DEFINITIVE: Which Linux Distro? (poll)


Which Linux Distro do you prefer?  

773 members have voted

  1. 1. Which Linux Distro do you prefer?

    • Slackware (or derivatives)
      33
    • Debian
      56
    • SUSE Linux (or derivatives)
      99
    • Fedora Core (or Redhat, or RHEL)
      120
    • Gentoo (or derivatives)
      86
    • Ubuntu
      273
    • Other Debian Derivative (Mepis, Kanotix, etc)
      25
    • Arch
      19
    • Linspire
      22
    • Mandriva
      40


Recommended Posts

I just want to know why Fedora/Mandrake/SuSe need 3+ CDs, while Gentoo only needs 2, and Ubuntu only needs 1? Does it mean that Gentoo/Ubuntu needs more work (read installation of software) to get it up and running properly? or does Gentoo/Ubuntu just not come with a lot of redundant stuff?

585678428[/snapback]

Fedora / Mandrake / SuSe has a LOT of extra applications that desktop users would like. Fedora Core 3 takes 6.7GB to install 'Everything'.

Gentoo isn't really a Desktop system, it doesn't have a Graphical User Interface as default, and it only installs the sheer necessities.

All Linux distros can install all Linux apps, but not everyone wants to install all the 'extras' which is great for servers who want to run Gentoo without a pretty interface and redundant software that they will never use, and this gives the user complete control over 'what to' and 'what not' to install.

P.S.

Fedora Core 3 & Gentoo 2005.0 rocks!

Close, I guess- Ubuntu's pretty similar to Gentoo (haven't worked extensively with either, feel free to correct me there), but there's one *huge* difference-- Ubuntu is built for you.

There's a serious, serious speed difference in Gentoo when you make the kernel and programs yourself with optemisation versus downloading the prepackaged bins or just compiling with no optomizing.

585656596[/snapback]

Oh, really? Have your run benchmarks to measure this "serious, serious" speed difference? I believe you'll find that the speed increases are marginal at best, and some popular compile optimisations used by many gentoo users (for instance -O3 in your CFLAGS) can sometimes slow down software rather than speed it up. I think you'll find it difficult to provide links to solid evidence which demonstrates a practical, noticable jump in speed when using hardware-specific optimisations.

Don't get me wrong, I am a huge gentoo supporter, and have used it pretty much exclusively as my main OS for a couple of years now, and I think it is still the best system for me to use (portage is just so ridiculously powerful when you learn all the ins and outs of the additional portage tools available), but I do honestly believe that the oft-touted "speed advantages" that gentoo has over other distros are pretty much non-existant in practice. Any reasonably recent, well-configured and setup linux system will run fast.

Gentoo is powerful for the flexibility it brings to the table more than anything else, imho.

I've always been a Fedora fan, but I decided to download and play around with Ubuntu 5.04 earlier today and all I can say is wow... very nicely done. Of course I've only used it for about three hours now, but from what I can tell so far, it is a much better distro then Fedora.

Debian / Other Debian-based...

More precisely: MEPIS.

Holds similar quality as Ubuntu, but this distro was from the scratch designed for KDE, not Gnome.

Currently, the popularity ranking (based on distro page visits) on Distrowatch.com shows:

1. Ubuntu

2. Mandrake

3. Fedora

4. MEPIS

5. SUSE

6. Debian

7. Knoppix

... which speaks a bit of its popularity and curiosity it's raising. :)

I'm therefore a bit surprised that it's not even a choice here. :(

Currently, the popularity ranking (based on distro page visits) on Distrowatch.com shows:

1. Ubuntu

2. Mandrake

3. Fedora

4. MEPIS

5. SUSE

6. Debian

7. Knoppix

... which speaks a bit of its popularity and curiosity it's raising. :)

I'm therefore a bit surprised that it's not even a choice here.  :(

585722483[/snapback]

Well, our installed base here at Neowin seems to be different than the general population who visits Distrowatch.

Our order (as of today) is

1. Fedora

2. Gentoo

3. SUSE

4. Ubuntu

5. Mandrake

While Mepis may be a great Debian-based distro, if we add the "Other Debian" + the "Other - Please specify" categories up, and assume that they all were Mepis, it still would not add up any higher than Ubuntu (which dominates the Debian varieties here).

But, in the Open Source world, things change very quickly. Ubuntu has rocketed into the spotlight from a new distro freshly created. At the end of the year, we will have the ability to remove a distro or two and add in whatever new popular items have come up.

is there a linux distro out there that is able to fully "emulate" windows xp?

i'm looking for something that would be able to run almost all windows applications, along with autodetect hardware and install, but with none of the hassles of windows.

585733665[/snapback]

I think that is called Windows.

You cannot jump into Linux expecting it to be just like Windows and have any sort of expectation of success.

In Windows, you are a user. In Linux, you must learn to be an administrator. It is extra work to get to learn to manage your system, but once that is done, you will find that Linux runs much more reliably and problem-free than Windows.

But you cannot start with a requirement that it runs Windows applications.

