P4 1.8GHz or AMD Athlon XP And Why?


Recommended Posts

Nah.. these so-called "benchmarks".. sad really, they compare DDR systems on both P4 and AMD. You want more power, hit up a P4 system with some RDRAM.. Im afraid no AMD could beat my other machine, a P4 2.2 Ghz with 1 gig of RDRAM =)

Then again, if you want a DDR-based system get an AMD, if you want a Rambus-based system, definately get an Intel. Just remember, DDR bandwidth = squat

yeah.. AMD all the way for me too. I've always rathered AMD since the Athlon came out and nobody could have ever changed my mind about that. I don't care what people say about AMD being hotter and or just a phase... AMD is here to stay and they'll be getting all my hard earned money when VIA release their KT333A chipset and AMD reaches up to a 2.0Ghz CPU.

/edit

That rambus is only power for Multimedia applications and nothing for normal apps.

Save some money and go for the AMD.

Nah.. these so-called "benchmarks"..

You have to watch the Intel guys. They claim that all of the benchmarks are lies. Just watch, next one of them will brag that the Intel doesn't even need a fan and the AMD will catch fire. If you mount your heatsink correctly you'll never have to worry about it.

ok guys

no more wars:)

just go to tom's hardware review page

there is everything there, written by pro people:)

i saw all the benchmarks

and here is the conclusion, if you don't want to waste your time like me:)

http://www6.tomshardware.com/cpu/01q4/0110.../xpvsp4-15.html

lets take this scenario... dont XP processors only take DDR RAM? meanwhile the P4 takes SDRAM, DDR, RDRAM.. but correct me if Im wrong. Anyhow, as well as the mobos for an Intel support a broader range of processors.. anywhere from a 1.4 GHz up to a 2.2 GHz.. thats quite the expandability aint it?

..and yes, not here to start anything :)

I'm not trying to pick on anybody either. I'm not a "fan boy." When it came time for me to make my recomendations for the 2002 capital budget at my company I did my research. AMD beat the Pentium 4 (not including the brand new one that wasn't out at the time) in all of the tests except the Quake III test. I am saving $400 on each workstation and getting a better box.

my athlon XP 1700+ comes today :) wohoo,

Upgrading from my amd 800mhz thingy,

as it says on the NVIDIA website,

FERIOCIOUS POWER. or summit

I Love AMD

Also.. I read (not sure) That the DDR333 board can be outperformed by a DDR266(A?) board.

Which doesn't make sense to me.

If you want a cheap, fast system get an Athlon XP. Athlons aren't as reliable as Pentiums because of heat issues and buggy chipsets(especially Via based chipsets). If AMD could only shake thier heat problems and start making more of thier own chipsets(instead of relying on 3rd party chipset makers) then the Athlon would be the ultimate platform.

If you want excellent reliability, great speed and a piece of mind that your CPU will never fry get an Intel Pentium 4 Northwood. It will cost you extra money, but you really can't put a price tag on quality. AMD fanboys will claim that thier Athlons totally smoke Pentium 4's(An Athlon will smoke if something happens to the cooling..like maybe the fan on the HSF going out ;P), but in reality a Pentium 4 Northwood and AMD Athlon XP are close in performance(The P4 is faster in some stuff vice versa). In the future when more app/game developers implement SSE2 support(or even when Nvidia, ATI, etc. implement SSE2 support into thier drivers) the Pentium 4 will totally destroy Athlons. As a matter of fact, I think that DX9 is going to support SSE2(I'm not sure about this though).

I own both an Athlon XP system and a P4 system and if I were to ever get rid of one of them it would be the Athlon system because I have problem after problem with the damned Via chipset it sits on and I get fed up with the room the Athlon system sits in getting hot because the system acts like a space heater(it blows warm air out of the blow holes at all times when on).

I will add one more thing. If you go with a Pentium 4 you are best off going with a mobo that has the I850 chipset. It is a fast and stable chipset. Do not get a mobo with the crap called the Via P4X266 chipset, and it is also a good idea to avoid SiS chipsets(even though SiS chipsets aren't very buggy). The P4 on the I850 chipset is the king of stability. If you do go with a P4 setup on any Intel chipset, make sure that you download and install the Intel Application Accelerator after you install your OS and chipset drivers because it makes a world of difference in performance for the P4 because it enables the P4 data pre-fetcher(You do not get this luxury with non-Intel chipsets).

If you want excellent reliability, great speed and a piece of mind that your CPU will never fry get an Intel Pentium 4 Northwood.

