Policy regarding OS X on non-Apple Hardware

By Marshalus
in Site Announcements

 Share

Recommended Posts

Grand Master

FloatingFatMan

Posted
Posted
now i remember on MACworld.com they reviewed the frakenmac. the osx86 mac that you could buy with it pre installed.. would that be illegal if i were to stumble across this site and buy a mackinhackinfranketosh ? and use it?

i uddderstand thats a whole nuther issue in ittitself

As far as I understand how the law works, it would be a breach of the EULA, but you wouldn't be the one committing that breach if you bought it pre-installed. Therefore you wouldn't be suable, but the vendor would be.

Remember folks, it's NOT a criminal offense to breach the terms of an EULA, it's a civil offense. No cops will come knocking on your door, but a lawyer might.

Mentor

Suren

Posted
Posted
Discussion of OS X on non-Apple hardware is allowed on Neowin. The amendment to the rules was conclusively made after much discussion among our staff. The primary reasoning behind this is a 1984 Federal Court ruling specifically makes it illegal for a company to force their users to install the OS on specific hardware. Which is ultimately the reason we're now allowing this discussion.

Note: Be aware though that Apple has a right to deny you support and service for OS X with a breach of the EULA. Neowin will not be held responsible in the event you void your warranty or support contracts.

Also please be mindful that Neowin still has a strong policy against warez of any kind and thus any discussion on illegally obtained copies of Mac OS X and such will be dealt with accordingly.

In order to differentiate new support threads in the forums, tagging your thread title with [OSx86] is now necessary.

Example: [OSx86] Can't get wireless card to be recognized

We do not intend to remove or amend warnings or other restrictions on accounts for previous violations of this rule because at the time the warning was placed on the account, these were the rules of Neowin.

Thank you for your understanding and patience.

I don't won't to sound like an idiot, but what has american laws have to do with Neowin since it is in Netherlands? Have we all become citizens of america or something?

On another aspect of this, some mods allow people ask about downloading tv programs for people from canada. so does this mean I can post an audio cd in neowin if my country laws says that I can?

btw: Which country laws does Neowin follow when it comes to copyrights? If its american laws, why?

Grand Master

Ji@nBing

Posted
Posted

I never could get it to install. I tired several different versions, but it would always just reboot just when it's about to load Darwin. I tried asking on several forums dedicated to this kind of stuff, but no one could ever figure out why as it should be able to install on my system easily.

Grand Master

Wannes

Posted
Posted
btw: Which country laws does Neowin follow when it comes to copyrights? If its american laws, why?

Neowin is an LLC, so actually it's a company in America I thought. Therefore they need to follow the rules of the United States.

Also it's not because the founders are from Holland that Neowin should follow the rules of the Netherlands. It depends on the location of your servers.

Collaborator

Srsly

Posted
Posted

^Yes indeed. And where is Neowin hosted then?

Well i was wrong a couple of pages back then. I thought it was illegal, but breaking the EULA is not illegal then. Now i want to try OSX86 too :laugh:

But in what forum should i post OSX86 threads?

Veteran

REM2000

Posted
Posted

as it has been stated before by some other posters, the main thing that's worrying me, is that apple will introduce similar methods to activation just like microsoft have with windows.

The beauty of OSX and Mac's was that when you wanted to reinstall the OS you put the disk in and let it install.

Experienced

mrt2

Posted
Posted
Petty arguing over the violation of laws pushed by special interest groups and written by corrupt government officials getting under the table payoffs to limit consumer rights for the purpose of corporate profit. EULAs and "licenses" specifying what you can and cannot do with the product you payed for and own.

I can't help but laugh at all of you playing into the game of greed.

Wowzers... I can't think of anything more well put being said in this forum or media for that matter.

Grand Master

Marshalus Veteran

Posted
  • Author
  • Veteran
Posted
I don't won't to sound like an idiot, but what has american laws have to do with Neowin since it is in Netherlands? Have we all become citizens of america or something?

On another aspect of this, some mods allow people ask about downloading tv programs for people from canada. so does this mean I can post an audio cd in neowin if my country laws says that I can?

btw: Which country laws does Neowin follow when it comes to copyrights? If its american laws, why?

Our servers are hosted in the United States, Neowin is registered as a corporation in the United States... we are bound by the laws of the United States.

Rising Star

ThehAWKs

Posted
Posted

How is it illegal to install software you own. You're not stealing anything, only breaking the EULA.

EULA violations have never been tested in a court of law. So, there's no precedent or case history to look at.

