Policy regarding OS X on non-Apple Hardware


Recommended Posts

now i remember on MACworld.com they reviewed the frakenmac. the osx86 mac that you could buy with it pre installed.. would that be illegal if i were to stumble across this site and buy a mackinhackinfranketosh ? and use it?

i uddderstand thats a whole nuther issue in ittitself

As far as I understand how the law works, it would be a breach of the EULA, but you wouldn't be the one committing that breach if you bought it pre-installed. Therefore you wouldn't be suable, but the vendor would be.

Remember folks, it's NOT a criminal offense to breach the terms of an EULA, it's a civil offense. No cops will come knocking on your door, but a lawyer might.

Discussion of OS X on non-Apple hardware is allowed on Neowin. The amendment to the rules was conclusively made after much discussion among our staff. The primary reasoning behind this is a 1984 Federal Court ruling specifically makes it illegal for a company to force their users to install the OS on specific hardware. Which is ultimately the reason we're now allowing this discussion.

Note: Be aware though that Apple has a right to deny you support and service for OS X with a breach of the EULA. Neowin will not be held responsible in the event you void your warranty or support contracts.

Also please be mindful that Neowin still has a strong policy against warez of any kind and thus any discussion on illegally obtained copies of Mac OS X and such will be dealt with accordingly.

In order to differentiate new support threads in the forums, tagging your thread title with [OSx86] is now necessary.

Example: [OSx86] Can't get wireless card to be recognized

We do not intend to remove or amend warnings or other restrictions on accounts for previous violations of this rule because at the time the warning was placed on the account, these were the rules of Neowin.

Thank you for your understanding and patience.

I don't won't to sound like an idiot, but what has american laws have to do with Neowin since it is in Netherlands? Have we all become citizens of america or something?

On another aspect of this, some mods allow people ask about downloading tv programs for people from canada. so does this mean I can post an audio cd in neowin if my country laws says that I can?

btw: Which country laws does Neowin follow when it comes to copyrights? If its american laws, why?

I never could get it to install. I tired several different versions, but it would always just reboot just when it's about to load Darwin. I tried asking on several forums dedicated to this kind of stuff, but no one could ever figure out why as it should be able to install on my system easily.

btw: Which country laws does Neowin follow when it comes to copyrights? If its american laws, why?

Neowin is an LLC, so actually it's a company in America I thought. Therefore they need to follow the rules of the United States.

Also it's not because the founders are from Holland that Neowin should follow the rules of the Netherlands. It depends on the location of your servers.

^Yes indeed. And where is Neowin hosted then?

Well i was wrong a couple of pages back then. I thought it was illegal, but breaking the EULA is not illegal then. Now i want to try OSX86 too :laugh:

But in what forum should i post OSX86 threads?

as it has been stated before by some other posters, the main thing that's worrying me, is that apple will introduce similar methods to activation just like microsoft have with windows.

The beauty of OSX and Mac's was that when you wanted to reinstall the OS you put the disk in and let it install.

Petty arguing over the violation of laws pushed by special interest groups and written by corrupt government officials getting under the table payoffs to limit consumer rights for the purpose of corporate profit. EULAs and "licenses" specifying what you can and cannot do with the product you payed for and own.

I can't help but laugh at all of you playing into the game of greed.

Wowzers... I can't think of anything more well put being said in this forum or media for that matter.

I don't won't to sound like an idiot, but what has american laws have to do with Neowin since it is in Netherlands? Have we all become citizens of america or something?

On another aspect of this, some mods allow people ask about downloading tv programs for people from canada. so does this mean I can post an audio cd in neowin if my country laws says that I can?

btw: Which country laws does Neowin follow when it comes to copyrights? If its american laws, why?

Our servers are hosted in the United States, Neowin is registered as a corporation in the United States... we are bound by the laws of the United States.

How is it illegal to install software you own. You're not stealing anything, only breaking the EULA.

EULA violations have never been tested in a court of law. So, there's no precedent or case history to look at.

Apple is attempting to create a monopoly or at least using monopolistic practices and they are violating fair trade practices, therefore the Apple Eula is illegal.