LMAO.... you've got the Intel logo as your avatar and you're telling people to go with AMD. Ever so slightly biased me thinks.

Gamers use AMD Athlon XP for a reason.... businesses use Intel for CAD, etc, for a reason.

LMAO, you don't even explain yourself. Please don't post in question threads unless you actually have something useful/helpful to say. As for the avatar, it says Intel Pentium 5. We all know there is no such thing as a Pentium 5(yet).

Take your spam.gif somewhere else. ;)

As a user who has both chips (as in my signature), the AthlonXP chips are a hell of a lot faster compared to P4's. I even tested both systems with the same amount of RAM, and my AthlonXP 1800+ was extremely faster than my P4-2GHz.

Go for AthlonXP - they're cheaper and more powerful, and requires a smaller hs/fan.

Athlons aren't as reliable as Pentiums because of heat issues and buggy chipsets(especially Via based chipsets).

I don't understand what you guys are doing wrong. I've built at least 100 Athlon workstations (most of them for CAD technicians) and I haven't have any trouble with them.

hey listen its plain and simple

Intel is AMD's Biatch

read the reveiws

read toms hardware

see the benchmarks

even the AMD XP2000 which runs at 1.67ghz, doesnt beat i must admit but keeps up with the 2.2ghz intel northwood and its 530mhz slower theoretically it shouldnt be anywhere near it on the benchmark scored

as for heatsinks and AMD's blowing up..... well thats pure crap coz i have my cpu running now at 35c with no watercooling just normal fans and stuff

take a look at the pros, the overclockers, the people with real real fast comps they all have an AMD

Once AMD goes down to 0.13Micron then i doubt intel would be in the same league as the AMD 0.18 micron keeps up with intels latest technology

Originally posted by irdawood  

hey listen its plain and simple  

Intel is AMD's Biatch......

so according to the rest isn't Intel the biatch then? If the the smaller one is in control and that's the funny part!

People keep comparing AMD's lastest to Intel's latest which goes to show you how bad Intel is right now. They don't compare the AMD XP 2000+ (1.67Ghz) to the Intel 1.6Ghz or even 1.7ghz! It's all the way up to 2.2Ghz cuz even the Intel owners on this board know that pound for pound AMD stomps over Intels when they are at the same GHz. The 1.6Ghz AMD makes the 1.6Ghz P4 look like a P3 at 800Mhz! Now what kinda battle is that when you put something that's 2-times better than the other one but the inferior one still keeps up even though it looses... come on intel people... admit it!!! AMD is a good chip that's why there's a discussion... i dont' see nobody comparing the VIA C3 chipset in all of this and that's just cuz it's not as good as the other 2.

As irdawood said, The Intel 2.2ghz uses .13 micron manufacturing process and the AMD uses .18. The Intel is better technology but the old ass AMDs still keep up to Intels new stuff.. should the new stuff blow the old ones out the water? As in the case of the nVidia chipsets?

Just something to think about...

