Ad free subscriber group to be implemented

By Steven P.
in Site Announcements

 Share

Recommended Posts

Grand Master

+LogicalApex MVC

Posted
  • MVC
Posted
I don't care about the badges and how we look. It is my opinion that they should have done the same features (adfree, no post timer, blog etc) for all subscriber tiers rather than just the most expensive one. That way you'd give an incentive to those who block the ads anyway to pay at least the smallest amount to contribute something.

What you're saying doesn't make much sense. Those who block the ads now, using software, aren't going to convert en masse. Much like a software pirate, you can never expect to convert every pirate into a paying customer.

With that being said, this isn't aimed at converting large numbers of those pirates to an AD free neowin. This plan is designed so that those users who do like NeoWin and don't like ADs can be given an option to remove the ADs without resorting to joining the pirates. So, the Tiers SHOULD be different so that the costs to NeoWin is properly reflected.

Otherwise, why should NeoWin eat the cost of forgoing AD revenue on the lower tier? That cost them the same as letting the pirate pirate (they are forced to eat that cost too)...

Hopefully that makes it all clearer for you ;)

Grand Master

Vice

Posted
Posted

Technically its not Piracy cause that would mean your stealing something or copying something but the Ad Blocker users are just rejecting something being given to them.

I mean you could make the argument that users are Stealing content, but the content is free to view and no one entered in to a contract. It's like a shop keeper throwing free candy bars at people and then telling them they are stealing if they reject the candy bars on the grounds of the energy expenditure in throwing it at you.

Not that I'm condoning Ad Blocking or anything I don't use one myself. I'm seeing some Experian Credit Report ad at the bottom of this topic actually. It's FREE! apparently.

Grand Master

+LogicalApex MVC

Posted
  • MVC
Posted
Technically its not Piracy cause that would mean your stealing something or copying something but the Ad Blocker users are just rejecting something being given to them.

I mean you could make the argument that users are Stealing content, but the content is free to view and no one entered in to a contract. It's like a shop keeper throwing free candy bars at people and then telling them they are stealing if they reject the candy bars on the grounds of the energy expenditure in throwing it at you.

Not that I'm condoning Ad Blocking or anything I don't use one myself. I'm seeing some Experian Credit Report ad at the bottom of this topic actually. It's FREE! apparently.

No it actually is piracy... The content on NeoWin is copyright material owned by NeoWin which is being offered to the viewers free as long as they see the ads... It is the same as if you downloaded an AD supported game for free then used a tool to strip the ADs out. That would be piracy. As the ADs are what paid for the game and is apart of the agreement between you and the content creator.

...

The unauthorized use or reproduction of copyrighted or patented material: software piracy.

...

http://www.answers.com/piracy

Unless NeoWin authorizes the use of AD Blocking software it is piracy...

Proficient

d4v1d05

Posted
Posted
No it actually is piracy... The content on NeoWin is copyright material owned by NeoWin which is being offered to the viewers free as long as they see the ads... It is the same as if you downloaded an AD supported game for free then used a tool to strip the ADs out. That would be piracy. As the ADs are what paid for the game and is apart of the agreement between you and the content creator.

Unless NeoWin authorizes the use of AD Blocking software it is piracy...

You need to learn the definition of piracy a bit better...

1. The act or crime of a pirate.

2. (Common Law) Robbery on the high seas; the taking of property from others on the open sea by open violence; without lawful authority, and with intent to steal; -- a crime answering to robbery on land.

Note: By statute law several other offenses committed on the seas (as trading with known pirates, or engaging in the slave trade) have been made piracy.

3. "Sometimes used, in a quasi-figurative sense, of violation of copyright; but for this, infringement is the correct and preferable term." --Abbott.

Pay close attention to #1 and #2... those are the real definitions of piracy, the "piracy" music companies and stuff are talking about is actually copyright theft... NOT piracy...