How is it illegal to install software you own. You're not stealing anything, only breaking the EULA.

EULA violations have never been tested in a court of law. So, there's no precedent or case history to look at.

Apple is attempting to create a monopoly or at least using monopolistic practices and they are violating fair trade practices, therefore the Apple Eula is illegal.

How can a company with less than 50% of the market (way less) be consider a Monopoly. There are other options available on Apple systems, you are not locked into running OS X in anyway... Apple's decision to limit THEIR intellectual property to THEIR equipment is their right and until someone legally challenges, and wins, against the Apple EULA (Not some 80's decision given how the landscape of copyright and IP laws have changed since then) it is still a violation of the EULA to install OS X on anything other than official Apple (or Apple Licensed) hardware.

How can a company with less than 50% of the market (way less) be consider a Monopoly. There are other options available on Apple systems, you are not locked into running OS X in anyway... Apple's decision to limit THEIR intellectual property to THEIR equipment is their right and until someone legally challenges, and wins, against the Apple EULA (Not some 80's decision given how the landscape of copyright and IP laws have changed since then) it is still a violation of the EULA to install OS X on anything other than official Apple (or Apple Licensed) hardware.

Can I read EULA on the box of OS X (when buying)?

Yes: It might be valid and stand a chance in court.

No: It doesn't mean ****.

I think there was a case in part where Microsoft lost in similar fashion?

where is this court decision document that everybody is citing, iv searched and couldn't find it, but i also dont know the *Who VS. *Who either.

and a rulling in 84 ( or whatever year ) vs current Tech i way different, which is why they redid the DMCA

dhan: MS lost a case where they were limiting what could be installed on the OS by manufactures ( OEM's were installing Netscape Communicator instead of IE on the desktop ) not hardware related from what i remember

I never could get it to install. I tired several different versions, but it would always just reboot just when it's about to load Darwin. I tried asking on several forums dedicated to this kind of stuff, but no one could ever figure out why as it should be able to install on my system easily.

wow, you went and bought several versions of OSX and none of them would install on your PC, that must really suck, spending all that and getting now where

How is it illegal to install software you own. You're not stealing anything, only breaking the EULA.

EULA violations have never been tested in a court of law. So, there's no precedent or case history to look at.

Apple is attempting to create a monopoly or at least using monopolistic practices and they are violating fair trade practices, therefore the Apple Eula is illegal.

then again, you could say the same about installing XP on more then one machine, so its that ok to discuss?

<snip>

dhan: MS lost a case where they were limiting what could be installed on the OS by manufactures ( OEM's were installing Netscape Communicator instead of IE on the desktop ) not hardware related from what i remember

I was not talking about the Netscape/DOJ case. I faintly remember someone suing MS because they couldn't read EULA beforehand or something like that.

Apple EULA (Not some 80's decision given how the landscape of copyright and IP laws have changed since then) it is still a violation of the EULA to install OS X on anything other than official Apple (or Apple Licensed) hardware.

Breaking the EULA is a breach of contract, which is a civil matter. Doesn't matter how you try to paint it, it's not illegal.

Nothing illegal about breaking a contract; you can't go to prison for that. It's a purely civil matter, so you can be sued sure, but it's not a matter of breaking the law.

In fact, as the law goes, it's less serious than not paying a parking fine.

Simply put, "a 1984 U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals decision held that a software publisher can't require consumers to run an operating system on a specific type of hardware." The US Supreme Court has refused to hear the case, so at this point it is legal for anyone who owns a copy of OS X (Leopard) to install it on any other hardware. The only thing Apple can do is refuse you support. That's where we come in.

Have you got a link to the entire decision? The other thing I can't find is where other laws such as the dmca come in. As mostly with law there are certain pieces that alow something whilst others forbid it: inconsistency. There's also a chance that this decision is overruled by newer pieces of law and decisions. Were those kind of things also checked?

In other words: are you absolutely sure that this decision from 1984 is the only thing that tells something about OS X on non-Apple hardware? Since it's a bit strange that in 24 years time no one has ever used it against Apple and it's also strange because this decision would affect nearly all electronics in the US in some way (it would mean that every single OS out there has to be crossplatform which is quite impossible).