Why is Ubuntu so popular?  What does it have that others don't?

585748123[/snapback]

It's Simple

It everything a noob or a basic *nix user wants

it like fedora 3 w/out the bs (mp3,etc...) and it has a bunch of nifty features that are made see able

Great way to switch from windows to linux

Debian / Other Debian-based...

More precisely: MEPIS.

Holds similar quality as Ubuntu, but this distro was from the scratch designed for KDE, not Gnome.

Currently, the popularity ranking (based on distro page visits) on Distrowatch.com shows:

1. Ubuntu

2. Mandrake

3. Fedora

4. MEPIS

5. SUSE

6. Debian

7. Knoppix

... which speaks a bit of its popularity and curiosity it's raising. :)

I'm therefore a bit surprised that it's not even a choice here.  :(

585722483[/snapback]

I believe SimplyMEPIS was largely derived from Knoppix. I could be wrong though.

Most Debian/KDE live CD distros are derived from Knoppix.

Why is Ubuntu so popular?  What does it have that others don't?

585748123[/snapback]

http://www.ubuntulinux.org/ubuntu/releases/

http://www.ubuntulinux.org/ubuntu/relationship/

In a nutshell, Ubuntu is desktop-oriented, community-driven distro for x86, AMD64 and PPC, with a rapid development cycle based on snapshots of Debian Sid.

Long version:

Ubuntu has a 6-month release cycle, sychronized with each release of Gnome. At each release cycle, it takes a snapshot from Debian Sid and integrates Ubuntu's own changes, then it's repository is frozen at the end of the release cycle. Ubuntu achieves a more rapid cycle by narrowing its focus to to the desktop, restricting its target to 3 CPU architetures and shrinking the number of offcially supported packages. Ubuntu splits Debian's main section into two: Ubuntu main (officially supported) and Ubuntu universe (community supported). Ubuntu main only has a fraction of the packages in Debian main, the rest is in universe.

While it's taken from Debian Sid at each cycle, Ubuntu has it's own package repository (unlike, say, Knoppix, Progency, MEPIS, etc., which all relies on Debian's official repo). Each final release version of Ubuntu has its own frozen repository, so you don't have to worry about a newer (but buggy) package in Sid's archive breaking your system.

It also tracks Gnome closely. One of its missions is to include the latest version of Gnome as soon as it's released. Ubuntu Hoary went final in a matter of days after Gnome 2.10 did.

I find Ubuntu's installation painless. Debian tends to ask me too many questions during X server installation, while Ubuntu pretty much did everything automatically. Though Ubuntu is probably not quite as good as Knoppix in the hardware detection department. Ubuntu also includes some closed source hardware drivers by default, though it otherwise stick to a free software-only policy.

Ubuntu is commited to fit its installation on a single CD. You can download all the xtra packages using apt-get. Like Debian, you can always download the next release via apt-get and do an in-place upgrade, instead of downloading another ISO for the upgrade.

Ubuntu is also the first and only Debian distro to switch to X.org's X server. Debian Sid is still using XFree86 and X.org is still broken.

Finally, Ubuntu has a lively community similar to that of Fedora. It can be difficult to find support for Debian due to its breadth. It relies on some 30 mailing lists and has no official forums. Ubuntu's support is much more centralized, and its narrower focus also make it easier to find answers.

What Ubuntu doesn't differ from Debian is that Ubuntu has a strict free software policy, it's built on Debian Sid so it maintain the same rigid packaging policy and Q&A. Apt-get provides the same painless package management and version upgrades (never have to download more ISOs for each upgrade).

So there you have it. Ubuntu is to Debian as Fedora is to Red Hat, with some added commercial backing and free software philosophy.

Edited by goofrider

id say ubuntu, my im a heavy multimedia user, and so far it really hasnt been doing that well for getting my media to work correctly. so im thinking of switching to fedora core 3, if theres a way to not use kde and gnome instead (is there?)

id say ubuntu, my im a heavy multimedia user, and so far it really hasnt been doing that well for getting my media to work correctly. so im thinking of switching to fedora core 3, if theres a way to not use kde and gnome instead (is there?)

585764276[/snapback]

Yes, and gnome is the default WM in FC3 afaik. I dont think you'll get a better multimedia experience using FC3 either. Whats wrong with Ubuntu, or what cant you get working?

sweet, might make the switch to fc3 (whats afaik) then. Ubuntu is okay, but when i try to get mp3s to work on say amarok or rhythm box, no luck

( i get that /dev/dsp or something like that is busy or some other error). they work on totem, but one a song at a time, and i wanna switch on the fly from a program. Speaking of totem, when i try to watch a movie from it, it lags horribly. Also after a while or so ill get some failed sequences in my boot (dual boot with winxp), dont really know the reason. Might be how i mounted my ntfs partition, help in the link right here if you can

msg43 saying:

"....... it like fedora 3 w/out the bs (mp3,etc...) and it has a bunch of nifty features that are ...."