Apple is attempting to create a monopoly or at least using monopolistic practices and they are violating fair trade practices, therefore the Apple Eula is illegal.

Grand Master

Cara Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted
How is it illegal to install software you own. You're not stealing anything, only breaking the EULA.

EULA violations have never been tested in a court of law. So, there's no precedent or case history to look at.

Apple is attempting to create a monopoly or at least using monopolistic practices and they are violating fair trade practices, therefore the Apple Eula is illegal.

How can a company with less than 50% of the market (way less) be consider a Monopoly. There are other options available on Apple systems, you are not locked into running OS X in anyway... Apple's decision to limit THEIR intellectual property to THEIR equipment is their right and until someone legally challenges, and wins, against the Apple EULA (Not some 80's decision given how the landscape of copyright and IP laws have changed since then) it is still a violation of the EULA to install OS X on anything other than official Apple (or Apple Licensed) hardware.

Grand Master

BajiRav

Posted
Posted
How can a company with less than 50% of the market (way less) be consider a Monopoly. There are other options available on Apple systems, you are not locked into running OS X in anyway... Apple's decision to limit THEIR intellectual property to THEIR equipment is their right and until someone legally challenges, and wins, against the Apple EULA (Not some 80's decision given how the landscape of copyright and IP laws have changed since then) it is still a violation of the EULA to install OS X on anything other than official Apple (or Apple Licensed) hardware.

Can I read EULA on the box of OS X (when buying)?

Yes: It might be valid and stand a chance in court.

No: It doesn't mean ****.

I think there was a case in part where Microsoft lost in similar fashion?

Grand Master

Hell-In-A-Handbasket

Posted
Posted

where is this court decision document that everybody is citing, iv searched and couldn't find it, but i also dont know the *Who VS. *Who either.

and a rulling in 84 ( or whatever year ) vs current Tech i way different, which is why they redid the DMCA

dhan: MS lost a case where they were limiting what could be installed on the OS by manufactures ( OEM's were installing Netscape Communicator instead of IE on the desktop ) not hardware related from what i remember

Mentor

evo_spook

Posted
Posted
I never could get it to install. I tired several different versions, but it would always just reboot just when it's about to load Darwin. I tried asking on several forums dedicated to this kind of stuff, but no one could ever figure out why as it should be able to install on my system easily.

wow, you went and bought several versions of OSX and none of them would install on your PC, that must really suck, spending all that and getting now where

How is it illegal to install software you own. You're not stealing anything, only breaking the EULA.

EULA violations have never been tested in a court of law. So, there's no precedent or case history to look at.

Apple is attempting to create a monopoly or at least using monopolistic practices and they are violating fair trade practices, therefore the Apple Eula is illegal.

then again, you could say the same about installing XP on more then one machine, so its that ok to discuss?

Grand Master

BajiRav

Posted
Posted
<snip>

dhan: MS lost a case where they were limiting what could be installed on the OS by manufactures ( OEM's were installing Netscape Communicator instead of IE on the desktop ) not hardware related from what i remember

I was not talking about the Netscape/DOJ case. I faintly remember someone suing MS because they couldn't read EULA beforehand or something like that.

Grand Master

FloatingFatMan

Posted
Posted
Apple EULA (Not some 80's decision given how the landscape of copyright and IP laws have changed since then) it is still a violation of the EULA to install OS X on anything other than official Apple (or Apple Licensed) hardware.

Breaking the EULA is a breach of contract, which is a civil matter. Doesn't matter how you try to paint it, it's not illegal.

Grand Master

FloatingFatMan

Posted
Posted

Nothing illegal about breaking a contract; you can't go to prison for that. It's a purely civil matter, so you can be sued sure, but it's not a matter of breaking the law.

In fact, as the law goes, it's less serious than not paying a parking fine.

Collaborator

dyn

Posted
Posted
Simply put, "a 1984 U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals decision held that a software publisher can't require consumers to run an operating system on a specific type of hardware." The US Supreme Court has refused to hear the case, so at this point it is legal for anyone who owns a copy of OS X (Leopard) to install it on any other hardware. The only thing Apple can do is refuse you support. That's where we come in.

Have you got a link to the entire decision? The other thing I can't find is where other laws such as the dmca come in. As mostly with law there are certain pieces that alow something whilst others forbid it: inconsistency. There's also a chance that this decision is overruled by newer pieces of law and decisions. Were those kind of things also checked?

