holding a tablet,  is cumbersome. 

 

For the back button, I'm sure I will get used to it, but the taskbar should not be the sole place for a back button since I many do not want a taskbar in tablet mode.

 

They need to fix the task view and notification center to make it more elegant.

 

This is what Sinofsky tweeted today: :)

Javascript is not enabled or refresh the page to view.

Click here to view the Tweet
  • Like 2

Hold on, you don't need to hit the task view button, the swipe from the left gesture still works, the button is there for mouse users really, and it's not even in the center, it should be offset to the left of the screen.

 

The back button isn't needed really, not on the tablet as much as the phone, but it's there to help you.  What current apps need it exactly? None that I know of, but future ported apps that hit the store might.  So they either put the back arrow in the app, or make it a universal button on the bar, either way you'll need to have one somewhere.

 

As far as the taskbar goes, I don't see this as any different from having to use, say, the app bar in 8.x, specially when you set it to be hidden and swipe up to show it/use it.  It's all about the default and where you want it.    The start button in charms was/is pretty redundant, most if not all windows devices have a hardware start button, look at the SP3 and the issues that caused, it's really not needed anymore.   Now you can just swipe up and hit the start button on the left, again, it's up to you what the taskbar does regardless of the default.

 

My thoughts precisely as to how the task bar in 10 will evolve.  I can't see how the task bar will evolve in any other way than being more like Windows Phone.

This is what Sinofsky tweeted today: :)

Listening to anything Sinofsky has to say is just insulting to Windows users everywhere. He single-handedly ruined what could of been a great OS with Windows 8. 

As far as the taskbar goes, I don't see this as any different from having to use, say, the app bar in 8.x, specially when you set it to be hidden and swipe up to show it/use it. 

What? App bar on existing apps and taskbar in Windows 10 have completely different functions. How do I get the commands (that are hidden in appbar by default) on my apps that haven't gone with stupid hamburger menu yet? On mouse and keyboard with right click or context-menu button, in other words in one simple action. With touch though now I have to swipe from the top, tap that little hamburger menu in the corner, tap App bar. This is such a PITA, they could do a simple tap-and-hold (equivalent of right click, and I did feedback on it) to replace swipe from bottom gesture, but no they didn't bother.

Listening to anything Sinofsky has to say is just insulting to Windows users everywhere. He single-handedly ruined what could of been a great OS with Windows 8. 

 

How quickly people forget... he was also responsible for turning Vista into 7.

 

Anyone thinking that it was his sole responsibility that Windows 8 into what they perceive to be a half-cooked product know nothing about product management or managing software projects to a real deadline.

The last thing anyone wants to do is sit a Surface on a desk, and have to constantly flip their arm up and down to manipulate the screen. Why did the horizontal alignment have to be killed off, when it was ergonomically superior?

I want the restoration of Windows 8.1 functionality. There was no reason to remove it. I want to be able to use Windows 10 without the need for a mouse or stylus.

Jesus, they're serious about that taskbar crap, aren't they? SMH.

No, it's 2015, and tablets are everywhere.

The taskbar is compensating for the charms. If you use auto hide, it will work exactly like Windows Phone.

 

Dot once said

 

 

 

 

 

I'm actually kind of happy about the changes...because I do not want to be forced to use a tablet UI (8x) on my desktop.  I friggen hated horizontal scrolling, even more so than the start screen.  Vertical mouse scroll should ? horizontal page scroll.

You have waited a looong time for quoting that post, haven't you? :rofl:
  • Like 2

Ugh, if you hit volume and use scroll wheel, nothing happens. The mouse needs to be over the actual slider. I hate that. 

 

 

Listening to anything Sinofsky has to say is just insulting to Windows users everywhere. He single-handedly ruined what could of been a great OS with Windows 8. 

 

I disagree with this completely. Windows needed to change to be successful, especially the UI and he pulled it off. Yes it was rough around the edges and whatnot, but considering he completely through out the old UI paradigm it was pretty impressive. He's also the guy behind Office 2007/W7, and he started the whole Building Windows 7/8 blogs and opening up the development process to users. 

He probably had his issues, I did hear he was a micro-manager and tough to work for, but he did get ###### done when he was there so w/e. 

Ugh, if you hit volume and use scroll wheel, nothing happens. The mouse needs to be over the actual slider. I hate that. 

 

The volume bar is rather large, is it a big deal? I just used my mouse and it wasn't... Maybe adjust your mouse sensitivity if it takes you too long to move yours! :D

The volume bar is rather large, is it a big deal? I just used my mouse and it wasn't... Maybe adjust your mouse sensitivity if it takes you too long to move yours! :D

Obviously it's not a big deal, but it's an extra movement, why do I have to move my mouse at all? If I click on the button and scroll up/down it should raise/lower the volume as expected. 

You have waited a looong time for quoting that post, haven't you? :rofl:

 

haha...good ol' search.  You can kind a lot of gems...especially in this case "adapt", "desktop", "start menu", "not" comes out with a bunch of prior tirades.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Posts

    • The current Statcoungter desktop numbers has Google Chrome increasing it's market share this past year and currently commanding 75% share. Everybody else is just making up the numbers with even MS Edge losing 3% this past year and has dipped just below 10% share which is staggering considering it's default on every Windows deviced purchased. If these numbers are correct that terrible Edge number is both devastating and embarrassing for MS especially when you add in the terribly low Bing market share. This leads me to ask a couple of questions as the default browser holding just less than 10% market share seems really weird. It used to be that all Chromium browsers were being counted as Google Chrome in some cases.  Is this still happening? Do these high Google Chrome numbers contains some Edge user numbers?
    • Yeah, all web browsers seem to have some junk in them these days. The regular Brave browser has a lot of unnecessary stuff in it, similar to Microsoft Edge, so I don't see any benefits of using Brave over Microsoft Edge if you already have Microsoft Edge fully set up with adblockers and that. The cleanest or best free browser outside of 'Microsoft Edge' I’ve tried so far is 'Opera Air'. It still has some bloat, but nowhere near as much as Brave browser, for example. I have a system wide Adblocking program for Windows 11 that doesn't just blocks ads in the the web browser, but over the whole thing. I don't really need a web browser with an inbuilt adblocker because of that.
    • I have been using Firefox for years.
    • I'd trust open source stuff on github more then closed source binaries from Microsoft.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Rookie
      moog19 went up a rank
      Rookie
    • Mentor
      grik went up a rank
      Mentor
    • Dedicated
      JKR earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • One Year In
      CHUNWEI earned a badge
      One Year In
    • Conversation Starter
      FBSPL earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      491
    2. 2
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      270
    3. 3
      Skyfrog
      75
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      68
    5. 5
      FloatingFatMan
      63
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!