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • AdGuard Family lifetime deal now only $14.97 by Steven Parker Today's highlighted Neowin Deal comes via our Apps + Software section, where you can get a lifetime subscription and save 91% on a lifetime AdGuard Family Plan. AdGuard is a unique program that has all the necessary features for what they claim to be "the best web experience." The software combines the an advanced ad blocker, a privacy protection module, and a parental control tool—all working in one app. This software deals with annoying ads, hides your data from a multitude of trackers, protects you from malware attacks, and even lets you restrict your kids from accessing inappropriate content. Install AdGuard and see the internet as it was supposed to be: clean and safe. Get rid of annoying banners, pop-ups & video ads once and for all Hide your data from the multitude of trackers & activity analyzers that swarm the web Avoid fraudulent and phishing website and malware attacks Protect your kids online by restricting them from accessing inappropriate & adult content Good to know Family Plan Length of access: lifetime This plan is only available to new users Redemption deadline: redeem your code within 30 days of purchase Max number of devices: 9 Access options: desktop & mobile Software version: AdGuard Family Updates included A lifetime subscription of AdGuard Family Plan normally costs $169.99, but this deal can be yours for just $14.97, that's a saving of $157.02. For full terms, specifications, and license info please click the link below. Get this AdGuard Family lifetime deal for just $14.97 (was $169.99) Although priced in U.S. dollars, this deal is available for digital purchase worldwide. As an online publication, Neowin too relies on ads for operating costs and, if you use an ad blocker, we'd appreciate being whitelisted. In addition, we have an ad-free subscription for $28 a year, which is another way to show support! Support queries If you have queries or need support for any of the Neowin Deals, please use the contact form here. Neowin Deals are managed and sold by StackCommerce who represent Neowin on an affiliate basis. Why we post these deals We post these because we earn commission on each sale so as not to rely solely on advertising, which many of our readers block. It all helps toward paying staff reporters, servers and hosting costs. So for those that keep moaning and complaining, be thankful we're still online for you to even do that. Other ways to support Neowin Whitelist Neowin by not blocking our ads Create a free member account to see fewer ads Make a donation to support our day to day running costs Subscribe to Neowin - for $14 a year, or $28 a year for an ad-free experience Disclosure: Neowin benefits from revenue of each sale made through our branded deals site powered by StackCommerce.
    • Passkeys: Think of them like a broken heart necklace. Imagine one of those heart necklaces that breaks into two matching pieces. One person keeps one half, and the other person keeps the other half. With passkeys, the website has one half, and you have the other half. If the website gets hacked and someone steals its half, that stolen piece is useless by itself. It cannot unlock your account without your matching half. This particular heart necklace is one of a kind, there is only one in existence. Your half of the necklace has to be stored somewhere. It might be stored on your phone, tablet, computer, security key, or a password manager that can sync it between all your devices. A security key is a small physical device that you keep with you, kind of like a house key, car key, or flash drive. I would not usually recommend a security key as the first option for the average person. For most people, it is easier to use their phone, computer, or a password manager that can sync passkeys between their devices. A security key is more like a spare key you keep in a safe place, just in case you lose access to your other devices or your password manager. Some security keys plug into your computer. Some plug into your phone or tablet. Some get tapped against your device. The idea is simple: a security key can hold another passkey for the same website. Think of it like creating a second one-of-a-kind heart necklace for the same account. One necklace could be paired with your password manager, while another necklace could be paired with your security key. That means the website has more than one matching half on file. One half matches the passkey in your password manager. Another half matches the passkey stored on your security key. So, if you lose access to your phone, computer, or password manager, you would still be able to log in using the passkey stored on your security key. Think of it like keeping an extra special necklace piece on a tiny keychain, stored somewhere safe. The website still has the matching half for that security key, but your half is safely stored inside the little key. A passkey does not automatically exist on every device you own. It lives wherever you save it. If your half is stored on one device, then that device is the one that has the matching piece. For example, if you create the passkey on your Windows computer and it is only saved to that computer, your iPhone does not automatically have that same half. If you create it on your iPhone and it only stays on that iPhone, your Android phone does not automatically