In other words: are you absolutely sure that this decision from 1984 is the only thing that tells something about OS X on non-Apple hardware? Since it's a bit strange that in 24 years time no one has ever used it against Apple and it's also strange because this decision would affect nearly all electronics in the US in some way (it would mean that every single OS out there has to be crossplatform which is quite impossible).

There's also Darwin which is what OS X uses as a base. Darwin is free and you can run it on a pc if you want to. Specific parts that make up the rest of OS X are not free. So in what regard is Apple not fulfilling that 1984 decision? They've had Darwin for years which you can install on non-Apple hardware.

Grand Master

Hurmoth

Posted
Posted

Full citation is Digidyne Corp. v. Data General Corp., 734 F.2d 1336 (9th Cir 1984), cert denied, 473 U.S. 908 (1985)

DATA GENERAL CORP. v. DIGIDYNE CORP. , 473 U.S. 908 (1985)

The Mac OS X end-user license agreement prohibits its use on hardware other than that sold by Apple. It reads, "You agree not to install, use, or run the Apple software on any non-Apple-labeled computer, or to enable others to do so."

A little legal history now. Way back in 1978, a company by the name of Digidyne brought suit against Data General, alleging that it was restraining trade by "tying" its RDOS operating system to its Nova minicomputer hardware. (Digidyne sold Nova clones.)

The case wound its way through the courts. A 1984 Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals decision held for Digidyne; the case was later denied rehearing by the U.S. Supreme Court.

It was a convoluted court case, but the bottom-line result was that Data General could not prohibit the use of its operating system on someone else's hardware. To use the legal term, you could not "tie" hardware and software. Related cases have involved prohibiting the use of specific supplies (such as punch cards) with a specific vendor's hardware.

Continue reading here.

I believe, and apparently a lot of other people do as well, that this case right here is why Apple hasn't put a stop to the OSx86 Project, the Psystar Mac Clone project and various websites from discussing this. Apple couldn't win without this case first being overturned by the US Supreme Court.

Grand Master

markwolfe Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted
Full citation is Digidyne Corp. v. Data General Corp., 734 F.2d 1336 (9th Cir 1984), cert denied, 473 U.S. 908 (1985)

DATA GENERAL CORP. v. DIGIDYNE CORP. , 473 U.S. 908 (1985)

...

Thanks for the link. (Y)

Put the link in the first post, where it mentions the ruling?

This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Posts

    • The Microsoft Office feature that time forgot

      By Circaflex · Posted

      You still can, its just under the Transform flyout for WordArt now
    • Waymo recalls self-driving software after cars enter closed freeway work zones

      By MrElectrifyer · Posted

      Likely nothing will be done in corporate America, there have been countless Tesla self-driving incidents. Then again, there have also been countless human operated incidents. It's literally daily news here in Canada, to the extent that it's now odd if we get a day where a collision doesn't get announced on the radio throughout the day...
    • SKG Hand Massager with Heat OS500 hands on