There's also Darwin which is what OS X uses as a base. Darwin is free and you can run it on a pc if you want to. Specific parts that make up the rest of OS X are not free. So in what regard is Apple not fulfilling that 1984 decision? They've had Darwin for years which you can install on non-Apple hardware.

Full citation is Digidyne Corp. v. Data General Corp., 734 F.2d 1336 (9th Cir 1984), cert denied, 473 U.S. 908 (1985)

DATA GENERAL CORP. v. DIGIDYNE CORP. , 473 U.S. 908 (1985)

The Mac OS X end-user license agreement prohibits its use on hardware other than that sold by Apple. It reads, "You agree not to install, use, or run the Apple software on any non-Apple-labeled computer, or to enable others to do so."

A little legal history now. Way back in 1978, a company by the name of Digidyne brought suit against Data General, alleging that it was restraining trade by "tying" its RDOS operating system to its Nova minicomputer hardware. (Digidyne sold Nova clones.)

The case wound its way through the courts. A 1984 Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals decision held for Digidyne; the case was later denied rehearing by the U.S. Supreme Court.

It was a convoluted court case, but the bottom-line result was that Data General could not prohibit the use of its operating system on someone else's hardware. To use the legal term, you could not "tie" hardware and software. Related cases have involved prohibiting the use of specific supplies (such as punch cards) with a specific vendor's hardware.

Continue reading here.

I believe, and apparently a lot of other people do as well, that this case right here is why Apple hasn't put a stop to the OSx86 Project, the Psystar Mac Clone project and various websites from discussing this. Apple couldn't win without this case first being overturned by the US Supreme Court.

Full citation is Digidyne Corp. v. Data General Corp., 734 F.2d 1336 (9th Cir 1984), cert denied, 473 U.S. 908 (1985)

DATA GENERAL CORP. v. DIGIDYNE CORP. , 473 U.S. 908 (1985)

...

Thanks for the link. (Y)

Put the link in the first post, where it mentions the ruling?