^ afaik = as far as i know

And i think msg43 was reffering to the licensing issue with mp3's which now affects Ubuntu as well as Fedora/Red Hat. After reading his post I think he is promoting Ubuntu over FC3...

585765401[/snapback]

The MP3 licensing also affects SUSE now. Thank you, Software Patents. :rolleyes:

I am a FC user, but it is possible that you will run into the same problems as you did in Ubuntu. Possible, also, that things will be easier. Sometimes a different approach is what it takes to 'click'. If there was a perfect distro for everyone, then everyone would use it, no? ;)

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • OpenAI is now rolling out Lockdown Mode to more ChatGPT users by Pradeep Viswanathan Back in February, OpenAI first announced Lockdown Mode for users who want the most comprehensive protection from potential attacks. At the time of the announcement, the company mentioned that this feature was available to a small set of highly security-conscious users, including executives or security teams at leading organizations. Today, OpenAI announced that Lockdown Mode is now rolling out to all personal ChatGPT accounts, including Free, Go, Plus, and Pro, and also self-serve ChatGPT Business accounts. Users can enable the feature from ChatGPT Settings > Security when it is available for their account. When Lockdown Mode is enabled, ChatGPT limits or disables several features that connect to the web or external services. These include live web browsing, Deep Research, Agent Mode, and more. Here is the complete list of services that will be disabled in Lockdown Mode: Live web browsing: Web browsing is limited to accessing only cached content. Search results may be limited, unavailable, or stale. Image support: ChatGPT may not display images in regular responses or retrieve images from the web. Users can still upload image files, and image generation remains available where it is otherwise available. Deep research: Deep research is disabled. Agent mode: Agent mode is disabled. Canvas networking: Users cannot approve Canvas-generated code to access the network. File downloads: ChatGPT cannot download files for data analysis. ChatGPT can still operate on your manually uploaded files. It is important to note that Lockdown Mode does not completely block prompt injections from appearing in content that ChatGPT processes. For example, a malicious instruction could still be present in an uploaded file or cached web content. However, the mode is designed to reduce the ways such an attack could send sensitive information outside the conversation. Along with Lockdown Mode, OpenAI today also announced that the Active sessions feature is now available across ChatGPT accounts and workspace types. This feature allows users to review where their account is signed in across devices and end sessions if required. A session will have the following information displayed: Device or browser information. First-party app context, such as ChatGPT, Codex, or API Platform. Approximate location. Sign-in date and time. Whether the device is a trusted device. Whether it is your current session. OpenAI highlighted that the Active sessions feature will not be available for accounts linked to an organization’s single sign-on setup, including SAML or OIDC.
    • with LSTC and ESU, moving to w11 or linux because w10 suddenly will not work when in reality it works and its a better choice, of course there are also developers that only test in 11 or force you to have TPM and Secure boot for the sake of "better security" in games. or most likely people is buying new PC that only ship with 11
    • with LTSC and ESU there are still viable as a stable platform not that they care and let people deal with w11 crashing and burning every month support mean shet if the platform is trash
    • Most boring game ever. Repetitive, empty, predictable, and full of cliches. Total waste of time and money, IMO.
    • Mafia: The Old Country expansion Man of Honor announced, brings back Salieri from original by Pulasthi Ariyasinghe During Summer Game Fest, 2K and Hanger 13 brought out a new Mafia: The Old Country trailer, revealing the game's first expansion. Named Man of Honor, this is slated to add two new chapters to the Enzo storyline that the game follows. There is an iconic character returning to the series with this expansion, with players set to run into Ennio Salieri, the future Don of the Salieri crime family. Fans of the original Mafia, or its Definitive Edition remake, may remember that name as one of the biggest characters in the storyline. This expansion is set prior to his rise to being the kingpin in the City of Lost Heaven. "Set in Sicily during the winter of 1905, Enzo Favara has proven himself a reliable soldier of the Torrisi crime family in the months since his initiation," says the studio about the new chapters. "Now, the Don entrusts him and Cesare with a delicate assignment of assisting Ennio Salieri, a man of honor recently released from prison and intent on reclaiming what is his." Working at Salieri's side, players will be heading into fresh environments as they return to the role of Enzo as a high-ranking soldato. The studio also promises brand-new weapons, fresh vehicles, and charms to collect in this expansion. Moreover, the expansion will add new content to the updated Free Ride mode. Alongside new collectibles and locations, this will add more challenges to beat alongside Salieri, which are described as runs that will "test the skills of even the most elite mafiosi." The Mafia: The Old Country Man of Honor story expansion will release on August 14, 2026, across PC, Xbox Series X|S, and PlayStation 5. It will cost $10 for owners of the base game to jump into.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Rookie
      moog19 went up a rank
      Rookie
    • Mentor
      grik went up a rank
      Mentor
    • Dedicated
      JKR earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • One Year In
      CHUNWEI earned a badge
      One Year In
    • Conversation Starter
      FBSPL earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      488
    2. 2
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      270
    3. 3
      Skyfrog
      75
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      68
    5. 5
      FloatingFatMan
      63
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!