have it either. That is where password managers come in. A password manager can act like a protected jewelry box for your passkeys. Instead of your half of the necklace being locked to only one device, the password manager can securely sync that half to your other approved devices. For example, Apple Passwords and iCloud Keychain can sync passkeys between your Apple devices. Google Password Manager can sync passkeys with your Google account. But password managers such as 1Password and Bitwarden can sync passkeys between everything, your phones, tablets and computers. Now, you might ask: “What happens if I lose access to the device that has my passkey?” That depends on where your passkey was saved and what recovery options the website gives you. If your passkey was synced through a password manager, you may be able to sign in from another device that has access to that same password manager. For example, if your passkey is saved in iCloud Keychain, Google Password Manager, 1Password, or Bitwarden, another approved device may still have access to it. If your passkey was saved only on one phone, computer, or security key, and you lose that device, then you may not have your half of the necklace anymore. In that case, you would usually need to use the website’s backup login or account recovery options. A lot of websites that support passkeys still let you fall back to your regular password. So if you lose access to your passkey, the site may still let you log in with your password, a code sent to your email, a text message, a recovery code, or some other account recovery process. That is convenient, but it is also important to understand: if the website still allows password login, then your password still matters. Passkeys are safer than passwords, but if your account still has a password as a backup, you should still use a strong, unique password and turn on two-factor authentication if the website offers it. This is why it is a good idea to have more than one safe way back into important accounts. For example, you might keep your passkey in a syncing password manager, add a second trusted device, save recovery codes somewhere safe, or set up a backup security key. A passkey is very secure, but just like a real key, you need a backup plan in case you lose access to it. Now, you might ask: “What stops a hacker from copying my half of the necklace?” That’s the important part: your half is protected. It is not something you type in, and it is not something the website gets to keep. Think of your half as being locked inside a tiny safe on your phone, computer, security key, or password manager. That safe only opens when you approve it with your fingerprint, face, PIN, or device password. When you log in, the website does not need to see your half. It only needs proof that your half matches its half. Your actual half is not handed over to the website. This is different from a password. With a password, you type the secret into the website. If you type it into a fake website, the hacker now has it. With a passkey, you are not typing your secret into the website. Your device is proving you have the matching half without giving the half away. That also helps protect you from fake websites. If someone makes a fake login page that looks like the real site, your device can tell it is not the real match. It will not use your passkey there. Now, could someone use your passkey if they stole your device, got into your password manager, or somehow unlocked the safe that holds your half? Yes, that is why your device password, PIN, fingerprint, face unlock, and password manager security still matter. But a hacker cannot just steal your passkey from the website or trick you into typing it into a fake page like they can with a password. That is why passkeys are safer than passwords. The two matching pieces have to come together, like two lovebirds who were once separated and are finally reunited.
    • Newegg offers insane combo deal on Amazon Prime Day 2026 that beats Steam Machine by Sayan Sen Building a PC is undoubtedly difficult nowadays but with this epic combo deal, Newegg is trying to make it as easy for you as it is possible. If you are making a new one or even upgrading an old system to a new Windows 11 device, this combo bundle is truly unmissable as you get AMD's Ryzen 9800X3D, a compatible X870 motherboard, a 240mm AIO liquid cooler and finally a Samsung 990 PRO SSD all for under $1000 (purchase link under the specs table down below). This should beat out the newly launched Steam Machine from Valve in terms of performance and performance per dollar especially if you are willing to set Linux up on it. Essentially with this combo you will get the AMD Ryzen 7 9800X3D 8-core 3D V cache CPU, Samsung's 990 PRO 2TB NVMe SSD, the MSI MAG X870 TOMAHAWK WIFI ATX Motherboard, and finally the Cooler Master Elite Liquid 240. Thanks to that massive vertically stacked L3 cache, the X3D desktop processors, including the 9800X3D, also come with the benefit of not needing fast memory. Even DDR5-5600 should be plenty for it. The technical specifications of the Ryzen 7 9800X3D are given in the table below: Specification Value Architecture Zen 5 Cores / Threads 8 / 16 Base Clock 4.7 GHz Max Boost Clock Up to 5.2 GHz L1 Cache 640 KB L2 Cache 8 MB L3 Cache 96 MB Total Cache 104 MB CPU Core Process TSMC 4nm FinFET I/O Die Process TSMC 6nm FinFET Socket AM5 Default TDP 120W Max Temperature (Tjmax) 95°C Thermal Solution Not included Memory Type DDR5 Max Capacity 256 GB Memory Speeds 2x1R: DDR5-5600 2x2R: DDR5-5600 4x1R: DDR5-3600 4x2R: DDR5-3600 PCIe Version PCIe 5.0 PCIe Lanes (Total/Usable) 28 / 24 USB 3.2 Gen 2 (10Gbps) 4 USB 2.0 1 Graphics Cores 2 CU RDNA 2 Frequency 2200 MHz DisplayPort over USB-C Yes Overclocking Unlocked Up next we have the tech specs for the MSI MAG X870 TOMAHAWK WIFI Motherboard: Specification Value Chipset AMD X870 CPU Support AMD Ryzen 9000 / 8000 / 7000 Series Desktop Processors Socket AM5 Memory Slots 4 × DDR5 UDIMM Maximum Memory Capacity 256GB Memory Support DDR5 8400–5600 MT/s (OC), DDR5 5600–4800 MT/s (JEDEC) Integrated Graphics Outputs 1 × HDMI 2.1 FRL (up to 8K 60Hz) 2 × USB4 Type-C with DisplayPort 1.4 HBR3 (up to 4K 60Hz) Expansion Slots PCI_E1: PCIe 5.0 x16 (CPU) PCI_E2: PCIe 3.0 x1 (Chipset) PCI_E3: PCIe 4.0 x4 (Chipset) Audio Realtek ALC4080 Codec 7.1-Channel USB High Performance Audio Supports up to 32-bit/384kHz playback on front panel S/PDIF output M.2 Slots 4 × M.2 M2_1: PCIe 5.0 x4 (CPU, 22110/2280) M2_2: PCIe 5.0 x4 (CPU, 2280/2260) M2_3: PCIe 4.0 x2 (Chipset, 2280/2260) M2_4: PCIe 4.0 x4 (Chipset, 2280/2260) SATA Ports 4 × SATA 6Gb/s RAID Support RAID 0, 1, 5, 10 for M.2 NVMe storage devices Rear USB Ports 4 × USB 2.0 3 × USB 5Gbps Type-A 2 × USB 10Gbps Type-A 1 × USB 10Gbps Type-C 2 × USB4 40Gbps Type-C Front USB Headers 4 × USB 2.0 4 × USB 5Gbps Type-A 1 × USB 20Gbps Type-C LAN Realtek 8126-CG 5G LAN Wireless Wi-Fi 7 (M.2 Key-E module pre-installed) Supports 2.4GHz / 5GHz / 6GHz bands Up to 5.8Gbps Supports 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac/ax/be Bluetooth Bluetooth 5.4, MLO, 4KQAM Internal Power Connectors 1 × 24-pin ATX Power 2 × CPU Power Connectors 1 × PCIe 8-pin Power Connector Fan Headers 1 × CPU Fan 1 × Combo Fan (Pump/System) 6 × System Fan RGB Headers 3 × Addressable V2 RGB (JARGB_V2) 1 × RGB LED (JRGB) Other Internal Headers 1 × EZ Conn-header 2 × Front Panel Headers 1 × Chassis Intrusion 1 × Front Audio 1 × TPM 2.0 Header Debug Features 4 × EZ Debug LEDs 1 × EZ Digit Debug LED Rear I/O Ports Clear CMOS Button Flash BIOS Button HDMI 2 × USB 40Gbps Type-C 1 × USB 10Gbps Type-C 4 × USB 10Gbps Type-A 3 × USB 5Gbps Type-A 4 × USB 2.0 5G LAN Port Wi-Fi/Bluetooth Antenna Connectors Audio Connectors Form Factor ATX The Samsung 990 PRO is a PCIe Gen4 NVMe SSD and still one of the fastest drives available today for under $500. Speaking of fast, sequential reads and writes are rated at 7450 MB/s and 6900 MB/s, respectively. The random throughputs for reads and writes are 1400K IOPS and 1550K IOPS, respectively. The 990 PRO is based on Samsung's 7th Gen V-NAND flash, and it too is TLC. It packs 2 gigs of LPDDR4 DRAM cache, which helps the random performance. The endurance rating for this is 1200 TBW (terabytes written), which should be sufficient for most users. The Samsung 990 PRO is compatible with the PlayStation 5, but if you are going to use the 990 PRO on a PC, check out the Samsung Magician app that lets you track your drive's health, update its firmware, customize various settings, and more. The tech specs are given below: Specification Value Interface PCIe Gen 4.0 x4, NVMe 2.0 Form Factor M.2 2280 Controller Samsung In-house Controller NAND Flash 3D TLC DRAM Cache 2GB LPDDR4 Sequential Read (Max) 7,450 MB/s Sequential Write (Max) 6,900 MB/s Random Read (4K) Up to 1,400,000 IOPS Random Write (4K) Up to 1,550,000 IOPS TBW (Endurance) 1,200 TBW MTBF 1,500,000 hours Operating Temperature 0°C to 70°C Storage Temperature -40°C to 85°C Shock Resistance 1,500G / 0.5ms Heatsink No Get the combo deal at this link: AMD Ryzen 7 9800X3D, Samsung 990 PRO 2TB, MSI MAG X870 TOMAHAWK WIFI motherboard, Cooler Master Elite Liquid 240: $784.99 + $25 off with promo code FTTF77: $759.99 (Sold and Shipped by Newegg US) Good to know This Newegg deal is U.S. specific, and not available in other regions unless specified. We only use first-party seller links (at the time of article publishing); ensure that you purchase from a first-party seller link only. Check out Today's Deals on Amazon | or our recent tech deals. Become a Prime member (for Students or SNAP) via Neowin Get Prime Access - Prime for half price (for qualifying Medicaid, EBT, SNAP) Subscribe to Prime Video, Audible Plus, Music Unlimited or Kindle Unlimited via Neowin As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
    • I heard from a lot of people that driver support for the latest games when RDNA first came out (Radeon 5000 series) was pretty bad, but if you didn't buy the card on day one, or were not trying to play the latest titles, then you were isolated from that issue. Other than that, it's been good and only getting better.
  • Recent Achievements

    • One Month Later
      timbobit earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • One Month Later
      nates earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      Almohandis earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Rookie
      dorf went up a rank
      Rookie
    • First Post
      mike_rumble earned a badge
      First Post
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      469
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      165
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      104
    4. 4
      Michael Scrip
      87
    5. 5
      Steven P.
      71
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!