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • This is what I want. Hey Gemini, how do I remove you from all my google products permanently?
    • I would never install install this build before rtm process. only 3 months to go. never install on your daily devices. just wait 3 months.
    • Motrix Next 3.9.6 by Razvan Serea Motrix Next is a modern, open-source cross-platform download manager built as the official next-generation successor to the original Motrix project. It has been completely rewritten using Tauri 2, Vue 3, TypeScript, and Rust, while still relying on the powerful Aria2 download engine for high-speed multi-protocol transfers. The app supports HTTP, HTTPS, FTP, BitTorrent, ED2K and magnet links, offering advanced features like multi-connection acceleration, task scheduling, bandwidth control, and batch download management. With a significantly reduced install size (around 20MB), it focuses on being lightweight, fast, and resource-efficient compared to traditional Electron-based download tools. Designed for Windows, macOS, and Linux, Motrix Next delivers a clean, modern UI inspired by Material Design 3 principles, with smooth animations and a minimal workflow. It improves usability through better download organization, system tray integration, and enhanced torrent handling including selective file downloads and tracker management. Motrix Next features: Multi-protocol downloads — HTTP, FTP, BitTorrent, Magnet, .torrent, ED2K, and Metalink tasks BitTorrent — Selective file download, DHT, peer exchange, encryption controls, metadata caching, GeoIP peer flags, and tracker probing Browser extension integration — Embedded Extension API with independent authentication, download confirmation, smart auto-submit, filename hints, referer/cookie forwarding, and real-time controls (Chrome Web Store · Edge Add-ons) Safe filename handling — Content-Disposition, RFC 2047, non-UTF-8, percent-encoded, and extensionless URL resolution with path traversal sanitization Download organization — Favorite and recent folders, optional file-type categorization, stale-record cleanup, and completed history backed by SQLite Concurrent downloads — Independent controls for active tasks, HTTP connections per server, segments per file, and BT peer limits Speed control — Global and per-task upload/download limits with day-of-week and time-of-day scheduling System integration — Tray operation, optional tray speed display, macOS Dock badge/progress, protocol handlers for magnet://, thunder://, and motrixnext:// Lightweight mode — Destroys the WebView on minimize-to-tray while Rust keeps the engine, task monitor, notifications, history, and extension routing alive Notifications and power options — Native task start/complete/failure notifications, keep-awake during downloads, and optional shutdown after completion Network controls — Scoped proxy support for downloads, app updates, and tracker updates, plus system proxy detection Auto-update channels — Stable, Beta, and Latest Across Channels policies with separate download and install phases Diagnostics — Structured logs, exportable diagnostic ZIPs, database integrity checks, automatic DB rebuild, and Linux GPU rendering fallback Personalization — Light/dark/system theme, 10 color schemes, 26 languages, and first-launch system language detection Motrix Next 3.9.6 changelog: New Features Clipboard management — App-owned copy actions no longer trigger the Add Task auto-detect popup. aria2 input compatibility — Multi-line aria2-style task input is supported for URLs with per-task options such as out=. BitTorrent IPv6 DHT — Added IPv6 DHT support and related configuration. File category URL patterns — File category rules can match URL patterns with validation and localized hints. Task status tags — Added clearer waiting and sharing states for task cards. Download event bridge — Added an aria2 WebSocket event bridge for faster download notifications. Improvements Improved task list transitions and preserved task state during tab switches. Kept RPC origin access enabled for local integrations. Restored AppImage stripping in release builds after beta validation. Added localized preference guidance across supported languages. Download: Motrix Next 64-bit | ARM64 | macOS ~20.0 MB (Open Source) Links: Website | macOS / Linux | Screenshot Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • Segra 1.6.2 by Razvan Serea Segra is a free, open-source OBS-powered game recorder offering fast gameplay capture, instant clips, AI highlights, deep game integration, and seamless uploads—perfect for gamers, streamers, and content creators. Lightweight, fast, zero bloat. Segra key features: Automatic Game Recording: Begin capturing gameplay the moment your game launches, with zero manual setup. Instant Clipping: Save important moments instantly using a customizable hotkey—perfect for highlights, montages, or quick shares. Segra AI Highlights: Let Segra automatically detect kills, assists, deaths, and key events to generate polished highlight reels without manual editing. Gameplay Uploads: Upload recordings and clips directly to Segra.tv for fast sharing and cloud access. Deep Game Integration: Enjoy advanced game-data tracking across hundreds of supported titles, enabling smart highlight generation and stat-informed clipping. High-Performance Capture: Record up to 4K at 144 FPS using OBS-powered technology with minimal performance impact, supporting NVENC, AMD VCE, and custom quality controls. Segra Editor: Edit recordings easily with timeline controls, segment management, and event-based navigation to build the perfect clip. Customization Options: Adjust hotkeys, output formats, storage paths, codecs, capture quality, and performance settings for a tailored recording experience. Segra 1.6.2 changelog: UI: Improved the transition from the loading skeleton to the real content card. Security: Added Segra.dll code signing and automatic VirusTotal upload. Settings: Fixed the settings header to highlight Account when scrolled to the top. Recording: Updated OBSKit.NET to 1.4.1. Download: Segra 1.6.2 | 74.5 MB (Open Source) View: Segra Homepage | Github | Screenshot Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • Hey Google, these are the Gemini features I want in 2026 by Aditya Tiwari Google Gemini has been around for over three years. The AI chatbot started its journey back in 2023 (as Bard) when ChatGPT was already a talk of the town. However, it quickly attracted criticism