      By Steven P. · Posted

      SKG Hand Massager with Heat OS500 hands on by Steven Parker I was offered the chance to test out the SKG Hand Massager with Heat OS500, and full disclosure, they let me keep it regardless of my findings. Anyway, I jumped at the chance due to my long hours sitting at my desk, mousing around. Apologies for the knife cut across the top of the box; that was my doing, being a bit too heavy-handed with opening up the outer packaging. First up, what's in the box: SKG Hand Massager with Heat OS500 1x Type-C charging cable User Manual 1-Year Warranty (card) In short, everything you need to get started. According to the official Amazon listing, here are the key features: Full-Hand Air Compression: OS500 wraps your fingers, palm, and wrist with multi-chamber air compression for a complete hand relaxation experience. The extended massage chamber helps cover more of the hand and wrist area than standard palm-only hand massagers Palm Kneading with 6 Modes & 6 Intensities: Built-in palm kneading rollers add a hands-on massage feel, while 6 preset modes and 6 pressure levels let you choose the comfort level that fits your day—from gentle relaxation to a firmer full-hand massage 3 Heat Levels with Cooling Fan: Choose from 104°F, 113°F or 122°F warmth to suit different seasons and comfort preferences. The built-in cooling fan helps reduce stuffiness during heated sessions, keeping your hand feeling fresh and comfortable Easy Visual Display & Smart Timer: The digital image display clearly shows massage area, mode, intensity, heat level, and remaining time at a glance. Select 10, 15, or 20-minute sessions for quick office breaks, evening relaxation, or everyday hand care Rechargeable, Cordless & Comfortable: A 3000mAh battery supports over 90 minutes of full-function use on a full charge, with convenient USB-C charging. The soft inner lining, smooth ABS/PU finish, and premium black-gold design make OS500 ideal for home, office, or gifting With all that out of the way, here are my own findings. I gave it a try on both left and right hands, and as you can maybe see from the above YouTube Short, (sorry for the shaky video), my whole hand fits in, but my wrist barely enters the Hand Massager. I was able to push through a bit more with my fingertips extending out the other end to get a bit of massaging on the start of my wrist. Usage For some reason, there is a strap that is very difficult to fasten to my wrist with one hand. I am not sure what function it has, and it isn't mentioned in the user manual. The only thing I could find was in the product images that claimed "wrist precision". Unlike the Bob and Brad Hand Massager, this device does not massage the wrist anyway, even though a "wrist mode" is mentioned, which must be for smaller hands than I have, as it is mainly intended for the hand and fingers. In addition, for its steeper price, there are no disposable gloves provided in the box, which is a bit of an issue considering the internal cover (which appears to be elasticated nylon) cannot be removed for washing; so you are left with only one choice: always thoroughly wash your hands before using it. I can imagine this thing getting a bit grimy after a period of use, and that is a bit of a shame. With that said, the buttons on the device, from left to right, do the following: Heat button: 3-level heat control at 104°F, 113°F, or 122°F Mode button: Auto mode Circular mode Soothing mode Relax mode Palm and fingers mode Palm and wrist mode Intensity button: from (First-time users) 15Ka, 25Ka, 35Ka, 45Ka, 55Ka, 60Ka (Intensive relief) Knead button: on or off (6 pressure levels) Power button: Long-press to turn on or off Cooling button: turn on or off the cooling fan Also, in the product imagery, it states there are 36 "custom modes," but nowhere is it listed what these modes are. I can only imagine that they mean a combination of all of the above settings in different intensity levels. The device itself seems to rely on a single "kneading" mechanism located at the palm area of the hand, which spins when in use, and the other massage features are mainly utilized through the air sacs, increasing and decreasing at various levels on the hand and fingers. I am not sure it offered too much relief for someone who is typing and operating a mouse for hours at a time; further testing may be required. It does feel nice, though. Finally, you may be wondering how this fits into the scope of a tech website? Well, let me tell you something: sometimes I sit for up to 15 hours working on Neowin, and although I take breaks in between, it takes a toll on my body. I think in the immediate absence of a partner to apply relief, a good massager like this Hand Massager can shed the strains of the day in just a couple of 15-minute bursts. On the official website, this has an MSRP of $99.99, but luckily for our readers, it is selling at $10 off for just $89.99 right now on Amazon. SKG Hand Massager with Heat OS500 for $89.99 (with $10 off coupon), $99.99 MSRP For me, this gets a thumbs hands(?) down. However, it could be improved by making it so that the protective covering could be removed and thrown into the washing machine, or get yourself some disposable gloves to use with it. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
    • Creative Sound Blaster AE-X PCIe review: your headphones will love it

      By Taliseian · Posted

      Thanks for the info, but I'm still not sure if I need this....
    • We check out the SKG PS700 Neck Massager