What you're actually talking about is circumventing the adverts within a game, however, by using an ad-blocker online, most likely you are merely NOT making requests to ad servers specified by a blacklist, the same as if a company decides to block specific porn/etc. websites, which by your definition, blocking access to those is piracy, too? Some adblockers will, however change HTML code within the site, and since HTML is distributed under a free license, all HTML-derivatives must be under the same license(I think?) therefore the user is allowed to modify the HTML to allow them to block adverts...

And, before you ask, no I don't use an ad-blocker... I look forward to subscribing to the new ad-free group :)

Grand Master

Wannes

Posted
Posted
I know we're not allowed to talk about ad-blockers, but uh...this is going to fail miserably.

I don't use an ad-blocker and yet, I'm still going to buy the package. It's just to support the site. The ads shouldn't bother anyone because they are placed very discrete.

Grand Master

+LogicalApex MVC

Posted
  • MVC
Posted
You need to learn the definition of piracy a bit better...

Pay close attention to #1 and #2... those are the real definitions of piracy, the "piracy" music companies and stuff are talking about is actually copyright theft... NOT piracy...

You have to remember language is fluid and constantly in change. 200 years ago Piracy meant theft on the high seas and now it also means digital theft. Language changes. I can think of countless terms that meant one thing in the past and means another now. It doesn't make the new meaning wrong because it differs. That is how language works. It updates itself to reflect society at that time.

What you're actually talking about is circumventing the adverts within a game, however, by using an ad-blocker online, most likely you are merely NOT making requests to ad servers specified by a blacklist, the same as if a company decides to block specific porn/etc. websites, which by your definition, blocking access to those is piracy, too? Some adblockers will, however change HTML code within the site, and since HTML is distributed under a free license, all HTML-derivatives must be under the same license(I think?) therefore the user is allowed to modify the HTML to allow them to block adverts...

And, before you ask, no I don't use an ad-blocker... I look forward to subscribing to the new ad-free group :)

No, HTML is protected by the same copyright laws that software is. You are not free to do what you want to HTML as it is not given to you under some public domain licence. Installing a crack modifies the program code which is just like modifying the HTML of a web page.

No need to split hairs here...

Veteran

+Chsoriano Subscriber²

Posted
  • Subscriber²
Posted

How are new subscriptions going to be handled? I have a subscription but it doesn't expire until August. If I pay for another year (at tier 2), am I going to have to wait until August until the ad-free subscription kicks in? Would there be a way to upgrade without letting the current subscription fees already paid go to waste?

Grand Master

Vice

Posted
Posted
You have to remember language is fluid and constantly in change. 200 years ago Piracy meant theft on the high seas and now it also means digital theft. Language changes. I can think of countless terms that meant one thing in the past and means another now. It doesn't make the new meaning wrong because it differs. That is how language works. It updates itself to reflect society at that time.

No, HTML is protected by the same copyright laws that software is. You are not free to do what you want to HTML as it is not given to you under some public domain licence. Installing a crack modifies the program code which is just like modifying the HTML of a web page.

No need to split hairs here...

Your not really modifying it though you are just choosing to not process parts of it that retrieve content from Ad serving domains. Like choosing not to read words in a book. That isn't piracy.

And technically the HTML pages are just plain Code, however your Browser chooses to interoperate that code and how its renderer may be modified in-memory by 3rd party plugins doesn't mean you are modifying the HTML itself ergo no modifications are made. The HTML pages themselves are not modified nor are modified versions ever saved or distributed. The key words here being never modified at all in any shape or form simply the renderer of the browser is manipulated to ignore parts of the code and render other things in the place of other parts (Again without modification of the actual HTML code).

The most important thing to remember is. You cant steal something that is being given to you for Free. We as users do not pay for this content it's completely 100% free (And generated by us may I add). It is the Advertising companies that Pay Neowin. The Contract between the Advertisers and Neowin is a separate entity to users viewing the Content on the Neowin servers. No agreements, no Terms of Service for simply viewing the site.