after misrepresenting facts about the James Webb Space Telescope. The search giant spent a year fine-tuning Bard before rebranding the chatbot and its underlying generative AI model to Gemini, drawing inspiration from NASA's first human spaceflight program. Note that Bard was initially powered by LaMDA and PaLM 2; Google has since added several new features and integrations to Gemini. That said, there is scope for improvement and a gap for new features. I have been using Gemini for a while now and have realized that the chatbot lacks several features, making it harder for me to research across topics. These are mostly function-over-form updates that can improve the overall experience. Delete individual messages from a conversation Image via DepositPhotos.com One good thing about Gemini is that it can maintain context throughout the conversation. But things might get chaotic when you want to ask a related question, but don't want it to be part of your conversation in the long run. You can't ask that related question in a fresh chat because Gemini will lose the active conversation context of what you're trying to research. If Google allowed you to delete individual question/answer pairs, you could simply ask about a sub-topic and remove it from the conversation to create a smooth flow of important stuff. Offline mode Image via DepositPhotos.com A big pain of using Gemini daily is that everything loads from the cloud. It takes time for your chats to appear, and you can't view your conversation history while offline. To get a better idea, you can open the Gemini app and see how it looks without an internet connection. While Gemini models run in the cloud, it wouldn't hurt if Google could store chats (at least the text part) on the device so we can refer to them when offline. Google can also offer a lightweight version of its AI model to help with basic drafting, summarization, and other tasks. It has the Gemini Nano model, which can perform on-device processing on Google Pixel, Samsung, and some other Android brands, but it's a system feature and not related to the cloud-based Gemini app. Make temporary chats permanent I can't thank Google enough for taking the time and effort to add incognito mode or temporary chat mode to the Gemini app. It lets you have conversations without worrying that the topics will end up in your chat history or used for model training (at least on paper). Google claims that it doesn't use your temporary chats to "personalize your Gemini experience or train Google’s AI models." However, the data is stored "up to 72 hours to respond to you and to process any feedback you choose to provide." That said, I often start researching something in a temporary chat, only to realize the chatbot's answer is good enough to refer to later. Sadly, Gemini doesn't have an option to make such temporary chats permanent. In other words, I won't be able to follow up on it if I close the temporary chat. I'm left with alternatives like copying the answers into notes or another app. My digital life will get a lot better if Gemini gets a button to make temporary chats permanent. Collapse answers for a cleaner view You're heavily invested in your research game and suddenly feel the need to go up in the chat to recall something. This is when the conversation thread starts to feel like an overwhelming, unending wall of questions and answers. What if Google added a way to collapse Q&A pairs in the Gemini chat thread? It would look quite clean and easy to navigate. You'll quickly get an overview of everything you have discussed with the chatbot. Add buttons to jump between messages Suggested mockup of the feature. This reminds me of a small but useful Gemini feature that Google could add to its chatbot: the ability to hop between prompts in a conversation. Just add simple up- and down-arrow buttons, similar to YouTube Shorts, so people can quickly scroll through the messages. A table of contents or Chat Overview It's hard to get a bird's-eye view of everything you have discussed with the chatbot during a lengthy conversation. This is where a table of contents, or Chat Overview, displayed at the top of the screen, possibly in a drop-down button, might come in handy. You'll be able to get an overview of the chat and jump between messages, serving as an alternative to the up/down arrow buttons. Temporary mode for Gemini Live Image: Google You can use Gemini Live to have real-time conversations with the chatbot, which feels like you're talking to someone in the same room. However, a downside is that Gemini Live doesn't work in Temporary Chat mode, so all your conversations end up in the chat history. Google should consider expanding the temporary chat mode to include Gemini Live. Default to a specific chat One thing that feels somewhat annoying to me is that Gemini always opens in a new chat, whether on web or mobile. Sometimes, you want to return to your last chat. Google can take cues from web browsers, which let you choose whether you want to go to a new tab or a specific web page(s). Gemini can also have options to default to a specific chat when reopened. That said, generative AI chatbots have endless possibilities given the vagueness of their work. You can mold them the way you want by attaching different connectors, adding custom instructions, and including source files. It remains to be seen what Google has in store for future updates and whether anything from this wishlist gets the green light. The search giant released a stream of new Gemini updates in recent months, including Gemini 3.5 Flash and Gemini Omni Spark, adding that it now has 13 products with more than a billion users each. What do you want to see in the Gemini app? Tell us in the comments.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Conversation Starter
      sumytbe earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
    • One Year In
      B4dM1k3 earned a badge
      One Year In
    • One Year In
      DarkWun earned a badge
      One Year In
    • Dedicated
      Almohandis earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • Dedicated
      JuvenileDelinquent earned a badge
      Dedicated
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      507
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      181
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      86
    4. 4
      Michael Scrip
      78
    5. 5
      Steven P.
      75
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!