Chkdsk bug in Windows 7 RTM Build 7600.16385/16399


Recommended Posts

Well the appropriate guys at Microsoft have been notified of the issue, so rest assured that they are looking into it. But if it really is a driver issue, well, that's going to (rightfully) be the hardware vendor's responsibility.

No, not a showstopper. Kind of like the old Marx Brothers joke: "Doc, it hurts when I do this..."

"Then don't do that!"

I'm pretty sure I can go a day or two without running chkdsk until a patch is applied.

BTW, is this present in both x86 and x64?

This issue is present on non-Patched 7600.16385 and Patched 7600.16399 builds, also on Windows Server 2008 R2, both x86 and x64. My big concern if you read the main post now it is also present when booting from the DVD in WinPE where majority of the IT/PC Repair Industry would go to fix a clients computer.

Well, the appropriate guys at Microsoft have been notified of the issue, so rest assured that they are looking into it. But, if it really is a driver issue, well, that's going to (rightfully) be the hardware vendor's responsibility.

Based on my finding that it is also present when booting directly from the DVD I would say chipset driver issue or not this should not have happened. Also, if it is a chipset drive issue... Why do all 3 of my computers that have Vista on it with the same drivers work fine using chkdsk yet Windows 7 has such a problem?

This is probably only a bug if the BSOD happens, otherwise I'm sure while they were developing it they knew of the huge memory consumption.

The /r command option says the disk must be locked, so maybe you were running a programming that tried anyways and poof

This is probably only a bug if the BSOD happens, otherwise I'm sure while they were developing it they knew of the huge memory consumption.

The /r command option says the disk must be locked, so maybe you were running a programming that tried anyways and poof

Nope, when the disk is dismounted all handles trying to access it are closed, essentially the thread is just killed off. Besides, that would cause high memory usage in the process trying to access the disk, not chkdsk itself

The /r command option says the disk must be locked, so maybe you were running a programming that tried anyways and poof

Yeah - as Frank Fontaine says, not applicable. I created a brand new 24GB volume in my VMware 'session', copied some random data to it (SQL Server 2008 installer) then dismounted the DVD image and ran the chkdsk. Nothing would have been using that data, but it still insisted on clearing any locks to the filesystem before it attempted to run the check.

I'm not sure it is a bug.. I'm running it now and it definitely didn't cause a BSOD.

All of my ram is not being used.. I'm hovering at 80% ram usage.. so the fact that it doesn't take up all of your available memory would seem to indicate that it stops short intentionally.

I'm willing to lay money on it being some kind of bug. Why would the behaviour of the application change so drastically and with no discernable benefit (quite the opposite!) between Vista and Windows 7?!

This seems kinda odd, why only with the /r command? And if it was a true memory leak you'd keep losing all your memory, I don't think it'd stop at some point/percent. And you wouldn't get it back if you close the app either would you? Don't memory leaks just take it all and never give it back even after, so you have to restart to get it free? That's how I always understood it.

I'm willing to lay money on it being some kind of bug. Why would the behaviour of the application change so drastically and with no discernable benefit (quite the opposite!) between Vista and Windows 7?!

I'd agree, it is definitely a bug. There is no plausible reason that I could come up with for it using so much memory. For anyone advocating it loading data into memory for performance reasons, just think about it for a second... the /r switch is used to check for bad sectors, a check which would be pointless and invalid if the data where preloaded into memory

Some more interesting info at another forum which, for some reason, Neowin won't let me link to (edits the url to include << spam >> tags!) - anyway, the guy posted this:

chkdsk /f seems to use 5MB of memory (at peak) for every 1GB of disk space you check (tested on a couple drives - example: a drive with 300GB of data uses 1.5GB of RAM

chkdsk /r seems to use memory equal to the amount of files on the disk. If I put 2.5GB of files on my USB flash drive and use chkdsk /r, it uses 2.5GB of memory by the end of stage 4 (though it stops increasing when you hit stage 5)

He also confirms that this only seems to occur on NTFS (not FAT) and that this appears to be a 64bit only bug...?

Surprisingly build 7600.16399 is faster than 7600.16385 on cpu operations. Confirmed with faster boot and playing a "heavy" cpu game. As for bugs, I still can drag the locked taskbar to the top by performing this: first, right click on any taskbar icon to open the jumplist then drag the taskbar up a little and it will move to the top. Another bug is when the taskbar is on top, if you do right click, the jumplist will have incorrect top position, but if you drag the jumplist, the top position limit will be the right one.

Heres a couple things I found sad.

1. Those 399 build updates are not official, unless its on Microsoft update or a official announcement is made, I'm not touching them.

2. Microsoft hasn't even mentioned anything about this officially yet.

3. According to Microsoft the RTM build is still coming to MSDNAA today, no mention of a show stopper or recompile etc.

4. This is not a chipset issue, chkdsk uses too much memory. And the 399 unofficial fixes do not fix it. When something is broken on all versions of different hardware, its not the hardware's fault, its the software.

Heres a couple things I found sad.

1. Those 399 build updates are not official, unless its on Microsoft update or a official announcement is made, I'm not touching them.

2. Microsoft hasn't even mentioned anything about this officially yet.

3. According to Microsoft the RTM build is still coming to MSDNAA today, no mention of a show stopper or recompile etc.

4. This is not a chipset issue, chkdsk uses too much memory. And the 399 unofficial fixes do not fix it. When something is broken on all versions of different hardware, its not the hardware's fault, its the software.