Grand Master

Veedems Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted
How are new subscriptions going to be handled? I have a subscription but it doesn't expire until August. If I pay for another year (at tier 2), am I going to have to wait until August until the ad-free subscription kicks in? Would there be a way to upgrade without letting the current subscription fees already paid go to waste?

I believe the plans are to offer an upgrade, yes.

Grand Master

Denis W. Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted
We'd have to add N versions for Europe too :p

And while we're at it, Starter Edition for countries with 56k connections and a K version for Korea. ;)

Proficient

d4v1d05

Posted
Posted
You have to remember language is fluid and constantly in change. 200 years ago Piracy meant theft on the high seas and now it also means digital theft. Language changes. I can think of countless terms that meant one thing in the past and means another now. It doesn't make the new meaning wrong because it differs. That is how language works. It updates itself to reflect society at that time.

No, HTML is protected by the same copyright laws that software is. You are not free to do what you want to HTML as it is not given to you under some public domain licence. Installing a crack modifies the program code which is just like modifying the HTML of a web page.

No need to split hairs here...

Ok, so let's say I modify my hosts file to send requests to pagead2.googlesyndication.com to 127.0.0.1 instead of the NS entry for that domain. By doing this, I am essentially blocking adverts hosted by google from appearing on the website. By your definition, in doing this, I am actually committing piracy (copyright theft?) which means that I am stealing someone's copyright by not requesting the adverts? This makes no sense... It's like buy one get one free at a supermarket, if you refuse the free one, you're not going to be accused of shoplifting or theft are you?

Never mind, you keep it in your precious little mind that this is copyright theft...

And NO, I don't use ad blocking software, or host-based ad blocking, I just get ads as they are, hence looking forward to the last of the intellitxt adverts!

Grand Master

+LogicalApex MVC

Posted
  • MVC
Posted
Ok, so let's say I modify my hosts file to send requests to pagead2.googlesyndication.com to 127.0.0.1 instead of the NS entry for that domain. By doing this, I am essentially blocking adverts hosted by google from appearing on the website. By your definition, in doing this, I am actually committing piracy (copyright theft?) which means that I am stealing someone's copyright by not requesting the adverts? This makes no sense... It's like buy one get one free at a supermarket, if you refuse the free one, you're not going to be accused of shoplifting or theft are you?

Never mind, you keep it in your precious little mind that this is copyright theft...

And NO, I don't use ad blocking software, or host-based ad blocking, I just get ads as they are, hence looking forward to the last of the intellitxt adverts!

You're mixing apples and oranges here... In the Supermarket you're not committing theft because although you're turning down the free item you are still paying for the item you do accept... Also, copyright material is not given to you to own when you access or pay for it, unlike a physical good. So just because you download the text of a website you're not free to do whatever you want with it, much like you are with a pack of hot dogs.

I can't buy a copy of the New York Times and start publishing my own copy of it with all the text they put into it just because I paid for it. In order to get the legal right to modify the text I have to create something substantially different that can be classified as a derivative work.

All of this is out of context, I think.

By modifying a website's code soley to remove ads you are stealing, and thus a pirate. You are robbing the site of its revenue stream that it is using to provide you the content. In essence, you are walking into the theater to enjoy the movie without paying for your ticket. That doesn't matter if you pay for the ticket out of your pocket or the bank down the street does because you opened an account. The digital form of that theft is referred to as piracy.

Just because something can be easily done doesn't make it legal. You can easily dump all your garbage on someone's property in the area where you live and most likely not get caught, but that doesn't mean it isn't a violation of public dumping laws.