      By Steven P. · Posted

      We check out the SKG PS700 Neck Massager by Steven Parker I was offered the chance to test out the SKG PS700 Neck Massager, and full disclosure, they let me keep it regardless of my findings. Anyway, I jumped at the chance due to my long hours sitting at my desk; I figured it could offer some neck pain relief. What's in the box: SKG PS700-2 Neck Massager Rechargeable Battery (inside massager) Type-C USB cable User Manual Quick Start guide 1-Year Warranty In short, everything you need to get started. According to the official listing, here are the key features: Biomimetic Kneading & High Torque Motor: Designed with innovative biomimetic kneading heads that perfectly simulate the touch of human hands. Powered by a high-torque motor, this massager delivers powerful and precise deep tissue relief to effectively target stiff neck muscles and release built-up tension Soothing Heat & Integrated Sound Relaxation: Experience the ultimate Relaxationation with our dual-action approach. The soothing heat function gently warms your neck, while the built-in sound Relaxation provides calming audio tracks, helping you achieve a state of mindfulness and mental tranquility during your physical massage Cordless Convenience & Travel-Ready & Father's Day Gifts: Crafted for maximum portability and ease of use. Its lightweight, cordless design allows you to enjoy a premium massage anywhere without the hassle of tangled wires-whether you're taking a quick break at your desk or winding down at home Versatile Relief for Home & Office: An essential wellness companion for office workers, gamers, frequent travelers, or anyone looking to integrate mindfulness into their daily routine. It seamlessly fits into your lifestyle, providing instant neck relief whenever and wherever you need it Safe & Premium Materials: Manufactured with high-quality, skin-friendly materials to ensure a safe and comfortable experience without irritation. SKG backs this device with dedicated customer service, making it a thoughtful tech-health gift for family and friends App & Bluetooth Music Control: Connect via Bluetooth to control your massage settings through the dedicated app and enjoy your favorite music during your massage session for a fully customizable and immersive relaxation experience Red Light Warmth Technology: Features advanced red light warmth technology that penetrates deep into neck muscles to enhance blood circulation and provide soothing comfort while relieving muscle tension and stiffness Design With all that out of the way, here are my own findings. SKG does not say what materials are used to make the neck massager. However, on the product website, it mentions "soft-touch silicone" with what looks like PU leather cushioning, with the rest being mostly made up of plastics. On the inside of the massager, there are two "biomimetic kneading heads" that are motorized for the different styles of massage, which are not actually listed at all in the paper user manual, but the standard included modes are: De-stress mode, Mediation mode, Relax mode, Shiatsu mode. The massager looks quite premium and is actually very comfortable to wear. This massager is small and light enough to go anywhere, as it doesn't get in the way of anything, so I was able to use it in the chair while writing this review. Unlike the back massager, SKG does not warn in the user guide not to use it for more than 30 minutes a day (or two 15-minute sessions). However, there is a long laundry list of important safeguards to consider before and during the use of the device, and it is warned that the neck massager is not waterproof. It also includes a 1,400mAh battery with a rated power of 14W and input of 5V, which is the standard for up to USB 3.0 power (although the Amperage is not mentioned at all). SKG does not say how long it takes to charge, but a quick calculation at 2A (if that is what it is) would mean it would take roughly 1.5 hrs to charge from empty. In any case, the light around the button changes from orange to green on a full charge. In addition, it is not possible to use the device while it is charging. On the right of the neck massager is the On/Off and modes button, which also acts as a joystick. You can operate all the modes directly from the power button, as well as the app, which I'll get into a bit later: Push up: Short press to adjust Heat levels On/Off button: long press Mode Switching: Short press (while in operation) ➕ Push left: increase Music volume ➖ push right: decrease Music volume Push down: Short-press to turn Music on or off The massager defaults to De-stress mode, and it is not stated anywhere if the neck massager has overheat protection. This time around, regarding heat, the only detail I could find is that it has "triple action soothing heat." The temperature stages are not listed anywhere in the paper manual, Amazon listing, or official website. The heat levels can be adjusted through the app or directly on the device using the joystick button. Usage There's also the SKG Health app, which makes using the massager far easier than feeling around for the button on the side of your neck. If the app is stopped, you are required to log in with a verification code over email, which I am not too pleased with, as this means it will only work that way for however long SKG decides to support it through said app. However, I was not able to get the app to connect to the OS500, which I have reported back to my contact. Bluetooth appeared to be working on the neck massager as it became available to pair with my phone, but the SKG app failed to discover it. Before I forget, there's also a switch next to the USB charging port to deactivate and activate the Voice Prompt, which, when enabled, audibly tells the user when switching intensities, modes, or connecting to the app and informs when the massages start and are completed. That said, on to my likes and dislikes, which are listed below. What I didn't like Unable to connect the Neck Massager to the app Use through the mobile app relies on continued support from SKG What I liked Can be used without the app Cordless use Light and comfortable to wear Heat is also quite comfortable Where to buy: According to the official website, this has an MSRP of $249.99, but is currently $50 (on Amazon). To sweeten the deal a bit more, there's also an in-page coupon that knocks a further $20 off the price. SKG PS700-2 Neck Massager for $179.99 on Amazon (was $199.99) Apply the in-page $20 off coupon for the final price of $179.99 Just like the back massager, this gets a confused thumbs up (due to the cost). However, I cannot rate it through app usage as it failed to connect. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

  • Recent Achievements

    • Dedicated
      Almohandis earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • Dedicated
      JuvenileDelinquent earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • First Post
      DrWankel earned a badge
      First Post
    • Reacting Well
      DrWankel earned a badge
      Reacting Well
    • Week One Done
      Supreme Spray LV earned a badge
      Week One Done

  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      505
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      184
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      85
    4. 4
      Michael Scrip
      78
    5. 5
      Steven P.
      76
    Show More

  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!