1. They are. Never heard of an unofficial hotfix from MS.

2. Not publicly. Why would they? They could potentially harm their sales by going "There's a big bug in our final product."

3. Of course not. Again, why would they? Not everyone has the issue.

4. It has been proven.

Has anyone been able to post this on Microsoft Connect? They dont have a public channel for Windows 7? This should be resolved as soon as possible!

Connect is closed to bug submissions now for Windows 7.... have to get to MS other ways now, anything that goes to connect wil get to no one

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Microsoft making much needed change to Windows 11, 10 Patch Tuesday security updates by Sayan Sen Recently, Microsoft delivered its latest Defender patches for Windows 11 ISOs. These definitions are released from time to time alongside the general security updates available during Patch Tuesday. Speaking of Defender, the company has now announced another important change that affects how security updates are delivered to enterprise devices running Windows. According to a recent announcement, Microsoft Defender for Endpoint's endpoint detection and response (EDR) updates will no longer be bundled with the monthly Windows security updates or Patch Tuesdays. Instead the company is shifting delivery of these updates to Microsoft Update, bringing EDR servicing in line with several other Microsoft Defender components. If you recall, Microsoft last year moved PowerShell updates to Microsoft Update (MU) as well since it provides automatic updates for Microsoft products and services. Thus the move is intended to allow Microsoft to deliver EDR improvements and security enhancements independently of the OS's regular monthly update cycle; this should enable faster deployment of protection updates without requiring organizations to wait for the next Patch release. For those unfamiliar, Microsoft Defender for Endpoint's EDR capabilities are designed to help organizations detect, investigate, and respond to advanced threats across managed devices. Keeping these components updated is critical for maintaining protection against evolving attack techniques. The rollout has already began for Windows 10 devices in late May 2026 (last month) and Microsoft says it will gradually expand support to Windows 11 and the remaining supported Windows versions over the coming months. The company expects deployment across Windows 10 and Windows 11 to be completed by fall 2026 or around Q3 of this year. Once the transition is complete, EDR updates will be delivered through Microsoft Update using KB5005292, provided the required prerequisite updates have already been installed. Microsoft is also introducing a new Defender Update Service as part of the change. Following installation of the first update, devices will automatically create a new directory located at %ProgramData%\Microsoft\Microsoft Defender\Defender Update. Microsoft notes that restarts may occasionally be necessary in case of "rare" failure scenarios. For most organizations, the tech giant says no action will be required as long as Microsoft Update is already permitted within their update management strategy. Admins who rely on manually deployed update packages, however, will need to adjust their processes to ensure the new Defender update package is included. Microsoft also recommends reviewing internal documentation and notifying helpdesk and security operations teams about the updated delivery mechanism to avoid confusion during the transition. As a prerequisite, the tech giant notes that systems must be running Sense version 10.8798.25857.1000 or later and have one of the following Windows updates (or later) installed: Win11 24H2 KB5062660 (2025-07 Cumulative Update Preview) Win11 23H2 KB5062663 (2025-07 Cumulative Update Preview) Win11 22H2 KB5062663 (2025-07 Cumulative Update Preview) Win10 22H2 KB5062649 (2025-07 Cumulative Update Preview) Win10 1809 KB5063877 (2025-08 Cumulative Update) Server 2019 KB5063877 (2025-08 Cumulative Update) Server 2022 KB5063880 (2025-08 Cumulative Update) Server 2025 KB5063878 (2025-08 Cumulative Update) As always, organizations should verify that their update policies align with the new servicing approach before the broader rollout reaches all supported Windows platforms later this year. In case of major problems, the EDR update can be rolled back to the inbox version stored in %ProgramFiles%\\Windows Defender Advanced Threat Protection (ATP) using: MpCmdRun.exe -RevertMde -Product Edr -ToVersion Inbox For those who have access to the Microsoft 365 Admin Center portal, you can view the message here under ID MC1381119.
    • My problem with these smart scopes is that IMO they're not really an entrance into astronomy, they're an entrance to looking at pretty(ish) pictures that you take by essentially pressing a button and letting the scope do the work. I still maintain that getting some binoculars or a solid dedicated telescope (which doesn't have to mean expensive) and actually spending time learning the night sky and using a telescope is a much better way to actually learn. But, granted, the learning curve is a bit steeper (as it tends to be).
    • I never played Crazy Taxi before, but this looks like a fun game!
    • The perception of Microsoft Edge is unfortunate as it's a world class browser. I'm not exaggerating when I say it's the best browser I've ever used with its feature set, speed, reliability and advanced security. Running the extension Ublock Origin is a must though to deal with advertising and trackers.
    • You can check out our latest 9070 GRE review with scores for the XT too, but these are on Windows: Gaming performance Productivity performance
  • Recent Achievements

    • One Month Later
      DJC50PLUS earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      DJC50PLUS earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Proficient
      Eric Biran went up a rank
      Proficient
    • Dedicated
      Conjor earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • Week One Done
      Windows Guy earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      493
    2. 2
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      248
    3. 3
      Steven P.
      73
    4. 4
      +Edouard
      69
    5. 5
      neufuse
      68
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!