I never said you use Ad Blocking software, and I don't care for the most part, but it is still piracy. As, from the definition I linked to earlier, which is from an accepted Dictionary; The American Heritage Dictionary, digital theft is piracy.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Posts

    • The quantum search for Time's origin had an equally mind-boggling conclusion

      By Taliseian · Posted

      It's all wibbly-wobbly, timey-wimey....stuff.
    • Flameshot 14.0 Final

      By Copernic · Posted

      Flameshot 14.0 Final by Razvan Serea Flameshot is a free and open-source, cross-platform tool to take screenshots with many built-in features to save you time. Using Flameshot is as simple as launching, dragging the selection box to cover the area you want to capture, making annotations as needed in on-screen and saving the shot to your computer, all with a very simple and straightforward interface. Flameshot allows users to simply upload their screenshots directly to the cloud in order to easily share it with others. You can upload your image directly to Imgur with a single click and share the URL with others. In-app screenshot editing - You can choose to add an arrow mark, highlight text, blur a section (blur or pixelate an area), add a text, draw something, add a rectangular/circular shaped border, add an incrementing counter number, and add a solid color box with Flameshot's built-in editing tools. Command-line interface (CLI) - Flameshot has several commands you can use in the terminal without launching the GUI via a command line interface. The command line interface lets you script Flameshot and use it as the subject of key binds. Flameshot 14.0 release notes: This release brings major improvements to multi-monitor support, fractional scaling support, new capture workflows, and a long list of bug fixes across all platforms. Changelog: New Multi-Monitor Capture Workflow New monitor selection screen before capture for better multi-monitor and mixed-scaling support. Option to auto-capture the monitor under the cursor (X11 & Windows). Tray menu can directly select a monitor. Linux Improvements XDG Desktop Portal is now the primary screenshot method. Added legacy X11 fallback option for minimal window managers. New D-Bus capture API for scripting and automation. Windows Enhancements Global screenshot hotkeys now supported (not limited to Print Screen). New portable mode stores settings next to the executable. Clipboard now always uses PNG format for better compatibility. CLI & Platform Updates Redesigned flameshot screen command with per-monitor capture support. Added native Nix Flake support. More compact launcher UI and improved update notifications. Major Fixes Multiple Wayland stability fixes, including KDE Plasma crash fixes. Clipboard compatibility improvements for GNOME, Wayland, X11, Windows, and macOS. Fixed D-Bus hangs, capture crashes, and HiDPI region issues. Other Changes Dropped Ubuntu 20.04 (Focal) support. Updated translations and build infrastructure. Intel macOS builds are no longer provided. [full release notes] Download: Flameshot 14.0 | 18.1 MB (Open Source) Download: Flameshot Portable | 53.0 MB Links: Flameshot Home Page | Screenshot Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • The quantum search for Time's origin had an equally mind-boggling conclusion

      By branfont · Posted

      Time, as we know it, was invented by Humans!
    • Politically funny images of the World

      By +Edouard · Posted

    • Helium Browser 0.13.4.1

      By Copernic · Posted

      Helium Browser 0.13.4.1 by Razvan Serea Helium is a private, fast, and honest Chromium-based web browser — built for people, with love. It offers the best privacy by default, unbiased ad-blocking, and a clean experience free from bloat and noise. Proudly based on Ungoogled-Chromium, Helium removes Google’s clutter while keeping a fast, efficient development pipeline. With thoughtful touches like native !bangs and split view, Helium is a people-first, fully open-source browser that puts control back in your hands. Privacy, security, and control come first. Ads, trackers, and third-party cookies are blocked automatically, HTTPS is enforced everywhere, and all Chromium extensions work seamlessly — while Google can’t track your activity. Helium’s 13,000+ offline-ready !bangs let you jump straight to sites or AI tools like ChatGPT instantly. Open-source, people-first, and unbiased, Helium delivers a browsing experience that’s fast, secure, and free from noise, ads, and compromises. Helium Browser key features: Performance Fast, efficient, and lightweight — built on Chromium’s optimized engine. Energy-saving and consistent — stays fast over time without slowing down. No bloat — stripped of unnecessary components for maximum speed. Minimalist interface — compact, clean, and distraction-free. Customizable toolbar — hide elements you don’t need. Smooth and stable — no flicker, lag, or animation glitches. Comfort-focused experience — intuitive and unobtrusive. Privacy & Security Best privacy by default — blocks ads, trackers, phishing, and third-party cookies. Unbiased ad-blocking — powered by community filters and uBlock Origin. No telemetry or analytics — zero background web requests on first launch. Strict HTTPS enforcement — warns for insecure sites. Passkeys supported — modern authentication made simple. No built-in password manager or cloud sync — your data stays yours. Extension Compatibility Full Chromium extension support — including MV2 extensions. Anonymized Chrome Web Store requests — Google can’t track extension installs. Extended MV2 support — maintained for as long as possible. Smart Features Native !bangs — browse faster using 13,000+ offline-ready shortcuts. AI integration — use !chatgpt and others directly from the address bar. Offline functionality — bangs work without an Internet connection. Philosophy People-first design — open source, transparent, and community-driven. No ads, no noise, no bias — privacy and honesty over profit. Helium Browser 0.13.4.1 changelog: 0a4f1149 revision: bump to 4 (#1969) 4848de1f helium/core: enable the chromium screenshot feature (#1968) e0dec3f5 onboarding: integrate strings to i18n system (#1948) 417fa5bc i18n: fix newline parsing for onboarding 7a339b39 i18n: add foraged translations for onboarding 4f090cff i18n/generate: add handling for onboarding strings bfe48d58 i18n_apply: manually override parent grd logic for onboarding strings ab214e3c onboarding: bump in deps, wire up grdp afa6a059 helium/core: disable pdf infobar feature (#1965) eba585e7 helium/ui/vertical: fix new tab button alignment and icon size (#1964) 6ecfc9e0 helium/ui/tabs: fix horizontal tab hover background color (#1963) 3db87dc0 helium/ui/tabs: fix new tab button hover/press colors (#1962) 6bbdcc3e helium/ui: improve tab group UI in all layouts (#1961) 53deb314 helium/ui/tabs: enable tab group hover cards e93aece7 helium/ui/vertical: fix tab group appearance, prevent line overlap 629f5495 helium/ui/tabs: restore solid group header colors, enable new colors 961c962e helium/ui/tabs: move horiz tab group underline to bottom, make it thick c96deab6 merge: update to chromium 149.0.7827.155 (#1959) 36db56b4 i18n: update source.gen.json 5ce006ae patches: refresh for chromium 149.0.7827.155 b4c1ea62 merge: update ungoogled-chromium to 149.0.7827.155 4e5e8671 Update to Chromium 149.0.7827.155 08a3e7da helium/ui/layout: disable mute on collapsed vertical tabs (#1778) a0a5bbaf helium/core: simplify context menu and prevent huge widths (#1951) c4732aac devutils/i18n: add forage command (#1944) 11d16986 devutils/i18n: add an option to translate using local CLI tools (#1942) d820c3a2 i18n/prompt: tighten translation rules to prevent common errors (#1940) cf827007 Update to Chromium 149.0.7827.114 6e3d5164 Update to Chromium 149.0.7827.102 Download: Helium 64-bit | Portable 64-bit |~100.0 MB (Open Source) Download: Helium ARM64 | Portable ARM64 Links: Helium Home Page | macOS | Linux | Screenshot Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware

  • Recent Achievements

    • Reacting Well
      BizSAR earned a badge
      Reacting Well
    • First Post
      AndreaB earned a badge
      First Post
    • Week One Done
      Huge Trailer earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Week One Done
      Classifyskilleducation earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Month Later
      eurospharma62 earned a badge
      One Month Later

  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      579
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      183
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      75
    4. 4
      Michael Scrip
      73
    5. 5
      neufuse
      64
    Show More

  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!